Teams 2023 Fantasy - Rate My Preseason Team

[WaynesWorld19]

​

 

[Corkintheocean]

I heard he's going through the midfield this year and is solid af, taking a gamble and hopefully it pays off.

He's cheap enough not to burn you too bad, can easily jump off for an early performing rook.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

I heard he's going through the midfield this year and is solid af, taking a gamble and hopefully it pays off.

So many high priced Rookies, soaking up your $$$$ and costing you a decent F3 premo ......very rarely do high priced rookies pay off

Nice DEF

 

[Joshieboii]

Long-time drafter, first time Classic player. This is what my team currently looks like. I have swapped between Max Holmes and Jai Culley 40 times already.

On RMX1921 using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[MooreDaicos]

So many high priced Rookies, soaking up your $$$$ and costing you a decent F3 premo ......very rarely do high priced rookies pay off

Nice DEF

Thanks for the tip, I'll give it a tweak later on after reading the threads on positions and I may even get into the top 1000 this year. Still trying to work out when to sell the rookies before they become too stagnant in earning $.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Thanks for the tip, I'll give it a tweak later on after reading the threads on positions and I may even get into the top 1000 this year. Still trying to work out when to sell the rookies before they become too stagnant in earning $.

You want 11-12 Premo's (keepers) in your Round 1 side .....you can't get there with so many high priced Rookies

 

[Barrybran]

You want 11-12 Premo's (keepers) in your Round 1 side .....you can't get there with so many high priced Rookies

Assuming we have enough rookies to allow this?

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Assuming we have enough rookies to allow this?

I've got 12 premos, 4 mid-pricers (inc Yeo) ...counting Ashcroft / Phillips as certainties, that leaves 4 on-field Rookies, which I'm pretty confident in.

The only query is, will we get enough cheap rookies ?

 

[Barrybran]

I've got 12 premos, 4 mid-pricers (inc Yeo) ...counting Ashcroft / Phillips as certainties .....that leaves 5 on-field Rookies, which I'm pretty confident in.

The only query is, will we get enough cheap rookies ?

Don't get me wrong, I think 5 rookies is a good number but I wonder how many red dots we'll all have if the likes of Mackenzie, and Phillipou out don't play round 1.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Don't get me wrong, I think 5 rookies is a good number but I wonder how many red dots we'll all have if the likes of Mackenzie, and Phillipou out don't play round 1.

Well, neither of those two are in my side, or likely to be .....I'm praying for Chandler, Fahey, Tsitas, & Johnson

Def Rookies look plentiful

 

[FlowersByIrene]

Last few winners have averaged 4-5 rookies on field with up to 8 mid pricers.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Long-time drafter, first time Classic player. This is what my team currently looks like. I have swapped between Max Holmes and Jai Culley 40 times already.View attachment 1609132

On RMX1921 using BigFooty.com mobile app

IIRC Mac Andrew is club suspended for 3-4 games ....maybe pencil in Constable, but have a rubber handy

 

[DynamiteDons]

This is where ive landed on before all the games start next week. Im happy with 85% of the team,
Positions I am considering
Rucks, F3, D4, M2, M4.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Last few winners have averaged 4-5 rookies on field with up to 8 mid pricers.

It's damn hard not to end up with 4-5 Rookies ....if you downgrade a premo, the most you'll save is $150K - $200K ....not enough to do much with

What's Phillips ....3rd season into his career, he's not a rookie, but priced as a Rookie
Same with Pedlar ...3rd season into his career, he's cheap as chips at $213K

What's the cut-off price point for a Mid-Pricer ?

 

[WaynesWorld19]

 

[Trav 20]

I was at today's intraclub for the Dees. 4 x 20 minutes with AFL umpires.

Oliver was close to BOG. He was completely unhindered by any thumb issues.

 

[FlowersByIrene]

It's damn hard not to end up with 4-5 Rookies ....if you downgrade a premo, the most you'll save is $150K - $200K ....not enough to do much with

What's Phillips ....3rd season into his career, he's not a rookie, but priced as a Rookie
Same with Pedlar ...3rd season into his career, he's cheap as chips at $213K

What's the cut-off price point for a Mid-Pricer ?

Yeah 'rookies' include anyone rookie priced, which this year is below $300.

Mid Pricer depends on line, but would be between $300-699 for defense, ruck or forward line and $300-$800 for midfield

 

[tigs2010]

I was at today's intraclub for the Dees. 4 x 20 minutes with AFL umpires.

Oliver was close to BOG. He was completely unhindered by any thumb issues.

How was Petracca?

 

[Barrybran]

How was Petracca?

That's a strange way of spelling Gawn, Grundy and Brayshaw

 

[Dan12]

Pretty sure Selby and a couple other winners recommend paying up for the higher priced rookies. I have 6 between 270-300k sitting there who look likely for round 1. I'm even content having Weddle at $266k sit on the pine.

 

[Trav 20]

How was Petracca?

Fantastic. He and Oliver were best.

Grundy kicked 2 goals and was very busy.

Keep an eye on young Judd McVee. The first two quarters was the probables versus the possibles and McVee took Salem's place in the probables.

 

[tigs2010]

Fantastic. He and Oliver were best.

Grundy kicked 2 goals and was very busy.

Keep an eye on young Judd McVee. The first two quarters was the probables versus the possibles and McVee took Salem's place in the probables.

Excellent. Think I might run CP5 over Sooky McCrae.

The other bloke sounds made up

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Pretty sure Selby and a couple other winners recommend paying up for the higher priced rookies. I have 6 between 270-300k sitting there who look likely for round 1. I'm even content having Weddle at $266k sit on the pine.

Phillips & Ashcroft are no brainers .....the question is, how many, B4 it impacts the quality of your premo's

Of course, we're looking for value with every pick ......but paying $280K for a 50 ave, which I can get for $200K, doesn't equate ....but that depends on their role

Example: Is HAW Mackenzie plying mid minutes, or will he be stuck on a HFF ....that'll impact his ave & whether he's a value pick .....don't pick them simply because they were a Top 10 Draft Pick

 

[tigs2010]

Phillips & Ashcroft are no brainers .....the question is, how many, B4 it impacts the quality of your premo's

Of course, we're looking for value with every pick ......but paying $280K for a 50 ave, which I can get for $200K, doesn't equate ....but that depends on their role

Example: Is HAW Mackenzie plying mid minutes, or will he be stuck on a HFF ....that'll impact his ave & whether he's a value pick .....don't pick them simply because they were a Top 10 Draft Pick

You also don’t want to pay up for a $280k guy if they’re not a locked in best 22. Especially with discretionary subs this year.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

You also don’t want to pay up for a $280k guy if they’re not a locked in best 22. Especially with discretionary subs this year.

Exactly ! ..... a Weddle for example, you'd imagine he's less likely to be subbed at 3/4 time, given his time trial results

Remember the pain Ward & McDonald caused last year, as expensive rookies .....there's still rookies that didn't play last year, or not many games ....that now have 2 x PS's under their belt

 

[11kgm]

Exactly ! ..... a Weddle for example, you'd imagine he's less likely to be subbed at 3/4 time, given his time trial results

Remember the pain Ward & McDonald caused last year, as expensive rookies .....there's still rookies that didn't play last year, or not many games ....that now have 2 x PS's under their belt

Just to add to that Davey is prime sub risk, doesn't have the fitness to do a full game