Position 2013 SC Defenders

Which rookie backmen will you select?

  • Cameron O'Shea (Port Adelaide) $168,500

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Jayden Pitt (Fremantle) $128,000

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    237

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
The most obvious swap for me to do this week (outside of LeCras who is injured now) is Watts > Hartlett. I should have stuck with Hartlett. FML
I'm thinking of doing the same but watch watts throw a spanner in the works and ton up this week.
 
i went the courtney dempsey rollercoaster ride along with 3500 coaches, round 1 it payed dividends, lets hope he continues to seagull whilst goddard commands the attention of the opposition
 

Log in to remove this ad.

i went the courtney dempsey rollercoaster ride along with 3500 coaches, round 1 it payed dividends, lets hope he continues to seagull whilst goddard commands the attention of the opposition
I dont think it's his potential that is in question, but whether or not he can stay fit.
 
Also considering going Watts > Suban now to save cash, do you think this is too risky?
I dont know much about him to be honest prob best to see how watts,suban,dempsey harlett or anyone you have your eye on go this week.Seeing nobody play one another this week and prices wont change to the following week.If cant watch the games you can see how the players are going on fanfooty etc.
 
Need some advice as i want to offload Sam Wright. (Bad choice i know)

current backline stands at : Goddard, Gibbs, Birchall, Wright, Goodes, Stevenson {Telerich, Heath}

Thoughts on any of these options:
1. Geary (straight swap)
2. Dempsey (spend extra $)
3. Suban (save 150k, but not sure if he can score like that again... 3 goals)
4. Pittard (save 250k, but not sure about having
5. Other options ??

Pittard is the only choice
 
Yeah i'm downgrading a midpricer to pittard and upgrading a rookie ruck to loony if hes picked. I've been against loony all year but after the 3 rookie ruck idea :thumbsdown: ganna have to bring the big fella in.
 
Yeah i'm downgrading a midpricer to pittard and upgrading a rookie ruck to loony if hes picked. I've been against loony all year but after the 3 rookie ruck idea :thumbsdown: ganna have to bring the big fella in.

Just hold Blicavs until after round 3 and look at berger for two weeks, it wont cost you anything and might save you a trade. No need to rush in with him, cant see him dominating from the first bounce, he'll take a few weeks to get the speed of the game again.
 
Just hold Blicavs until after round 3 and look at berger for two weeks, it wont cost you anything and might save you a trade. No need to rush in with him, cant see him dominating from the first bounce, he'll take a few weeks to get the speed of the game again.

Good call. This is my plan of attack for now
 
Suban looked the goods in R1 will be interesting to see how he goes R2. If he does well get him in if you need someone to downgrade to instead of Watts/Goddard etc.

Also interested in seeing how Terlich performs, I truly thought Vlaustin would be in R1 farkin annoying.
 
Suban looked the goods in R1 will be interesting to see how he goes R2. If he does well get him in if you need someone to downgrade to instead of Watts/Goddard etc.

Also interested in seeing how Terlich performs, I truly thought Vlaustin would be in R1 farkin annoying.

Luckily I swapped Vlaustin for Heath early on. Vlaustin could *finger crossed* be a good downgrade option.
 
i'm holding sway on Vlaustin, I might look at trading Docherty though for Terlich or Stevenson in a couple of rounds. I already have Pittard.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

i'm holding sway on Vlaustin, I might look at trading Docherty though for Terlich or Stevenson in a couple of rounds. I already have Pittard.

I've got all 3 Port rookie defenders (not Colqhoun). I take it you have Goodes, see how everyone goes this round then trade either Vlaustin or Docherty or both.
 
I've got all 3 Port rookie defenders (not Colqhoun). I take it you have Goodes, see how everyone goes this round then trade either Vlaustin or Docherty or both.
Yep have Goodes as well and Colquhoun for MPP in mid which is fine for now as I also have O'Maera for cover in Mid. I'll most likely get Stevenson next, depending on how Terlich looks out there (not scores) as well. A little worried about having all 3 Port defenders (1 as mid).
 
Harry O could be worth a look if Bucks keeps playing him on the wing.
My exact thoughts after watching the NAB Cup! Will clearly increase his disposal numbers playing up the ground, thus increasing his scoring ability. Looked very good against the roos and found enough of it, scoring 97? However, after saying all this, he wont be in my side all year
 
Yeah I doubt Harry O will be first choice wing in a full Collingwood team.
 
Think I'll still go Franklin > Goldstein (move Cox forward) and Koby Stevens > Josh Kennedy (Eagles) (Move Dwyer form forward bench to midfield bench)

Will pick Franklin back up in round 7-8 and save myself the frustration from his low scores due his horror draw early on. :thumbsu:
 
Think I'll still go Franklin > Goldstein (move Cox forward) and Koby Stevens > Josh Kennedy (Eagles) (Move Dwyer form forward bench to midfield bench)

Will pick Franklin back up in round 7-8 and save myself the frustration from his low scores due his horror draw early on. :thumbsu:

Stop trading
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top