2015 SC NAB Challenge Thread

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.

Log in to remove this ad.

Waiting for toxic ology report on Hodge Jed SDT Boomer JLewis

Okay from a sc point of watching.
hawks
Ruffy..did nothing till he went into.mid as a ruck rover.
JLEWIS was the standout for the hawks
suckling..blah
sam mitch lots of link ups but a tier below sc mid relevancy
gibson was very very impressive
burgoyne did sweet fa
jorourke will be good For hawks but no sc yet
hodge sat in 2nd gear all game, looked non interested tbh
cyril looked electric for a half
jett anderson, he moves like a jet and knows when to run.great game awareness
alex woodward surprised, his decision making is v good

Rest of hawks who cares not sc relevant unless i missed someone

Kangas
swallow was excellent. Never stopped running
Ziebell looked great for a half then went mia
goldy did "F" All struggled to get to usable positions around the ground
boomer similar to hodge
macmillan..played deep defence and did not inspire any reason to pick him
wright was very very good in def
atley not sc relevant

Rest of kangas. ..whatevs

Anyone with any questions feel free
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Might have to rethink my reluctance in paying close to $600k for Gray, is only a practice match but geez what a player.

Yeah just brought him in. Thinking the next rung down will be ok to bring in durimg the season but gray could be megabucks and i could be too far behind not starting him
 
Gray is a god, was only running around at 3/4 pace too. Wasn't going hard at all. Both Boak and Wines were good, but we rotated our mids like crazy, so they didn't really get huge time in the middle and even on the field at some points.

Karl Amon was incredible, only played a half, however he will struggle to push anyone out of the 22 due to the quality. Krak was great, only played a quarter and a half. Real shot for round 1 with Monfries out and Chad might not be up round 1. However many could be sucked in because once those two are back I am not sure he stays.

Gray is just as big of a lock and Gazza in my eyes. He will win the Charlie this year, mark my words.
 
SCORES: (Power scores bolded)

Robbie Gray — 169

Matt Priddis — 135

Brad Sheppard — 116

Travis Boak — 111

Paul Stewart — 104

Kane Cornes — 101

Brad Ebert — 99

Ollie Wines — 97

Matthew Lobbe — 95

Andrew Gaff — 91

Fraser McInnes — 88

Andrew Moore — 88

Matt Rosa — 82

Tom Lamb — 82

Luke Shuey — 82

Aaron Young — 82

Sam Butler — 78

Mark LeCras — 78

Jasper Pittard — 76

Justin Westhoff — 71

Sam Gray — 70

Jay Schulz — 66

Scott Lycett — 66

Kane Mitchell — 65

Dom Sheed — 65

Josh Kennedy — 63

Tom Jonas — 61

Elliot Yeo — 60

Cam O’Shea — 58

Karl Amon — 57

Jamie Cripps — 57

Alipate Carlile — 54

John Butcher — 46

Xavier Ellis — 46

Tom Clurey — 45

Kane Lucas — 45

Nathan Krakouer — 42

Jarman Impey — 42

Jackson Nelson — 37

Malcolm Karpany — 36

Simon Tunbridge — 34

Jamie Bennell — 32

Sharrod Wellingham — 32

Brendon Ah Chee — 31

Jeremy McGovern — 30

Jake Neade — 29

Brant Colledge — 25

Patrick McGinnity — 24

Matt White — 24

Hamish Hartlett — 14

Liam Duggan — 10

Mitchell Brown — 9

Krakouer's 42 came in 38% TOG
 
SCORES: (North Melbourne players bolded)

Josh Gibson — 160

Jordan Lewis — 116

Lindsay Thomas — 111

Brian Lake — 105

Ryan Bastinac — 104

Scott Thompson — 99

Ben Cunnington — 96

Andrew Swallow — 95

Sam Wright — 87

Michael Firrito — 83

Robbie Tarrant — 83

Jack Gunston — 80

Bradley Hill — 78

Jack Ziebell — 76

Matthew Suckling — 75

Luke Breust — 74

Luke Hodge — 73

Sam Gibson — 72

Shaun Burgoyne — 72

Jamie Macmillan — 71

Ben Stratton — 69

Brad McKenzie — 69

Jed Anderson — 69

Kayne Turner — 68

Sam Mitchell — 66

David Hale — 65

Billy Hartung — 64

Liam Shiels — 64

Todd Goldstein — 63

Cyril Rioli — 61

Ben Jacobs — 60

Jono O’Rourke — 56

Leigh Adams — 55

Brent Harvey — 53

Robin Nahas — 51

Jarryd Roughead — 50

James Frawley — 50

Alex Woodward — 45

Jarrad Waite — 41

Shaun Atley — 40

Taylor Duryea — 39

Paul Puopolo — 38

Mason Wood — 38

Jonathon Ceglar — 37

Isaac Smith — 36

Daniel Howe — 33

Majak Daw — 32

Joel Tippett — 26

Drew Petrie — 19

Marc Pittonet — 14

Aaron Black — 12

Ben Brown — 10
 
Lycett 66? Don't you get points for pressure acts and 1%ers and the like? eww! Stinky score for a good game! :eek:

Lycett's stats show zero 1%ers... His first quarter was below par as he only had 1 possession, but he worked himself into the game well. His score probably got hurt by not doing more when the game was closer and also having 4 free kicks against. Definitely some positives for him though, 9 touches at 100% disposal efficiency, 2 contested marks and 2 goals in only 74% game time. Don't worry about his score too much.
 
Gray, Wines & Lamb very solid.
Got all 3! Gray worth every cent, Wines looks promising and Lamb and Lonie are on my bench and both had solid hit outs.
Lycett 66? Don't you get points for pressure acts and 1%ers and the like? eww! Stinky score for a good game! :eek:
Gave away 4 free kicks though! That hurts
 
Gray is a god, was only running around at 3/4 pace too. Wasn't going hard at all. Both Boak and Wines were good, but we rotated our mids like crazy, so they didn't really get huge time in the middle and even on the field at some points.

Karl Amon was incredible, only played a half, however he will struggle to push anyone out of the 22 due to the quality. Krak was great, only played a quarter and a half. Real shot for round 1 with Monfries out and Chad might not be up round 1. However many could be sucked in because once those two are back I am not sure he stays.

Gray is just as big of a lock and Gazza in my eyes. He will win the Charlie this year, mark my words.
Not one for hyperbole are you?
 
Okay from a sc point of watching.
hawks
Ruffy..did nothing till he went into.mid as a ruck rover.
JLEWIS was the standout for the hawks
suckling..blah
sam mitch lots of link ups but a tier below sc mid relevancy
gibson was very very impressive
burgoyne did sweet fa
jorourke will be good For hawks but no sc yet
hodge sat in 2nd gear all game, looked non interested tbh
cyril looked electric for a half
jett anderson, he moves like a jet and knows when to run.great game awareness
alex woodward surprised, his decision making is v good

Rest of hawks who cares not sc relevant unless i missed someone

Kangas
swallow was excellent. Never stopped running
Ziebell looked great for a half then went mia
goldy did "F" All struggled to get to usable positions around the ground
boomer similar to hodge
macmillan..played deep defence and did not inspire any reason to pick him
wright was very very good in def
atley not sc relevant

Rest of kangas. ..whatevs

Anyone with any questions feel free

Nice work Toxic! I just have a couple of questions in regards to one player...

Scott D Thompson

How did he look and what type of role was he playing?
 
Nice work Toxic! I just have a couple of questions in regards to one player...

Scott D Thompson

How did he look and what type of role was he playing?

Was amazed he scored 90+
Tippett was excellent
tarrant was good

Didnt notice sdt much tbh. He was in quite a few meaninglessness handball exchanges.

On top of that the hawks forward line was...well. .pretty disfunctional at best.

Put dal and Higgins back in and sdt probably has less rebounding responsibilities

He'd be a watch in nab 3 but as a 3rd tall defender he could be an option.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top