- Sep 13, 2016
- 3,465
- 8,490
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Crisp, Daicos, Kelly, Macrae, Rioli, Weitering?
Lol no
Lol no
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
AFLW 2024 - Round 6 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Josh KellyHugh McLuggage is the only wingman I can see there. It looks like the old cliche of piling stoppage midfielders in at the expense of wings and forwards checks out again.
I think Sean Darcy is unlucky to not make the squad given his impact in the position of ruck is elite, but Gawn and Witts ahead of him is reasonable.
+ the coleman medallist and they still manage to miss out on finals. huge achievementCarlton with 5 players in the AA squad.
Absolutely f*cken lol, what an absolute crock of s**t
Couldn't happen to a nicer and more above board organisation+ the coleman medallist and they still manage to miss out on finals. huge achievement
Only by 5 minutes..they were in the 8 until the last 5 minutes of the season ..Couldn't happen to a nicer and more above board organisation
fact is if you are at the top of the list you get more players whether they're the best in the position or just made to look real good in a winning side.
But Carlton. 9th. Seriously WTF. Does that just indicate how bad the rest of the team is?
I'm with you, I watch my fair share of oppo footy and legit never f**ken heard of him. Do they mean Beau Maister?Who the f*** is Callum Wilkie? Not even joking. Doesn't ring a bell at all. Legit doesn't sound like a real player to me.
Wilkie is one of the more deserving players, he's a gun defender. Plenty of bigger spuds in that list.
Too many blokes that only played well for half the season like Weitering, Cripps, Crisp, Papley etc and blokes that don't get near it if they played for Us/Gold Coast or weren't a name like Rioli or Bont.
Similar to the endless procession of Friday night games that those w***ers did not earn.fact is if you are at the top of the ladder you get more players whether they're the best in the position or just made to look real good in a winning side.
But Carlton. 9th. Seriously WTF. Does that just indicate how bad the rest of the team is?
He's been enormous for about 12 rounds and mediocre the rest. I think he gets in because those 12 rounds are outstanding. Many more consistent players out there.Cripps?
Blokes been enormous all year - he's a no brainer best 18 starter.
Nah. The problem with Carlton has always been their depth. Carlton's top 6 of Weitering, Walsh, Cripps, Curnow, McKay and Saad, might be the best top 6 of any team in the league. Falls away pretty dramatically after that.Lol, no they're not. In the world of Victorian media they are.
Walsh is truly top notch talent. The rest are well overrated.
It's the most obvious looking Ross Lyon list going.Nah. The problem with Carlton has always been their depth. Carlton's top 6 of Weitering, Walsh, Cripps, Curnow, McKay and Saad, might be the best top 6 of any team in the league. Falls away pretty dramatically after that.
I wouldn't be critical of Crisp - a warrior who is the underrated heart and soul of that club.Wilkie is one of the more deserving players, he's a gun defender. Plenty of bigger spuds in that list.
Too many blokes that only played well for half the season like Weitering, Cripps, Crisp, Papley etc and blokes that don't get near it if they played for Us/Gold Coast or weren't a name like Rioli or Bont.
He's been solid all year, but I'd argue only AA good for half of it.I wouldn't be critical of Crisp - a warrior who is the underrated heart and soul of that club.
I will be critical. Will Brodie literally had a better season and was never in any serious consideration for the AA squad.I wouldn't be critical of Crisp - a warrior who is the underrated heart and soul of that club.
They're really not. They're talked up endlessly as a Victorian team with excellent AFL and media connections.Nah. The problem with Carlton has always been their depth. Carlton's top 6 of Weitering, Walsh, Cripps, Curnow, McKay and Saad, might be the best top 6 of any team in the league. Falls away pretty dramatically after that.