Opinion 2023 Player X vs Y vs Z

[Richo83]

Quiet easily with Cameron at least 10-15 points upside

#39 Most Relevant | Darcy Cameron - Coaches Panel

An injury is all it can take to make someone fantasy football relevant. In 2022 Darcy Cameron took his opportunity and became a hugely important selection across the formats. With Brodie Grundy now out of the picture, can Darcy continue his hot run of form and be one of the best selections in...

coachespanel.tv

Oooh I was thinking Geelong Cameron. I like Darcy Cameron and he's my D4 for two reasons:

1. He'll be rucking as a solo ruck (I predict anyway) and he scored well last year doing that

2. He's another ruck option I can loop in with my bench ruck being a ruck/forward.

Regarding Rozee v Butters, I went Rozee as I think he has more midfield potential and I think his low scores early in 2022 were injury related or something. Butters I think is more forward; but he had some injury impacted scores.

I think both are great gets though; I just worry about having too many players on one bye.

 

[Richo83]

Dunkley and Tom Mitchell v Smith and Macrae.

Got 72k left which I feel like I'll use changing rookies. Worried about having too many premiums on the round 15 bye as I have Taranto, Coniglio, Rozee, Dale, Cerra and English.

 

[Shaunn]

J Kelly and D Sheed or
J Steele and Worpel?

 

[Shaunn]

This is a big one but anything could happen

Docherty, Sheed, English and Mclean
or
Sicily, Worpel, D Cameron and Dylan Moore?

 

[Tex Danger]

J Kelly and D Sheed or
J Steele and Worpel?

Kelly and sheed safest bet imo

 

[Tex Danger]

Bailey smith v Parish V J Kelly v Kaeys (left field option in what will be an otherwise commonly debated pack)

 

[Corkintheocean]

J Kelly and D Sheed or
J Steele and Worpel?

It's never to early to completely disregard Worpel from your calculations.

 

[Shadow89]

Bailey smith v Parish V J Kelly v Kaeys (left field option in what will be an otherwise commonly debated pack)

Parish is still injured and hasn't had a pre-season so put a line through him (I had him in my first team but then saw his injury news so had to take him out).

Keays is a great Fantasy POD when played in the middle, but Nicks played him forward a bit last year, so no guarantees that this won't continue.

So then it's between Smith and Jelly for mine, with Bailey getting the nod due to playing in a fantasy friendly team. Kingsley will bring across Richmond learnings for sure, so I could see Jelly getting pushed to the wing instead, where he scores less in the Richmond'esque system. Still both pretty solid choices regardless.

Other one I'd throw into that mix is Bont, given the Lobb recruitment up forward, so him likely being a full time mid. Reckon this could be the year he pushes 110, IMO.

 

[Corby_4]

Parish is still injured and hasn't had a pre-season so put a line through him (I had him in my first team but then saw his injury news so had to take him out).

Keays is a great Fantasy POD when played in the middle, but Nicks played him forward a bit last year, so no guarantees that this won't continue.

So then it's between Smith and Jelly for mine, with Bailey getting the nod due to playing in a fantasy friendly team. Kingsley will bring across Richmond learnings for sure, so I could see Jelly getting pushed to the wing instead, where he scores less in the Richmond'esque system. Still both pretty solid choices regardless.

Other one I'd throw into that mix is Bont, given the Lobb recruitment up forward, so him likely being a full time mid. Reckon this could be the year he pushes 110, IMO.

Can he stay on the park though?
His injury history is a bit dodgy.
That'd be my only concern going anywhere near Bont.

 

[Shadow89]

Can he stay on the park though?
His injury history is a bit dodgy.
That'd be my only concern going anywhere near Bont.

Really? Tbh, durability is not something that comes to mind when thinking of Bont.

Didn't miss a game last year and only missed 1 the year prior. Taking out his debut year, he's only missed 4 games in the past 8 years, and 3 of those were in 2018. That's pretty damn impressive, IMO.

 

[Corby_4]

Really? Tbh, durability is not something that comes to mind when thinking of Bont.

Didn't miss a game last year and only missed 1 the year prior. Taking out his debut year, he's only missed 4 games in the past 8 years, and 3 of those were in 2018. That's pretty damn impressive, IMO.

I meant Lobb sorry, I should have been more specific and worded it better.

 

[Shadow89]

I meant Lobb sorry, I should have been more specific and worded it better.

Ahhhhh, now that makes more sense, haha!

I reckon if they're structuring with Lobb in the team, that someone like Bruce is a more likely backup than shunting Bont forward - especially given the midfield gap of Dunks leaving - and mid being where Bont absolutely dominates

 

[Tex Danger]

Parish is still injured and hasn't had a pre-season so put a line through him (I had him in my first team but then saw his injury news so had to take him out).

Keays is a great Fantasy POD when played in the middle, but Nicks played him forward a bit last year, so no guarantees that this won't continue.

So then it's between Smith and Jelly for mine, with Bailey getting the nod due to playing in a fantasy friendly team. Kingsley will bring across Richmond learnings for sure, so I could see Jelly getting pushed to the wing instead, where he scores less in the Richmond'esque system. Still both pretty solid choices regardless.

Other one I'd throw into that mix is Bont, given the Lobb recruitment up forward, so him likely being a full time mid. Reckon this could be the year he pushes 110, IMO.

That’s a shame about parish, prob high in that group otherwise esp as starts year well and has goid early draw

Kaeys had a shoulder injury operated on post season. He has said that was main reason for playing forward and expects a return to mids. Agree though with a developing team there’s uncertainty. Balks to the walll pick and not sure I’ll pin my hopes on him but I may

Smith I do really like. My current team I’m about 10k short but that’s going quite pricey in rookie placeholders.

 

[Shaunn]

Laird and Sheed
or
Steele and T Greene

 

[Tex Danger]

Laird and Sheed
or
Steele and T Greene

Steele and sheed

 

[mezaire]

Laird and Sheed
or
Steele and T Greene

I'd actually go Steele and Sheed!!

I think Laird will come back slightly to 115 odd and Steele will average about the same.

Personally I think Green ( I assume you mean Tom) will always be that 85-100 guy

 

[Shaunn]

I'd actually go Steele and Sheed!!

I think Laird will come back slightly to 115 odd and Steele will average about the same.

Personally I think Green ( I assume you mean Tom) will always be that 85-100 guy

Steele and sheed

Yeah Laird could be amazing but i doubt he keeps up the 120 again, so makes sense.
What are we thinking on Steele or Miller? I feel Steele will be more consistent as he had 110 average even with the game he got injured in.

 

[Tex Danger]

Yeah Laird could be amazing but i doubt he keeps up the 120 again, so makes sense.
What are we thinking on Steele or Miller? I feel Steele will be more consistent as he had 110 average even with the game he got injured in.

For some reason I lean to miller but it’s a coin toss surely

If either of those get back to 120 as they’ve shown they can they are huge picks. And I feel 1 may but not both (also likely none)

 

[mezaire]

Yeah Laird could be amazing but i doubt he keeps up the 120 again, so makes sense.
What are we thinking on Steele or Miller? I feel Steele will be more consistent as he had 110 average even with the game he got injured in.

They are my M1 and 2 at the moment, but if I had to choose it would be Touk. I just think he can always score through tackles!

 

[Shaunn]

They are my M1 and @ at the moment, but if I had to choose it would be Touk. I just think he can always score through tackles!

Steele did average more tackles out of the two .

 

[Shaunn]

Rate them in order. Butters, Gulden or Cerra?

I do have Rozee already if that makes a difference.

 

[11kgm]

Rate them in order. Butters, Gulden or Cerra?

I do have Rozee already if that makes a difference.

Aren't 2 forward ones a mid?

 

[Shaunn]

Aren't 2 forward ones a mid?

I can move players around to get either 3, just think they're all good options at that price.

 

[11kgm]

I can move players around to get either 3, just think they're all good options at that price.

I'd say Cerra at the start of the year without Walsh, Butters if he wasn't Kamikaze, Gulden next

 

[LilDosDos]

400-500K Mid Price Madness Battle Royal

Tarry Thomas v James Worpel v Wayne Milera v Toby Mclean

Pretty much 100% on Mclean, currently tossing up between fitting Worpel or Thomas into my side....