Opinion 2023 Player X vs Y vs Z

[WaynesWorld19]

Sometimes it's a line-ball call .....do I prefer Piggy, Macrae, or Laird .....get other opinions on your conundrum here

 

[LilDosDos]

If both fit and in the team, Tarryn Thomas or Darcy Tucker as that awkwardly priced North Melbourne pick? Or stay away from both

 

[Corby_4]

Steele and Crae vs Trac and LDU?

 

[JDWCE]

Steele and Crae vs Trac and LDU?

Not even close for me

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Not even close for me

+1

 

[Zevon]

If both fit and in the team, Tarryn Thomas or Darcy Tucker as that awkwardly priced North Melbourne pick? Or stay away from both

Probably a wait-and-see on both to be honest, but probably Thomas if I had to pick one

 

[LilDosDos]

Probably a wait-and-see on both to be honest, but probably Thomas if I had to pick one

Just saw an AFL article today that Tucker is injured, so question answered I guess

 

[11kgm]

If both fit and in the team, Tarryn Thomas or Darcy Tucker as that awkwardly priced North Melbourne pick? Or stay away from both

Tucker had a knee surgery, so I would go Thomas at the moment

 

[Barrybran]

I'm curious about Rozee v Butters. Why is Rozee getting a lot of love but not Butters?

 

[powerrrrrrrrrrrr]

I'm curious about Rozee v Butters. Why is Rozee getting a lot of love but not Butters?

Rozee should be a full time midfielder now which should increase his scoring. Butters will likely still split his mid/fwd time.

Although Butters has scoring potential as he’s shown, Rozee has the same scoring potential but should have much greater consistency now.

 

[powerrrrrrrrrrrr]

Is Noah Anderson V LDU just splitting hairs?

 

[Milo Cyrus]

I'm curious about Rozee v Butters. Why is Rozee getting a lot of love but not Butters?

If Butters can work out how to not run into brick walls and kill himself; he'd be of interest.

 

[11kgm]

Is Noah Anderson V LDU just splitting hairs?

Noah i see being pretty much at his price, LDU went nuts in the second half of the year

 

[Shaunn]

Sinclair, Dawson, Sicily or A Brayshaw in what order?

Also Salem or Yeo? Was also looking at Himmelberg as his ceiling is alot higher in defence, just more so if he plays there.

 

[11kgm]

Sinclair, Dawson, Sicily or A Brayshaw in what order?

Also Salem or Yeo? Was also looking at Himmelberg as his ceiling is alot higher in defence, just more so if he plays there.

A.Brayshaw isn't training at the moment so he would be 4
Siciliy is number 3 I don't know if he can go big again, will he be required to lock down or potentially play forward
Sinclair new coach need to see his role number 2
Dawson likely to get tagged at number 1

Salem over Yeo, Salem is a safe 90 and only had a bad injury last year, Yeo has been broken for a while

Himmelberg was playing forward in match sim

 

[Shaunn]

A.Brayshaw isn't training at the moment so he would be 4
Siciliy is number 3 I don't know if he can go big again, will he be required to lock down or potentially play forward
Sinclair new coach need to see his role number 2
Dawson likely to get tagged at number 1

Salem over Yeo, Salem is a safe 90 and only had a bad injury last year, Yeo has been broken for a while

Himmelberg was playing forward in match sim

Yeah ive been leaning more on Salem, I think if i can make a move or two i think Sinclair or just keep Sicily for now.

 

[11kgm]

Yeah ive been leaning more on Salem, I think if i can make a move or two i think Sinclair or just keep Sicily for now.

I have gone back to Docherty, Salem, Daicos/Young

 

[Shaunn]

I have gone back to Docherty, Salem, Daicos/Young

Yeah ive got those 3 already, Just deciding between Sicily and Sinclair i think.
If i go Sinclair i only have 888k, if i go Sicily i have 945k.

If i go Sicily i could go B. Smith. If i go Sinclair, i could go Parish or even Coniglio. So many mid options.

 

[11kgm]

Yeah ive got those 3 already, Just deciding between Sicily and Sinclair i think.
If i go Sinclair i only have 888k, if i go Sicily i have 945k.

If i go Sicily i could go B. Smith. If i go Sinclair, i could go Parish or even Coniglio. So many mid options.

I went Doc Salem Yong McKenna Ginbey Wilmot

But went 4 premo deep in the forward line

 

[JDWCE]

I actually don't mind Sicily. He's essentially their distributor coming out of defence. Their stabiliser sort of type. Always want the ball in his hands. Most assume Hawks will struggle this year right? He's a great interceptor so it makes sense that people are saying he will see a lot of ball as their defence theoretically should see a lot of it. Plus if they do struggle moving the ball forward you'd think most of the time they are gonna chip it around and he should see those chips. I'm pretty bullish on him as I see way less question marks compared with a lot of the other top guys.

 

[Shaunn]

I went Doc Salem Yong McKenna Ginbey Wilmot

But went 4 premo deep in the forward line

Yeah Young looks good at that price tbh.
I had 4 premos in the forward line but im thinking of Tarryn Thomas or Mclean as the 4th and maybe going a bigger premo in the mid.

 

[Shaunn]

What do we all think about the rucks?

Is English iffy at 901k or we wanting to go cheaper and get Cameron?

Think im keeping Marshall as a lock for now.

But going cheaper and getting Cameron gets an upgrade in another area.

 

[11kgm]

What do we all think about the rucks?

Is English iffy at 901k or we wanting to go cheaper and get Cameron?

Think im keeping Marshall as a lock for now.

But going cheaper and getting Cameron gets an upgrade in another area.

I'm locking English, Marshall I'm worried without King what will happen there

I have DC at F4 then someone cheaper at R2, like Meek/Lycett if shit hits the fan swing DC to R2

And go which ever forward is doing well but does mean i miss McLean

 

[Shaunn]

I'm locking English, Marshall I'm worried without King what will happen there

I have DC at F4 then someone cheaper at R2, like Meek/Lycett if s**t hits the fan swing DC to R2

And go which ever forward is doing well but does mean i miss McLean

Well we should see in pre season how Marshall is used hopefully. If badly ill just go Cameron.
Apparently Thomas has been used off half back so far in pre season if i heard correctly?

 

[11kgm]

Well we should see in pre season how Marshall is used hopefully. If badly ill just go Cameron.
Apparently Thomas has been used off half back so far in pre season if i heard correctly?

Correct but he also is taking it easy due to a broken foot