Trades 2024 Fantasy Round 2 Trades

[Phar Ace]

You ain’t seen spudding like me.
Traders AFL article
I own all the most traded out - none of the most trade in
Own all of the stocks down and none up.
Grundy, Wines, ZReid, Budarick, Fisher, Newcombe, Martin, JyClark
Amongst all this $#!t you’d think all the other vegetables would thrive.
No not really - 4 of 22 got over the tonne.

Wow, you must have a Graduate Diploma of Spudding!

 

[Calebs Shlong]

PERKINS!

Talk me out of it.

 

[largebus]

Do I ditch Z Reid now when I'm already dumping Gibcus?
Or do I hold him for a bit to offload Wines (for Bonner)?

 

[stallon]

Do I ditch Z Reid now when I'm already dumping Gibcus?
Or do I hold him for a bit to offload Wines (for Bonner)?

No rush to dump Reid, there isnt any cheaper def rookies worth going to right now

 

[stallon]

PERKINS!

Talk me out of it.

Parish back this week, vsing a strong team in Sydney, role not guaranteed, the bombers have guys like Tsatas, Hobbs, etc who will be playing full games soon trying to get time in there too

 

[Corkintheocean]

PERKINS!

Talk me out of it.

Should be sufficient.

 

[stallon]

Going Jhye Clark out, any insight into Sharp vs Dempsey?

Dempsey is more likely to throw up a 30 if Geelong lose, Sharp at least is on the wing which has been a fruitful role for freo wingers in recent years

 

[Milo Cyrus]

I'm sure I heard tigs2010 whisper it earlier on - he's good to blame for everything - just ask Zevon! (miss you TedDougChris )

 

[SM]

PERKINS!

Talk me out of it.

Parish.

 

[TY24]

The two sets of trades I’m stuck between are

Grundy out Xerri In & Wines out M. Crouch In

Or

Wines Out Fyfe In & Coffield Out D’Ambrossio in

Either way I think Wines has to go, Fyfe’s injury record just makes me nervous when I already have Yeo in the side as well.

 

[Milo Cyrus]

The two sets of trades I’m stuck between are

Grundy out Xerri In & Wines out M. Crouch In

Or

Wines Out Fyfe In & Coffield Out D’Ambrossio in

Either way I think Wines has to go, Fyfe’s injury record just makes me nervous when I already have Yeo in the side as well.

 

[Phteven]

Wow, you must have a Graduate Diploma of Spudding!

I have those very same players i had Tsatas in and he was the sub. Saw this with minutes to go and checked out Billings, Fyfe and MavKenzie. Chose Mackenzie and copped a 41. Tsatas came on late for a 43!!

 

[Corkintheocean]

I have those very same players i had Tsatas in and he was the sub. Saw this with minutes to go and checked out Billings, Fyfe and MavKenzie. Chose Mackenzie and copped a 41. Tsatas came on late for a 43!!

What we need is a few good Tsatas.

What is Tsatas? eh?

 

[Banga19]

Weighing up who of Wines or Newcombe to trade. The Port v West Coast game was not suited to Wines, high scores from kick ins which is unusual, low contested possessions and tackles, very bruise free. In saying that though, Wines got similar CBAs to last year, he'll need more to average 90+

Newcome didn't really pass the eye test, surely Mitchell gives him a bit of a rocket. Started slowly last year too. Leaning towards trading Wines and giving Newcombe another look.

Also I reckon reasonable chance that Lazzaro is dropped or subbed for Simpkin

 

[Pure Grunt]

I have those very same players i had Tsatas in and he was the sub. Saw this with minutes to go and checked out Billings, Fyfe and MavKenzie. Chose Mackenzie and copped a 41. Tsatas came on late for a 43!!

I went Fyfe in place of Tsatas.

At least now I know how Warnie feels.
Hand out a bit of advice and then **** it up.
Will be very guarded with my advice. Might stick to gifs.

 

[SM]

You ain’t seen spudding like me.
Traders AFL article
I own all the most traded out - none of the most trade in
Own all of the stocks down and none up.
Grundy, Wines, ZReid, Budarick, Fisher, Newcombe, Martin, JyClark
Amongst all this $#!t you’d think all the other vegetables would thrive.
No not really - 4 of 22 got over the tonne.

Do we have the same team? Lol.

 

[Pure Grunt]

Do we have the same team? Lol.

 

[Mezzoculo]

What are people's thoughts on Billings vs Dempsey? Given our forward lines are most likely to be our weakest, points wise, does the higher output of Billings outweigh his higher cost? Or do we expect Dempsey's past few scores to be repeated going forward?

 

[samFFC]

Wines to Bonner done

Trying to target price risers that have a bigger ceiling to clear 90 plus, with the best 18.

Likely Sharp in for the other trade, rather than Dempsey.

 

[samFFC]

What are people's thoughts on Billings vs Dempsey? Given our forward lines are most likely to be our weakest, points wise, does the higher output of Billings outweigh his higher cost? Or do we expect Dempsey's past few scores to be repeated going forward?

Should be similar price rises over 4-6 weeks, I would go Billings.

 

[amazingjoshy]

Dempsey did average 88 in the VFL last year and only averaged 1.3 goals a game in that, so I'm not sure he necessarily needs goals to score decently

 

[4tune8]

What are people's thoughts on Billings vs Dempsey? Given our forward lines are most likely to be our weakest, points wise, does the higher output of Billings outweigh his higher cost? Or do we expect Dempsey's past few scores to be repeated going forward?

I've gone with the low BE for Dempsey, but it's not a simple X > Y for me.

Trading out Fisher gives me the funds to upgrade Gibcus > Mass plus enough left over for another corrective trade next week or the one after, Wines will stay for another week as his role could've been matchup dependent, his grunt wasn't needed against WCE, might be different this week against the Tigers mids who are more seasoned and bigger bodies.

If I don't trade Gibcus then I'll be down to fielding 21, possibly doesn't matter with best 18 but you never know. I have doubts on Massimo's scoring power, who else to get though? Hore? Pink?

Billings is on the radar, I doubt he reaches the heights of last round again and with Hunter due back in a couple of weeks casts more doubts, although Windsor could lose his spot. Billings is my fall back for Wines in any case.

Bringing Demsey in means fielding an extra rookie up forward but Massimo takes a defence rookie off, well, after the next 2 weeks.

I also have Newcombe and Amon to deal with who both get another week because I can't do anything with them yet, Amon will more than likely go to Flanders after his bye and if Newc spuds it up again this week then he'll be given the arse too.

 

[Gunf]

Dempsey did average 88 in the VFL last year and only averaged 1.3 goals a game in that, so I'm not sure he necessarily needs goals to score decently

The thing about Dempsey was he was a decent forward last year but his talent truly shined when he was give midfield time

A(VFL) game last year in which he tore it apart he had something like 30 an 5 goals after being moved into the midfield.

So he can absolutely score without goals just needs to get on his bike a bit and become an outlet on the wing as he is a great mark and a running machine.

 

[4tune8]

The thing about Dempsey was he was a decent forward last year but his talent truly shined when he was give midfield time

A(VFL) game last year in which he tore it apart he had something like 30 an 5 goals after being moved into the midfield.

So he can absolutely score without goals just needs to get on his bike a bit and become an outlet on the wing as he is a great mark and a running machine.

Looks like a good replacement for Smith

 

[SELFCONFESDAFLNERD]

Z.Williams > Phillips
Lazzaro > Billings

I wanted Bergman but i cant ignore that 140 from Billings, and he should be good for 80ish from now until i can upgrade him.

79k itb

Ash goes next round when he has the bye but hopefully can post a 100 this week against WC. Hoping Grundy bounces back and a score of 110+ from Bont would be nice.