2011 Rd. 1 Lineup

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Not for me. Maybe if we were playing against a taller side. McKenzie is our 2nd best full back and our 2nd best centre-half back IMO.

As if. We totally decided on our KPD situation in the other thread. The consensus being that mckenzie and glass are locks. I am guessing you are trying to say that brown should be in the team over mckenzie because he is a better half back. And glass has the full back possie already taken. So even if mckenzie is the better all round KPD he should not get a game in front of brown as brown is better at the vacant position of half back. What if glass played back pocket? Leaving mckenzie to take full back and brown half back.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

As if we totally decided on all this on the other thread. Im guessing your saying brown comes in over mckenzie because mckenzie cant play Half back? And glass has the full back possie. What it glass played pocket?
Has anyone really been far even as decided to use even go want to do look more like?
 
FB: Smith - Glass - Waters
HB: Hurn - Brown - Butler
C: Rosa - Priddis - Sheppard
HF: Strijk - Kennedy - Ebert
FF: Hams - Wilson - LeCras

R: Naitanui - Shuey - S.Selwood
I: Mackenzie - Masten - Cox
S: Swift

After the weekend, didn't think I saw anything that I would change from the above team. Obviously, its looking less and less likely that Hams is available and more likely that Kerr is so thats the only direct swap in and out of the 22. Probably a few positional changes to fit that as well.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

As if. We totally decided on our KPD situation in the other thread. The consensus being that mckenzie and glass are locks. I am guessing you are trying to say that brown should be in the team over mckenzie because he is a better half back. And glass has the full back possie already taken. So even if mckenzie is the better all round KPD he should not get a game in front of brown as brown is better at the vacant position of half back. What if glass played back pocket? Leaving mckenzie to take full back and brown half back.

Hope you're being facetious. Just because the majority of people in that other thread shared an opinion doesn't mean no one else should have an opinion. Ridiculous post.
 
Hope you're being facetious. Just because the majority of people in that other thread shared an opinion doesn't mean no one else should have an opinion. Ridiculous post.

Yer i was. The whole point of BF is to talk/debate about footy. You need all sorts of opinions to encourage a good debate. Obviously the results of a poll on one thread of our board aint mean everyone should just conform to the opinions of the masses represented. Its for these reasons that i actually enjoy/encourage GM's presence. He is awesome at devils advocate.
 
waters glass butler
hurn brown sheppard
ebert swift stevens
strijk kennedy shuey
lecras darling naitanui

foll: cox kerr masten

int: s.selwood gaff rosa

sub: weedon

that's our best side IMO. probably too young and a tall short.
 
A hard choice trying to pick a team for round one. There are a lot of young players that could well be interchangable in the side. Also the question as to how we will use the sub is an interesting one.

I had a go, minus Kerr and Hams seeing as he is on the rookie list.

B: J.Jones Glass Butler
HB: Hurn Mackenzie Sheppard
C: Rosa Priddis Dalziell
HF: Waters Kennedy Strijk
F: Darling Wilson Lecras
Foll: Cox Masten Shuey
Inter: Natanui Stevens S.Selwood
Sub: Nicoski
 
A hard choice trying to pick a team for round one. There are a lot of young players that could well be interchangable in the side. Also the question as to how we will use the sub is an interesting one.

I had a go, minus Kerr and Hams seeing as he is on the rookie list.

B: J.Jones Glass Butler
HB: Hurn Mackenzie Sheppard
C: Rosa Priddis Dalziell
HF: Waters Kennedy Strijk
F: Darling Wilson Lecras
Foll: Cox Masten Shuey
Inter: Natanui Stevens S.Selwood
Sub: Nicoski

At the rate Swift is improving - I'D SAY HE WOULD HAVE TO BE IN.
If he gets his speed and zip back to late 2009 he will be like
p_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
 
At the rate Swift is improving - I'D SAY HE WOULD HAVE TO BE IN.
If he gets his speed and zip back to late 2009 he will be like
p_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

Oh I agree that Swift would be very close or already in the team. Another couple of showings like last weekend and he would be a shoe in definately.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top