Position 2013 SC Defenders

[Super Hans]

My team is almost 100% settled, except one thing. Hanley vs Enright. This is doing my head in. My head says Hanley but my heart says Enright. Aghhh.

 

[MightyMark]

Hanley.
Hanley should increase his out put this year, where as Enright at best will maintain.

 

[maculosus]

Should I be worried that I will have a starting donut in my backline? It's not like we're playing anyone this week.

prem/prem/prem/Goodes/Stevenson/Terlich - Docherty/Colq

Im 2k short of being able to trade out colq for pittard, what should I do?

Then you'll be able to afford Heath, another Port rookie and already selected

 

[GOAUS!]

Im having the same problem. Really dont want to head into the season with 5 port rookies. Hoping Terlich gets named, and I can swap out Heath.

Terlich not named (is an emergency).

 

[rocker_oz33]

Ben jacobs worth ago as mid pricer.

 

[MightyMark]

Terlich not named (is an emergency).

Im still going to keep him. Wont forgive myself if I trade him out and he comes in next week. Already kicking myself from my first panic trade (Barlow to Rich), not going to make another rash decision.

 

[Mkcaptain]

Because of all the rookies I had not being named. I'm now going to go for 2 playing rookies and a mid pricer. I'm tossing up between Russell and Jacobs. Russell's job security worries me

 

[Mantastic]

Im still going to keep him. Wont forgive myself if I trade him out and he comes in next week. Already kicking myself from my first panic trade (Barlow to Rich), not going to make another rash decision.

I'm keeping him too. Him and Rowe. Thankfully Neade is playing as I didn't want to to nurse through a rookie at F8 as well. In saying that though I'll be keeping an eye on L. Brown just in case. Already have all 3 Port rookies.

 

[GOAUS!]

Im still going to keep him. Wont forgive myself if I trade him out and he comes in next week. Already kicking myself from my first panic trade (Barlow to Rich), not going to make another rash decision.

If he doesn't come in next week and Luke Brown is named then decisions will be made.

 

[Mattrox]

Im still going to keep him. Wont forgive myself if I trade him out and he comes in next week. Already kicking myself from my first panic trade (Barlow to Rich), not going to make another rash decision.

I dropped Terlich. .... I'll just grab him on the bubble in rnd 4 if required.

 

[Chism]

VERY close watch on Hamish Hartlett today. He just missed my cut but i still have plans on bringing him in if i like what he does in the next few weeks before the price adjustments kick in.

 

[BORK]

Had the 2 premium backline set until the Terlich situation arose. Feel pretty happy with the round 1 output of it so far.

Goddard, Gibbs, Hartlett, Goodes, Pittard, Stevenson, Heath, Brown.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Had the 2 premium backline set until the Terlich situation arose. Feel pretty happy with the round 1 output of it so far.

Goddard, Gibbs, Hartlett, Goodes, Pittard, Stevenson, Heath, Brown.

I actually did go with the with the 2 premium defender setup and pretty happy with it -

Goddard, Gibbs, Goodes, Pittard, Stevenson, Heath (Turlich, Docherty)

Will most likely trade Docherty > L.Brown in a couple of weeks if Brown is selected next week.

Although with the way the Lions played against the Bulldogs Docherty could come in next week.

Hmmm!

 

[MightyMark]

If he doesn't come in next week and Luke Brown is named then decisions will be made.

This is true.

Bigger concern for me now, is Watts. What the hell happened there? I knew he would be frustrating, but that effort was deplorable.

So far every one of my 50/50 decisions have failed me.

Great start to the year.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Yuup Watts effort was a stinker,If stinks it up again this week he might get the boot.

 

[BORK]

I actually did go with the with the 2 premium defender setup and pretty happy with it -

Goddard, Gibbs, Goodes, Pittard, Stevenson, Heath (Turlich, Docherty)

Will most likely trade Docherty > L.Brown in a couple of weeks if Brown is selected next week.

Although with the way the Lions played against the Bulldogs Docherty could come in next week.

Hmmm!

Was an underrated tactic this year and made the rest of the side look very strong.

 

[Big Fozza]

anyone else grab newman and seriously questioning it?

 

[dlanod]

anyone else grab newman and seriously questioning it?

Yes. Next question?

 

[Big Fozza]

Yes. Next question?

if he spuds it up next week will you get rid of him?

 

[PK]

anyone else grab newman and seriously questioning it?

What to do, what to do. For someone like myself who left 1K in the bank, the only option would be to trade out a premium who I agonised over for 2 months, for the extra dollars of a Hartlett, Birchall etc...

 

[Big Fozza]

What to do, what to do. For someone like myself who left 1K in the bank, the only option would be to trade out a premium who I agonised over for 2 months, for the extra dollars of a Hartlett, Birchall etc...

i'm tossing up doing something crazy; Franklin to j kennedy and then newman to Gibbs. it's the ultimate no-no but extra trades are tempting me plus i love a bit of a gamble. also i had a pretty average round so am behind the 8 ball.

just writing it makes it sound like a bad idea... what to do what to do...

 

[Patty Healey]

The most obvious swap for me to do this week (outside of LeCras who is injured now) is Watts > Hartlett. I should have stuck with Hartlett. FML

 

[dlanod]

if he spuds it up next week will you get rid of him?

Yes.

i'm tossing up doing something crazy; Franklin to j kennedy and then newman to Gibbs. it's the ultimate no-no but extra trades are tempting me plus i love a bit of a gamble. also i had a pretty average round so am behind the 8 ball.

just writing it makes it sound like a bad idea... what to do what to do...

Stop looking at my trade notes (except I already have Gibbs)...

 

[James1001]

Need some advice as i want to offload Sam Wright. (Bad choice i know)

current backline stands at : Goddard, Gibbs, Birchall, Wright, Goodes, Stevenson {Telerich, Heath}

Thoughts on any of these options:
1. Geary (straight swap)
2. Dempsey (spend extra $)
3. Suban (save 150k, but not sure if he can score like that again... 3 goals)
4. Pittard (save 250k, but not sure about having
5. Other options ??

 

[Werewolf]

Pittard easily - he'll make you the most cash