List Mgmt. 2024 Draft - Post Trade Period Edition

[Tiger_Of_Old]

You conveniently left out 10 and 18.
Would look more like:
1/2\6/11/20
Or
1/6/10/11/18/20

Not sure I want that trade. Forget pick FOS.

Didn't conveniently leave out those picks.
Was more what our first 3 picks would look like.

 

[Charlie Pannam]

I genuinely would not be against us taking Draper at 1 or trading up to take him at 2.

I hadn't looked much into him till the last few nights, he is seriously impressive.

Could almost argue the pick of the trio when comparing Lalor / FOS / Draper.

Lalor/Draper are right at the top of my wish list. They’d compliment each other perfectly in our midfield with a combination of speed, power and their ability to hurt opposition on the inside and outside . However will be extremely surprised if Draper ends up in the Y&B.

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

True. People banging on about getting Cadman. Will prob cost 2 first round picks. Better off just getting Armstrong at pick 11 (if he is still available).

And Armstrong is a bust?
We'd wait 5yrs before declaring it.
2029 same kp boat as today without a paddle.
You know what your getting with Cadman.

 

[Coach_Required]

Wouldn't even pick this guy in the top 5



How's the run and bounce? 3min 30sec ...... lmao

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

I like the idea of taking a key forward but Armstrong ain't it. I was once a champion chf myself so I know these things. Shanahan is the guy, yes he lacks a bit of mongrel and he's not the sharpest tool in the shed, but how smart do you need to be to play football anyway. I think he'll turn out fine with a bit of confidence and experience.

Keep healthy Royce

 

[Oldmanuncle]

Its gone quiet but months ago were apparently frothing over Faull,

Played well on the back end of last year.
Back injury kept him out for big chunk this year but his 5 goals on return created a lot of hype.
Won't be a bad thing if he lands at Punt road.

 

[prodigy]

SEN's 2024 AFL full Phantom Draft

Draft expert Nathan Sepe makes his predictions for every selection in the 2024 AFL National Draft.

www.sen.com.au

1. Jagga
6. Langford
10. Tauru
11. Travaglia
18. Moraes
20. J. Whitlock
23. Faull
24. Dodson

I think I've generally felt negative toward every relatively reputable mock/phantom draft I've seen so far.

 

[lizard man]

jonty Faull will be the best key forward out of all of them

 

[tiger_tough]

SEN's 2024 AFL full Phantom Draft

Draft expert Nathan Sepe makes his predictions for every selection in the 2024 AFL National Draft.

www.sen.com.au

1. Jagga
6. Langford
10. Tauru
11. Travaglia
18. Moraes
20. J. Whitlock
23. Faull
24. Dodson

Needs more talls...

 

[db26]

2 SA kids could be on our radar not much media hype , but talented. One Vic Metro kid.

Charlie Nicholls
State: South Australia
State League Club: Central District
Community Club: Mintaro Manoora
Date of Birth: 08/06/2006
Height: 197cm

Charlie West
State: South Australia
State League Club: Woodville-West Torrens
Community Club: Henley
Date of Birth: 01/02/2006
Height: 194cm

Floyd Burmeister
State: Victoria Country
State League Club: GWV Rebels
Community Club: Redan
Date of Birth: 04/05/2006
Height: 199cm

 

[tiger_tough]

On September 17 he said Richmond are doing anything possible to pair up FOS and Jagga. Bloke has absolutely no idea.

Checks out....

 

[db26]

I genuinely would not be against us taking Draper at 1 or trading up to take him at 2.

I hadn't looked much into him till the last few nights, he is seriously impressive.

Could almost argue the pick of the trio when comparing Lalor / FOS / Draper.

My issue with him is his kicking at that pick has to be

 

[db26]

I'm the same but want Gerryn, competitive beast clunks marks and was in the top 10 for agility.

I see him more as a ruck forward not purely as a KPF

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

Unless he is the 2nd coming of Lockett Dunstall or Ablett Sr / @El Duderino then no.

.

 

[tiger_tough]

The supremely talented Sam Lalor appears to be firming as the favourite to be taken at pick 1 in next weeks National Draft. Unfortunately, calling these FULL season highlights is rather wishful thinking on my part as Lalor suffered through a series of injuries in 2024 which severely limited the amount of footy he was able to play.

 

[Finn9]

I think I've generally felt negative toward every relatively reputable mock/phantom draft I've seen so far.

If realistically we don't get FOS, what would be your next best haul?

edit: I am not a fan of that SEN mock at all

 

[db26]

And Armstrong is a bust?
We'd wait 5yrs before declaring it.
2029 same kp boat as today without a paddle.
You know what your getting with Cadman.

Maybe in 2 years , but not now. He will cost minimal 2 top 10 picks we need those picks for the rebuild

 

[bigstyletiger]

jonty Faull will be the best key forward out of all of them

He looks to be the most competitive.

 

[Michaels]

My issue with him is his kicking at that pick has to be

Doesn't seem to be too many issues with his kicking.

 

[SA_Tiger11]

Starting to get a stiffy

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

If it looks like two of FOS/Jagga/Smillie are there at 6 I’m calling up the Saints and getting 7

At what cost
10 & 11?

 

[_RT_]

My Current Draft Wish List (October ranking)

1. Jagga Smith - Midfielder (1)
2. Sid Draper - Midfielder (2)
3. Sam Lalor - Mid/Forward (3)
4. Finn O'Sullivan - Midfielder (4)
5. Josh Smillie - Midfielder (7)
6. Murphy Reid - Midfielder (9)
7. Harvey Langford - Midfielder (6)
8. Alixzander Tauru - KPP (8)
9. Harry Armstrong - KPF (5)
10. Bo Allan - Midfielder (10)
11. Jack Whitlock - KPF (15)
12. Matt Whitlock - KPP (16)
13. Xavier Lindsay - Midfielder (14)
14. Jobe Shanahan - KPF (13)
15. Alex Dodson - Ruck (19)
16. Tobie Travaglia - Mid/Defender(12)
17. Taj Hotton - Mid/Forward (17)
18. Jesse Dattoli - Mid/Forward (18)
19. Joe Berry - Forward (22)
20. Christian Moreas - Mid/Forward (20)
21. Cooper Hynes - Mid/Forward (21)
22. Luke Trainor - KPP (11)
23. Jonty Faull - KPF (23)
24. Jack Ough - Def/Midfielder (24)
25. Hamish Davis - Mid/Forward (25)
26. Tom Gross - Mid/Forward (26)
27. Kayle Gerreyn - KPF/Ruck (27)
28. Ollie Hannaford - Forward (28)
29. Harrison Oliver - Defender (29)
30. James Barrat (NR)

My top 7 are now all midfield types, with the top 4 unchanged. Smillie climbs back into my top 5, while Reid climbs into the top 6 and drops Langford down 1 spot. The biggest changes come with the elevation of KPP/Ruck with 6 of the next 8 being filled by them, which ties in with my desire to see us address the lack of quality young talls on our list, especially up forward and in the ruck. The top 20 is then rounded out by mid/forward types who can add some class and X factor inside 50, while also pushing up into the midfield as they develop. Trainor is the biggest fall from the edge of the top 10 to outside the top 20 which comes off the concerns some have about his being a concussion risk, which has to be taken into account. In saying that he could prove to be a steal for a club with 1/3 of the picks in the first round who could take a punt as the kid is certainly talented enough. I've got roughies in the mix for being picked up late 1st/early 2nd in Ough Davis & Barrat and I wonder if tigs2010 is a still a fan of Davis, while everyone has a soft spot for Jack Ough

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

I was shot down big time when I said his 2024 form couldnt be ignored. He barely fired a shot in his draft year whilst players went past him.

 

[SA_Tiger11]

Probably gotta get it in our head that Lalor will be our first pick. It’s happening.

 

[tony__montana]

I genuinely would not be against us taking Draper at 1 or trading up to take him at 2.

I hadn't looked much into him till the last few nights, he is seriously impressive.

Could almost argue the pick of the trio when comparing Lalor / FOS / Draper.

Hes impressed me the most - Im just a mug punter and dont put in the time some of the more distinguished campaigners on this board do, but i'll ssay it again- he's very impressive, he seems to be the only genuine real burst away mid in this draft, none of the others seem to have it.