Autopsy 2023 Preliminary Final Blues brave season comes to an end

Who played well for Carlton in the Preliminary Final vs Brisbane?


  • Total voters
    127
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

I said at some point earlier this year improving our bottom six would be transformational.

Turns out that improvement was within and the team was indeed transformed when everyone on the park started contributing.

Onward and upward for 2024...one or two missing pieces, more natural progression, some finals experience/heartbreak...we have A LOT to look forward to.

Carn the ****ing Baggers!!
 
I am exhausted after the last few weeks - what a wild ride this year was. Proud of the boys and stoked I got to see not one, but TWO winning finals in the flesh.

Time for a well-earned rest and to book in some surgeries. Let’s aim for top 4 next year (and for Brisbane to smash some Pies next week). Up the Baggers 🩵💙
 

Log in to remove this ad.

And it was correct. Our midfield is too slow.

Not bad reaching the last 4 and a couple of options to play with next year

Williams for one could go through the middle, Hollands will become more contested, Doc

We didn't lose tonight because of the pace of our midfield, it's lazy analysis

Neale, Dunkley, McCluggage don't scream speed
 
Last edited:
Fagan got the message out to his players to smash the ball into space and not leave it inside in the contest. Other teams will be onto us now. We need some speed badly next year
Stop panicking. There will always be something we aren't doing perfectly well. Sadly, your place here is assured.
 
His tandom work with TDK has been one of the rising ruck duos in the league. Find another Guinea Pig.
I'm not the only one to say that we're a better team without Pittonet. He's not good or quick enough around the ground or forward to be a number one ruckman. Game has gone past his type.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Fagan got the message out to his players to smash the ball into space and not leave it inside in the contest. Other teams will be onto us now. We need some speed badly next year

Zac Williams will be a good start

Boyd, Saad, Williams, Newman decent half backs


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
I'm not the only one to say that we're a better team without Pittonet. He's not good or quick enough around the ground or forward to be a number one ruckman. Game has gone past his type.

Think TDK plays his best footy as No1 ruck

JSOS and Harry can pinch hit for 5 minutes a quarter


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
You don't think the sides we played in the 2nd half of the season knew what our one wood was?
Exactly. Or that we don’t know our opposition’s one wood? Everyone knew how the Melbourne final was going to look. The Sydney and Brisbane finals, it was a matter of which style would prevail.
 
Call it as I see it. Hewett's disposal is ordinary at best and had an average finals series. Handballs to players under pressure and no penetration on his kicks

To improve next season we can't have the same midfield group we had tonight.

Pittonet offers us very little around the ground. Never seen a ruckman who can't jump and so slow. Needs a massive preseason to work on his running and jumping.

Everyone knows our one wood. If opposition can match our clearance game they win.

He was soundly beaten tonight.
your last few efforts - looking forward to you coming back biggger & better & even more negative next season :thumbsu::thumbsu::thumbsu:
 
I'm not the only one to say that we're a better team without Pittonet. He's not good or quick enough around the ground or forward to be a number one ruckman. Game has gone past his type.
Have a good night cannot agree at all. Look at how many games we win when Pitto plays.
 
Have to concede the selection committee nailed this game.

Boyd was an inspired choice. Marchbank stood up. Hollands didn't wither under the physicality of finals footy.

Motlop vs Owies is the only arguable point, and I don't think it would have swayed the outcome either way.
Have to disagree.
Kemp was sorely missed down back.
Owies would have been a leading option and able to put pressure on. Our forward pressure was woeful.
Kennedy was ok but we really needed some speed from the sub.
Boyd was good but I'd say the MC failed miserably.
I just hope we don't lose players because of it.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Autopsy 2023 Preliminary Final Blues brave season comes to an end

Back
Top