I hope so. We desperately need a clever small forward to replace Bolton (and Cumberland). We have no X factor small forwards.thought they were very keen on berry.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
I hope so. We desperately need a clever small forward to replace Bolton (and Cumberland). We have no X factor small forwards.thought they were very keen on berry.
Well, stuff all the time and money we waste on the recruiting department, that settles it, don't touch FOS. Thank God for Coach's arthritic bones.FOS is gonna be a dud. Feel it in my bones.
I think what your post highlights is why most, if not all, mock drafts have us taking 3-4 talls.Firstly I don't consider Bauer as a KPP but more a general forward similar to the way Broad is a general defender so I didn't put him on the list.
The other name I missed was Ryan and given the opinions on him by a lot of supporters he was fortunate to get 3 years.
Even if he is still here in 3 years I'm not confident that he'll be our number 1 ruck and given the other options are 2 basketball converts in Hayes-Brown and Colina I'll be disappointed if we don't take another ruck like Dodson if available.
Up forward Lynch could be gone this time next year that means we're relying on Koschitzke & Lefau neither are what I'd consider a number 1 forward, then there is the untried Fawcett and Gray a 3rd round pick and MSD respectively if we're relying on them to become leaders of the forward line we're going to need a lot to go right for that to happen. So again if we don't take a KPF this draft I'll be disappointed l.
Finally our defensive stocks. Balta is a lock and Gibcus showed plenty in his first season to suggest he should be a long term option. Unfortunately he has copped 2 LTI that have cruelled his development. Blight while promising has only been given 2025 to prove himself. Miller has a chance to be around but will need to improve his consistency. So while a KPD isn't a necessity if we rate one as best available when the pick is on the clock.
We're rebuilding the list and the belief that we only seem to need midfielders is completely wrong. We need to address every area of the ground if we want to give ourselves the best chance to turn things around.
For me that means taking 3-5 midfield/flankers and at least 2 KPP and a Ruck and make the most out of our draft hand to address as many areas as possible and give the rebuild a solid foundation to build from. Anything less than that will be a mistake
I don’t hate the idea of 3 talls. Cadman & Armstrong leading up the ground and a big behemoth in the goal square (who can ruck). 3 quick smalls crumbing. I hate medium forwards, I’d rather an extra tall.Need someone who can ruck though. Cadman has done it a bit but if we are offering a 10 year deal and coughing up 2 first rounders I'd probably rather we don't make him do that lol.
Maybe can run with 3 talls I guess.
StKilda and Melbourne both have their second picks before our pick 10. They both need key forwards and I cant see them taking 2 mids each.Currently only two teams pick between our selections at six and ten and I can’t see the Saints prioritising a key forward with their picks
I’d take Smillie at six under the educated guess that Armstrong is more likely to still be there at ten
thats okay i feel there it isnt night and day between Armstrong and Whitlock,Jobe. The game is going towards forwards that crash packs and can take marks further up the ground when we are trying to get out. Jonty is the guy for that.StKilda and Melbourne both have their second picks before our pick 10. They both need key forwards and I cant see them taking 2 mids each.
If Bauer is a general forward then so is Lefau.Firstly I don't consider Bauer as a KPP but more a general forward similar to the way Broad is a general defender so I didn't put him on the list.
The other name I missed was Ryan and given the opinions on him by a lot of supporters he was fortunate to get 3 years.
Even if he is still here in 3 years I'm not confident that he'll be our number 1 ruck and given the other options are 2 basketball converts in Hayes-Brown and Colina I'll be disappointed if we don't take another ruck like Dodson if available.
Up forward Lynch could be gone this time next year that means we're relying on Koschitzke & Lefau neither are what I'd consider a number 1 forward, then there is the untried Fawcett and Gray a 3rd round pick and MSD respectively if we're relying on them to become leaders of the forward line we're going to need a lot to go right for that to happen. So again if we don't take a KPF this draft I'll be disappointed l.
Finally our defensive stocks. Balta is a lock and Gibcus showed plenty in his first season to suggest he should be a long term option. Unfortunately he has copped 2 LTI that have cruelled his development. Blight while promising has only been given 2025 to prove himself. Miller has a chance to be around but will need to improve his consistency. So while a KPD isn't a necessity if we rate one as best available when the pick is on the clock.
We're rebuilding the list and the belief that we only seem to need midfielders is completely wrong. We need to address every area of the ground if we want to give ourselves the best chance to turn things around.
For me that means taking 3-5 midfield/flankers and at least 2 KPP and a Ruck and make the most out of our draft hand to address as many areas as possible and give the rebuild a solid foundation to build from. Anything less than that will be a mistake
Player | Pick | Club |
---|---|---|
Jai Culley | 1 | West Coast |
Max Ramsden | 6 | Hawthorn |
Hugo Hall-Kahan | 11 | Sydney |
Luke Nankervis | Pre-season | Adelaide |
Player | Pick | Club |
---|---|---|
Finn Callaghan | 1 | GWS |
Josh Sinn | 12 | Port Adelaide |
Campbell Chesser | 14 | West Coast |
Mitchito Owens | 33 | St Kilda |
Blake Howes | 39 | Melbourne |
Marcus Windhager | 47 | St Kilda |
Dante Visentini | 56 | Port Adelaide |
Luke Cleary | 61 | Western Bulldogs |
Player | Pick | Club |
---|---|---|
Will Ashcroft | 2 | Brisbane Lions |
Harry Sheezel | 3 | North Melbourne |
Cam Mckenzie | 7 | Hawthorn |
Charlie Clarke | 24 | Western Bulldogs |
Toby McMullin | 34 | GWS |
Oli Hotton | 35 | St Kilda |
Angus McLennan | Zone | St Kilda |
Jack Peris | Zone | St Kilda |
Player | Pick | Club |
---|---|---|
Ryley Sanders | 6 | Western Bulldogs |
Charlie Edwards | 21 | Adelaide |
Ollie Murphy | 41 | Fremantle |
Luke Lloyd | 42 | Brisbane |
Harvey Johnson | 49 | West Coast |
Archie Roberts | 54 | Essendon |
Calsher Dear | 56 | Hawthorn |
Vigo Visentini | Rookie | Essendon |
Matt Carroll | Rookie | Carlton |
*Cooper Lord | Mid-season | Carlton |
Player | Power ranking |
---|---|
Levi Ashcroft | 1 |
Murphy Reid | 7 |
Harry Armstrong | 9 |
Luke Trainor | 13 |
Taj Hotton | 17 |
Sam Marshall | 19 |
Harrison Oliver | 34 |
Adrian Cole | 42 |
Josh Dolan | 49 |
Lennox Hoffman | 51 |
Jhett Haeata | Unranked |
Lachie Voss | Unranked |
Mitch Kirkwood-Scott | Unranked |
Bailey McKenzie | Unranked |
No current season stats available
The criteria was who was going to be on the list in three years.Which footballer will make it, is guess work.
2023 & 2024 showed me we need multiple quality KPF. I would take the opportunity to draft the best available this draft, We need Naismith cover, Ryan ain't ready & I'd draft one this draft We went DFA for Sam N, might be a good time to draft
Definitely: Balta, Gibcus, Fawcett, Ryan?
For me : Balta's the only lock. Huge qn marks over Gibcus, Fawcett, Ryan in terms of durability & ability.
Probably on the list : Miller, Young, Lefau, Bauer add Brown & Kosi too. But hopefully playing a lot of VFL.
Too early to say: Blight, Gray, Hayes-Brown. How often do mid season draftees & Cat B players make it? Never.
I'd be using picks in the 20s to get KPF & ruck depth. Dodson & or Armstrong
Allan is shite. Forget himI see in several mock drafts that the general consensus is that we are selecting (before bids).
1. Sam Lalor
6. Josh Smillie (or slider in FOS, Jagga, Draper)
10. Harry Armstrong
11. Bo Allan (if no Travaglia)
People may say that is too tall going for Smillie and Allan as our 2 mids in this draft and that's probably fair. But I'm starting to wonder with most rebuilding sides and what we saw under Yze's first year is that draftees are trialed in different positions or mostly played behind the ball to learn the game at AFL level, If a Travaglia or Tauru is gone by our 10 and 11 picks, do they see Bo Allan as the hole that Rioli has left?
Doing a bit of reading and watching on Allan we apparently like him, he ticks a lot of the boxes that modern coaches love in exiting the defence by foot. Burst of speed, loves a contest, disposal penetration, leadership and versatility. Whilst Smillie can rotate in the Midfield and forward line with his height. Allan can rotate from defence to midfield when Smillie is up forward or resting?
could we see something like this early on?
FB: Vlastuin - Balta - Gibcus
HB: Allan - Broad - Brown
C: Ralphsmith - Hopper - Mcintosh
Foll: Nankervis - Tarranto - Smillie
HF: Lalor - Bauer - M. Rioli
F: Mansell - Lynch - Campbell
INT: Kosi - Ross - Prestia - Short
ahh yes, 18 year old kid being considered in the top 15 of what recruiters calling the most even and in-depth draft in years is 'shite'. got it.Allan is shite. Forget him
He wouldn't come anyway Pies got a better listTaj hotton player comparison: Adam Treloar. This tells you all you need to know.
If that is bait ,and it's by the master?
AgreeIf Bauer is a general forward then so is Lefau.
All I'm saying is that it doesn't need to be done all in one year though.
We have every chance of being bottom again next year and we are likely going to end up with another 3 first round picks through trading.
If we need key position players id rather take them higher up the order or simply trade for them. I'd prefer a Cadman within the next couple of years vs a gamble on a tall between picks 18 and 30 this year.
I'm not saying we don't take any key position players, but one or two is plenty for one draft.
Did they forget about pick 20View attachment 2160633
Richmond holds eight of the top 25 picks in the upcoming National Draft, leaving them with many possible strategies for those selections.
It has been suggested that they are likely to trade either up the draft order or into the 2025 draft, in order to space out the picks – given draft contracts all come up at the same time and obviously to give themselves some ammunition for next year.
The Tigers hold picks 1, 6, 10, 11, 18, 23 and 24, following the departures of Shai Bolton, Liam Baker and Daniel Rioli to Fremantle, West Coast and Gold Coast respectively.
Former Geelong forward Daniel Menzel praised their job cashing in during the trade period.
“I think Richmond did a good job too. They got rid of all of those players and stacked as much draft capital as they could. They’re not winning the flag in the next couple of seasons,” Menzel told SEN SA’s Sportsday.
“They’ve got to stock up on kids before Tassie comes in and you don’t want to be down the bottom then. You might as well be down the bottom for the next couple of years and get yourself ready to go, rather than peter around 12th or 13th and then have to rebuild.”
Menzel however would not be trading out of their incredible draft hand, saying they’re giving themselves eight chances to land star players and increasing their odds at nailing five or six of the selections.
“I am not swapping anything. I’m keeping as many picks as possible,” he said.
“The reality is, number one draft picks don’t always hit and neither do picks 2, 3 and 4.
“So if they’ve got eight of the top 24, they’re probably going to hit on four or five of them. Play the percentages.
“If you get five quality players out of this draft, you’d absolutely take that.
“They could try and get a couple picks higher and then what happens if they miss a few and only end up with two good players?
“I quite like that plan and I think it’ll set them up to be able to reload and go again in a few years.”
A similar comparison would be GWS’ 2011 draft crop. The Giants held the top five picks in the draft, as well as 7, 9, 10, 11, 13 and 14.
While they stumbled somewhat on selections like Dom Tyson at pick 3, Matt Buntine at pick 5 and Liam Sumner at 10, they landed Stephen Coniglio at 2, Nick Haynes at 7, Toby Greene at 11, Taylor Adams at 13 and Devon Smith at 14.
This offset middling picks as well like Jon Patton at 1, Will Hoskin-Elliott at 3 and Adam Tomlinson at 9.
Similarly in 2010, the Suns held picks 1, 2, 3, 7, 9, 10, 11 and 13 – selecting David Swallow, Harley Bennell, Sam Day, Josh Caddy, Dion Prestia, Daniel Gorringe, Tom Lynch and Seb Tape.
Could sheer quantity be the way for the Tigers in the 2024 National Draft?
Why sheer quantity is the best path for Richmond at the 2024 AFL Draft
“I am not swapping anything. I’m keeping as many picks as possible.”www.sen.com.au
nah, I reckon he could slide on what he has shownThere’s zero chance Smillie gets to 13. And I’d say there’s a 0.001% chance he gets to 10.
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Wonder if there is someone else under 24 who we might be targeting end of next year98% chance North don't hold Pick 2 come their pick.
Melbourne no chance to trade for it. Adelaide a small chance if they really think Carlton will take Draper at 3. Saint's could be the other.
North's F1 would be nice, though I don't think there is going to be much value getting mid F1's next year where the draft isn't as deep as this one. Unless we are packaging up for Cadman.
Gibcus is a forward.I disagree, west coast, north and essendon have worse key defenders than us, Adelaide and bulldogs are also probably equally bad.
We have Vlastuin, Broad, Brown, and Gibcus (if he stays on the park) plus one of Young, Blight, Miller rotates down there.
I have no doubt that at least one of Young, Blight and Miller can eventually develop to be a strong defensive roll player if we back them in to play.
Key defense is clearly currently our most competitive area, we need to invest all our picks into mids, tall forwards and small forwards this year
On SM-A528B using BigFooty.com mobile app
If Smith is available at 6, we're taking him.Currently only two teams pick between our selections at six and ten and I can’t see the Saints prioritising a key forward with their picks
I’d take Smillie at six under the educated guess that Armstrong is more likely to still be there at ten
I think we should do the trade for 2, just gives us more certainty, stronger base, more confidence to build going forward in terms of stronger foundationsIf Smith is available at 6, we're taking him.
Holding 6 is a play for Smith, with Smillie as the backup.
If we don't rate Smith, we'll trade 6+18 for pick 2 and take Lalor+FOS.
To take Lalor + FOS, or another combination?I think we should do the trade for 2, just gives us more certainty
take Lalor and FOS, I am less confident about some of the others and I like some of the options with later picks and being later, less risk as value is not as great in terms of investment, with deep draft more bang for buckTo take Lalor + FOS, or another combination?
I don't think we do the straight trade (I think we're after Smith as a slider). We might do 6+11 for 2 and F1. It's too good to turn down.
Idk why we don't just wait til he's OOC...Hopefully we will hold Essendon or Melbourne's F1.
Cadman will be contracted so he's going to cost a fortune but we need hold & use our own pick in 2025.