Teams 2013 Rate my SuperCoach Team

[BigGib]

What do you guys think of my team? I believe the rookie forwards are harder to come by this year than defenders and am considering replacing Atley with someone like Docherty and splitting Pav into someone like LeCras and Dustin Martin. What are your thoughts guys?

 

[Satan]

just did first team

goddard, h shaw, scotland , rivers,gilham, vlastuin (terlich frost)

ablett, pendles, gibbs, dangerfield, moloney, whitfield,wines, blivcas(omeara, viney)

kruezer, roughead hawthorn, (currie, hannath)

franklin, cox, le cras,mcaffer,varcoe, rowe (daniher,stringer)

14200 left

 

[Sosballs]

Hey Guys
If you could get me your thoughts it was be amazing

Backs. Goddard , Gibbs , lake , Rutten , M.Brown , B.Goodes pittard , Docherty

Mids. Ablest , dangerfield , Selwood J , Cotchin. Varcoe , Horlin-smith , Blicavs , Viney simpkin , Mitchell K

Rucks . Naitanui , Leuenberger rowe ,Daw

Forwards Franklin , Hawkins , Betts , LeCras , Koschitzke , Byrnes menzel D , Mayes

How can I fix any issues

Cheers everyone

 

[TheOz]

Hey Guys
If you could get me your thoughts it was be amazing

Backs. Goddard , Gibbs , lake , Rutten , M.Brown , B.Goodes pittard , Docherty

Mids. Ablest , dangerfield , Selwood J , Cotchin. Varcoe , Horlin-smith , Blicavs , Viney simpkin , Mitchell K

Rucks . Naitanui , Leuenberger rowe ,Daw

Forwards Franklin , Hawkins , Betts , LeCras , Koschitzke , Byrnes menzel D , Mayes

How can I fix any issues

Cheers everyone

Get rid of Rutten and Kosi ASAP. Replace Naitanui with Cox as Naitanui wont be playing early on. Not sure about Blicavs scoring potential, get Wines instead. Love Eddie but wont score highly enough on a consistent basis. Move Varcoe intot he forward line and get another mid rookie in there.

 

[mufassa]

Any suggestions?? Got caught out with not having enough DPP last year so I have picked a few.

Backs: Goddard, Gibbs, Duffield, Johncock, Valastuin, Goodes - Terlich Staker
Mids: Swan, Murphy, Heppell, Harlett, Ball, Varcoe, Crouch, O'Meara - Viney Mayes
Rucks: Goldstein Leuenberger - Rowe, Currie
Forwards: Franklin, Cox, Martin, Watts, Broughton, Monfries - Stringer, Macaffer.


thanks

 

[KardiniaPark]

Get rid of Rutten and Kosi ASAP. Replace Naitanui with Cox as Naitanui wont be playing early on. Not sure about Blicavs scoring potential, get Wines instead. Love Eddie but wont score highly enough on a consistent basis. Move Varcoe intot he forward line and get another mid rookie in there.

No, varcoe should be in the midfield to cover Mayes.

 

[toxic]

15 SLEEPS! ​

 

[toxic]

Any suggestions?? Got caught out with not having enough DPP last year so I have picked a few.

Backs: Goddard, Gibbs, Duffield, Johncock, Valastuin, Goodes - Terlich Staker
Mids: Swan, Murphy, Heppell, Harlett, Ball, Varcoe, Crouch, O'Meara - Viney Mayes
Rucks: Goldstein Leuenberger - Rowe, Currie
Forwards: Franklin, Cox, Martin, Watts, Broughton, Monfries - Stringer, Macaffer.


thanks

okay so from no DPP to entering rehab for an addictin to DPP - IMO if you want dpp use rookies to do it, eg: Hartlett to defence where he belongs, Johncock to the stiffy paddock where he belongs, heppell to defence where he belongs, use the mids for premium mids (they score higher)
fwds & rucks look solid, stringers ankle might see him miss the start of the season

 

[mufassa]

okay so from no DPP to entering rehab for an addictin to DPP - IMO if you want dpp use rookies to do it, eg: Hartlett to defence where he belongs, Johncock to the stiffy paddock where he belongs, heppell to defence where he belongs, use the mids for premium mids (they score higher)
fwds & rucks look solid, stringers ankle might see him miss the start of the season

thanks - have you posted your team?

 

[13jakejake13]

feedback would be appreciated!
if you think someone is out of place can you please recommend a replacement, thanks.

 

[toxic]

thanks - have you posted your team?

mufassa i havent for quite some time - seems to be changing every 2 days - see pm

 

[toxic]

View attachment 12891

feedback would be appreciated!
if you think someone is out of place can you please recommend a replacement, thanks.

Tom Scully - replacement = ANYONE, but seriously downgrade Scully to some 360K and below and use the extra cash to upgrade Bennell or SSElwood

 

[gtrain29]

How about this one guys?think I'm about settled with it depending on the rnd 1 rookies of corse.

BACKS- Goddard H-Shaw Gibbs Adcock Vlastuin Docherty Stevenson Terlich

MIDS- Ablett Swan J Selwood Cotchin Heppell Wines Crouch O'mera Mitchell Viney

RUCKS- Goldstein Leueenberger Witts Currie

FWDS- Franklin Rockliff Breust Lecras Varco Mayes Macaffer Lee

Have taken a punt on Heppell and Breust looking for a break out year/pushing into the midfield and any advice would be greatly appreciated on any issues!! Cheers guys

 

[13jakejake13]

How about this one guys?think I'm about settled with it depending on the rnd 1 rookies of corse.

BACKS- Goddard H-Shaw Gibbs Adcock Vlastuin Docherty Stevenson Terlich

MIDS- Ablett Swan J Selwood Cotchin Heppell Wines Crouch O'mera Mitchell Viney

RUCKS- Goldstein Leueenberger Witts Currie

FWDS- Franklin Rockliff Breust Lecras Varco Mayes Macaffer Lee

Have taken a punt on Heppell and Breust looking for a break out year/pushing into the midfield and any advice would be greatly appreciated on any issues!! Cheers guys

adcock out, hartlett in as he has a lot more upside and looking to breakout.
goodes is a necessity in the backline so swap him for stevenson
cotchin for dangerfield and swan for pendlebury
dangerfield is going to breakout again this year if the signs are correct and cotchin has the weight of captaincy.
pendlebury is a chance for brownlow and should average 130,

solid team anyway,
these are just some recommendations,

 

[Hawks2011]

Hey guys, Just recently readjusted my super coach and would appreciate any tips or feedback!

Personally I think its a ripper team and Im going to take out the competition haha

 

[13jakejake13]

Hey guys, Just recently readjusted my super coach and would appreciate any tips or feedback!

Personally I think its a ripper team and Im going to take out the competition haha

View attachment 12900

3 rookies on field in the backline is a bit much.

maybe dial down the midfield, and swap watson and cotchin for a couple of semi premiums 500k-550k to free up some cash and add a premium to your defence, hartlett would probably be the best option.

otherwise, solid team!

 

[Hawks2011]

3 rookies on field in the backline is a bit much.

maybe dial down the midfield, and swap watson and cotchin for a couple of semi premiums 500k-550k to free up some cash and add a premium to your defence, hartlett would probably be the best option.

otherwise, solid team!

The midfield is doing things to me though haha

 

[WeSt CoAsT EaGLeS]

After some fiddling around I think I've come up with a decent team...

B: Goddard, Shaw, Gibbs, Birchall, B.Goodes, Stevenson [Docherty, Terlich]

C: Ablett, Dangerfield, A.Swallow, Rockliff, Moloney, Wines, O'Meara, Viney [K.Mitchell, Crouch]

R: Roughead, Leuenberger [Rowe, Currie]

F: Franklin, Cox, Broughton, LeCras, Varcoe, Daniher [Macaffer, Lee]

Remaining: $171,600

Thoughts? Anyone I can upgrade/change with the money I have left?

 

[Swan4Brownlow]

After some fiddling around I think I've come up with a decent team...

B: Goddard, Shaw, Gibbs, Birchall, B.Goodes, Stevenson [Docherty, Terlich]

C: Ablett, Dangerfield, A.Swallow, Rockliff, Moloney, Wines, O'Meara, Viney [K.Mitchell, Crouch]

R: Roughead, Leuenberger [Rowe, Currie]

F: Franklin, Cox, Broughton, LeCras, Varcoe, Daniher [Macaffer, Lee]

Remaining: $171,600

Thoughts? Anyone I can upgrade/change with the money I have left?

I'd start by moving rockliff to the forwards in place of LeCras, then look to get in a different premium mid. Back line looks strong and te forward line once you replace LeCras with rockliff will also be a lot more reliable. I think between swallow and moloney you might want to go for one more out and out premium like a pendlebury or Cotchin. While he's a gun, swallow seems to be one rung below the absolute elite, so maybe move moloney down to a rookie and bump up swallow. Not convinced about roughead as a number one ruck but if it pays off you've got yourself a head start, plus with Rowe you could always switch him with cox once you come to upgrading for some more premium forwards.

My side:
BACKS: Goddard, Gibbs, Hartlett, Goodes, Stevenson, Vlastuin (Terlich, Staker)
I figure goodes is a lock for the dogs, so don't really view him as a normal rookie risk wise. Also think Hartlett if he can stay on the park is a lock for top 5 backs. Went a bit more expensive with Vlastuin because I figure if he can show his class it'll be worth the money in the long run. Starting with Staker on the brnch to give me the ability to move broughton between the forwards and backs to cover any potential 0

MIDS: Ablett, Pendlebury, Dangerfield, Cotchin, Murphy, Wines, Mitchell, O'meara, viney, crouch.
This is where the points are made, so went top heavy. Really tempted by David swallow but I couldn't justify ditching a top 10 mid to bring in a bit of a mid price risk. Rookies seem stock standard, not sold on crouch but he's there for the time being

RUCKS: Cox, Luenberger, Daw, Sinclair
Sinclair is there for captain loophole. Cox seems as safe an option as anyone else at the moment. Berger very underpriced but I hope he plays well this week. Daw could become any of witts or currie very easily

FORWARDS: Franklin, Rockliff, Robinson, Broughton, Varcoe, Maccaffer, Rowe, Kerridge
Franklin is self explanatory. Rockliff seems to have as much upside as any forward. Robinson should play more midfield time at the blues, varcoe looks value for money and broughton can be switched to the backs to provide extra flexibility. In the end I hope he's my D6. Rookies are subject to change again based on who stands out/is named although I'd like to keep Rowe for ruck flexibility

BANK: 92,700

Not entirely happy with the make up of the team. I'd like to have a better R2, be able to fit in a mid priced mid who could break out this year, plus some better forward rookies and more solid forward options in general would make me happier.

 

[theduckfan]

Hey Guys,

Anyone care to rate my team for 2013.

Leaves me with ~100k in the kitty

 

[LETSGOKANGAS]

I'd start by moving rockliff to the forwards in place of LeCras, then look to get in a different premium mid. Back line looks strong and te forward line once you replace LeCras with rockliff will also be a lot more reliable. I think between swallow and moloney you might want to go for one more out and out premium like a pendlebury or Cotchin. While he's a gun, swallow seems to be one rung below the absolute elite, so maybe move moloney down to a rookie and bump up swallow. Not convinced about roughead as a number one ruck but if it pays off you've got yourself a head start, plus with Rowe you could always switch him with cox once you come to upgrading for some more premium forwards.

My side:
BACKS: Goddard, Gibbs, Hartlett, Goodes, Stevenson, Vlastuin (Terlich, Staker)
I figure goodes is a lock for the dogs, so don't really view him as a normal rookie risk wise. Also think Hartlett if he can stay on the park is a lock for top 5 backs. Went a bit more expensive with Vlastuin because I figure if he can show his class it'll be worth the money in the long run. Starting with Staker on the brnch to give me the ability to move broughton between the forwards and backs to cover any potential 0

MIDS: Ablett, Pendlebury, Dangerfield, Cotchin, Murphy, Wines, Mitchell, O'meara, viney, crouch.
This is where the points are made, so went top heavy. Really tempted by David swallow but I couldn't justify ditching a top 10 mid to bring in a bit of a mid price risk. Rookies seem stock standard, not sold on crouch but he's there for the time being

RUCKS: Cox, Luenberger, Daw, Sinclair
Sinclair is there for captain loophole. Cox seems as safe an option as anyone else at the moment. Berger very underpriced but I hope he plays well this week. Daw could become any of witts or currie very easily

FORWARDS: Franklin, Rockliff, Robinson, Broughton, Varcoe, Maccaffer, Rowe, Kerridge
Franklin is self explanatory. Rockliff seems to have as much upside as any forward. Robinson should play more midfield time at the blues, varcoe looks value for money and broughton can be switched to the backs to provide extra flexibility. In the end I hope he's my D6. Rookies are subject to change again based on who stands out/is named although I'd like to keep Rowe for ruck flexibility

BANK: 92,700

Not entirely happy with the make up of the team. I'd like to have a better R2, be able to fit in a mid priced mid who could break out this year, plus some better forward rookies and more solid forward options in general would make me happier.

Good read. I also went with Cox and Luenberger. Luenberger has had a bad run with injury. Thinking he will cop a break "a good break' with injury.

Trying to figure in Dangerfield into my mid, though it might come at the cost of downgrading Cox to say the Kruze or Goldy.

I have read and seen many Rockcliffs. Not sold. I think J Riewoldt will be great with an upcoming Tigers midfield supplying more quality inside 50s.

 

[LETSGOKANGAS]

Hey Guys,

Anyone care to rate my team for 2013.

Leaves me with ~100k in the kitty

I love North Melbourne too. But Currie starting ruck is a no no. Look he could explode onto the scene but with Goldy as #1 his scores will be low.

Your mids are top heavy but this is a common strategy. Mids are a go.

Forwards need another quality scorer. I too am going Lecras....good value. I would upgrade Roughhead.

Defs....again going two rookies and Atley...will look better with say Atley to Shaw if you have the cash. But hey hope Atley kills it HI FIVE!

 

[MightyMark]

Hey Guys,

Anyone care to rate my team for 2013.

Leaves me with ~100k in the kitty

For the most part I agree with LETSGOKANGAS, you are going to find yourself in a bit of trouble with that forward line. You need another guaranteed starter. And Currie should not be starting on your field, no matter what potential you think he has.

But what has got me curious, is that im pretty sure this is the first team ive seen without a Brisbane player. I dont know why that matters but given the value coming out of the Lion's at the moment, it seems strange.

 

[theduckfan]

For the most part I agree with LETSGOKANGAS, you are going to find yourself in a bit of trouble with that forward line. You need another guaranteed starter. And Currie should not be starting on your field, no matter what potential you think he has.

But what has got me curious, is that im pretty sure this is the first team ive seen without a Brisbane player. I dont know why that matters but given the value coming out of the Lion's at the moment, it seems strange.

Had zorko in my mids but downgrades to varcoe so I could upgrade a defender.

Any suggestions on players to chose?

 

[Jazz71286]

Second year SC'er but this is the first year I'm actually taking is seriously. Any advice/info/suggestions would be great. Before you mention it, yes I know I don't have Ablett. I'm hoping he comes down a bit in the first few weeks and the cash I saved has been spent elsewhere on premium prospects.

B: Goddard, Gibbs, Hartlett, H Taylor, Vlaustin, B Goodes (Docherty, Terlich)
M: Swan, Dangerfield, Cotchin, Shuey, Hannebery, Moloney, Wines, O'Meara (Crouch, Viney)
R: Goldstein, Leuenberger (Rowe, Currie)
F: Cox, Rockcliff, Bruest, LeCras, Varcoe, Macaffer (Mayes, Staker)

Thanks in advance