Position 2015 SuperCoach forwards

[Da Breust]

For SC 2015
1. Lonie
2. Lambert
3. Lamb
4. Daniel

daylight

5. Clark

Still daylight?

 

[GOAUS!]

Still daylight?

Some would argue there's daylight between Clark and the rest.

 

[Bont2Bruce]

Still daylight?

****ing preseason.

 

[Mercuri Rising]

****ing preseason.

Amen.

 

[toxic]

M clark 150k rd1

Hogan 350k rd 7

Hmmm this may, just may have been slightly adrift

 

[toxic]

While you're at it Toxic, who do you think will win the flag this year? Please don't say the Hawks.

Port

Port easily

 

[felsty]

Conventional forward line I'm guessing will be 4 premos plus Hogan/Clark/Lonie/Lambert. Is it worth having 3 starting rookies and shoring up the backs? Probably not I feel.

Thats what I have done and its actually not bad.. dont knock it til you try it

 

[Great 2008]

Buggr you Clark was happy to see people staying clear.

 

[TheOz]

Clark averaged 84.1 playing as a key position forward in an utterly shit Melbourne team in 2013, in a much stronger Geelong team, given that teams will play their best defender on Hawkins (as the Crows did with Talia last night), plus doing some pinch hitting in the ruck, Clark is no brainer as a rookie starter in the forwards. Pencil him in for at least a 75 average.

 

[TheOz]

Conventional forward line I'm guessing will be 4 premos plus Hogan/Clark/Lonie/Lambert. Is it worth having 3 starting rookies and shoring up the backs? Probably not I feel.

You might not have much of a choice given the apparent lack of backline rookies.

 

[KardiniaPark]

Conventional forward line I'm guessing will be 4 premos plus Hogan/Clark/Lonie/Lambert. Is it worth having 3 starting rookies and shoring up the backs? Probably not I feel.

Probably not, I've tried it with bulking up the mids with 6 super Prems and having 3 forward, it just looks a bit arse about. I like the thought mentally of only having to upgrade two more FWD

 

[KardiniaPark]

You might not have much of a choice given the apparent lack of backline rookies.

Brown, Edwards, Saad, Hamling, Goddard. I don't think it's as bad as it seems. I think Hamling is the only iffy one really. From all reports the rest look like they will walk straight in.

 

[Double the Fist]

Brown, Edwards, Saad, Hamling, Goddard. I don't think it's as bad as it seems. I think Hamling is the only iffy one really. From all reports the rest look like they will walk straight in.

Even GOddard? Saints board less sure!

 

[Double the Fist]

Port

Port easily

Its out of Sydney and Hawf again I think. Sydneys depth isnt that bad, Hawks depth is ****ing great!
Ports depth? Meh! Not fantastic. Hinkley is a gun coach and has already proven himself IMO but not Port. They will be thereabouts me thinks.

FWIW WC won't make finals without E-mac. Opens spots for Sheed and Lamb at start of season. I'm keeping a keen eye on Lamb.

 

[King_Steele]

Brown, Edwards, Saad, Hamling, Goddard. I don't think it's as bad as it seems. I think Hamling is the only iffy one really. From all reports the rest look like they will walk straight in.

None of those players besides Brown will have decent enough JS.

 

[Bont2Bruce]

None of those players besides Brown will have decent enough JS.

That's the thing with rookies isn't it? They just need to play the first 6-7 games though to do the business for SC.

 

[King_Steele]

That's the thing with rookies isn't it? They just need to play the first 6-7 games though to do the business for SC.

Yeah but this is defence we are talking about.

Depth of rookies is shit house.

 

[cyril4brownlow]

Protip: Pick cyril. He will finish with most points at end of year. (also brownlow)

 

[Lums23]

Yeah but this is defence we are talking about.

Depth of rookies is shit house.

I love how every thread ends up being a discussion about the defenders

 

[King_Steele]

I love how every thread ends up being a discussion about the defenders

It's a very serious discussion point indeed.

 

[SnappyHappy]

Conventional forward line I'm guessing will be 4 premos plus Hogan/Clark/Lonie/Lambert. Is it worth having 3 starting rookies and shoring up the backs? Probably not I feel.

I'm really looking into this set up now for the forward line. The fact that Clark also spent some time in the ruck is a great sign, I'm a lot more confident now that he will be a solid enough scorer with good JS to hold down F4 until he appreciates enough for an upgrade. If Lambert is upgraded and plays R1 I think he is also a solid F5, then Hogan, Lonie and Lamb will hopefully play enough games to cover F6.

Might mean starting without Gray because there is so much value in the forwards but I think if this allows you to start with a stronger backline it will put you ahead. A lot of people will be risking it with mid pricers in defence and that could end badly.

 

[Double the Fist]

Protip: Pick cyril. He will finish with most points at end of year. (also brownlow)

Your 11th post is a cracker!

 

[tracygrimshaw]

For SC 2015
1. Lonie
2. Lambert
3. Lamb
4. Daniel

daylight

5. Clark

Still daylight?

Probably been said a few pages back, but Salem and Karnezis... Where do we see them fitting in this sub-200k category?

 

[SnappyHappy]

Probably been said a few pages back, but Salem and Karnezis... Where do we see them fitting in this sub-200k category?

Salem is a no for me at his price based on his NAB 1 performance. Karnezis I'd like another look at but he has burnt people in the past so probably a bit riskier.

 

[Big Fozza]

Salem is a no for me at his price based on his NAB 1 performance. Karnezis I'd like another look at but he has burnt people in the past so probably a bit riskier.

Whats his JS look like?