The_Sherrin
Debutant
- Apr 3, 2012
- 115
- 14
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
I have seen Nambour play a few times and they look very good. Probably too good for the Div 3 comp. But you need to consider it in some context.
Granted, they won the flag last year, but they didn't win it as convincingly as you'd want to move up a division. You also need to remember that it is a weakened competition. The best two teams from 2010 were moved up into Div 2 so they were playing the equivalent of teams 3-10 in 2011 and 2012.
Look how other teams have gone in the past decade who have moved up.
Wynnum - convincing premierships (including undefeated) in 2002 and 2003, struggled for a couple of years before becoming a serious player in this division.
Robina - convincing premierships (including undefeated) in 2004 and 2005, struggled for a couple of years in the division up before dropping back a division and being above the standard again. Have come back up and are probably going to finish bottom 3 this year.
Kedron - premiership in 2007 and a top contender in subsequent seasons. Are really a bit of a joke at this level and will probably look to go back a division next year.
Kenmore - convincing undefeated premiership in 2006, made finals once (I think) since coming up in 2007. Have struggled in recent seasons, but will probably scrape into the five this season.
The above doesn't paint a pretty picture for teams moving up, even ones who were belting teams before they came up.
In saying that if Nambour continue smacking teams in the division below (percentage of 350% last time i checked), I'd say that they should definitely apply to move up in place of Kedron. They would beat a few of the lesser teams and would probably be tough to beat at home. Who really wants to travel to Nambour though?
The_Badger
Putting on my Wynnum Cap for a second
Wynnum Vikings Grand Finals Apperences in the past 10 yrs
2002 Lost Div 2
2003 Won DIv 2
2005 lost Div 1
2006 Lost Div1
2008 Won Div 1
2009 Won Div 1
2004 promoted First year in Div 1 only won 2 matches. 2005 Vikings went from wooden spooners to Grand Finialis in 1 season
Not bad for a team that "struggled" lol
Last week I went to the Coorparoo v Wynnum match, even though I don't like having a go at umps, but 1 out of the 2 umpires thought he was the 3rd team. My personal view, was that he ruined a good match. The Central Ump wasn't biased to either team, but when you have both teams constantly confused on his decesions making, let alone confusing the spectators, made it very frustrating game to watch. Back to div 3 ressies I would hope.
At the end of the day the right team won.