Injury 2024 Injury Thread

[yakamoto]

Not sure that you pick a team on how ou rank individuals. I don’t think Aish’s position in the best 22 has ever been under threat. Has he ever played for Peel since coming to us? Don’t think so.
On the other hand his position in the 22 sometimes comes under threat on Bigfooty, along with about that of 30 or so other members of the squad.

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

Not sure that you pick a team on how ou rank individuals. I don’t think Aish’s position in the best 22 has ever been under threat. Has he ever played for Peel since coming to us? Don’t think so.
On the other hand his position in the 22 sometimes comes under threat on Bigfooty, along with about that of 30 or so other members of the squad.

That is not the original point of my post. Do you think if Aish goes out for a few weeks and Worner comes in playing the same role and potentially playing it well that he immediately kicks him out? That was the point of my post, Aish, is a bottom 5ish best 22 player. You do not give up your spot as one of those players unless you absolutely have to and split webbing isnt going to keep him out

 

[Ge3ks]

Odin Jones will play for Peel on managed minutes.

This is very pleasing news.

 

[Lach72]

Not sure that you pick a team on how ou rank individuals. I don’t think Aish’s position in the best 22 has ever been under threat. Has he ever played for Peel since coming to us? Don’t think so.
On the other hand his position in the 22 sometimes comes under threat on Bigfooty, along with about that of 30 or so other members of the squad.

If Aish played another game like he did against West Coast his position was very much up for discussion

 

[rgauci]

Not sure that you pick a team on how ou rank individuals. I don’t think Aish’s position in the best 22 has ever been under threat. Has he ever played for Peel since coming to us? Don’t think so.
On the other hand his position in the 22 sometimes comes under threat on Bigfooty, along with about that of 30 or so other members of the squad.

He played WAFL beginning of 2022. We won a few games before he worked his way back in.

 

[s_wd6]

He played WAFL beginning of 2022. We won a few games before he worked his way back in.

I think it was more so him playing a WAFL pre season game to build fitness after coming off an injury though. He was back in the team round two. He'll play his 100th game for us this year.

 

[FreoGirl]

Glad to hear Draper is OK

 

[sumavich]

Been a very good pick up Aish. Bit of a barometer for the team really

 

[Minz]

So happy Odin’s coming through the concussion thing. I’ve had post-concussion symptoms; made me utterly miserable!

On another note, is Cox going ok?

 

[gaskin]

So happy Odin’s coming through the concussion thing. I’ve had post-concussion symptoms; made me utterly miserable!

On another note, is Cox going ok?

7-8 weeks down from 7-9 last week which puts him around round 14-15 which is about where we thought he would be.

 

[s_wd6]

7-8 weeks down from 7-9 last week which puts him around round 14-15 which is about where we thought he would be.

Wasn't he 7-9 the week before last too? His timeline has stayed the same for multiple weeks.

 

[freo_leo29]

Wasn't he 7-9 the week before last too? His timeline has stayed the same for multiple weeks.

Nah, he was 9-11 (4 weeks ago) and then repeated 9-11 (3 weeks), then he dropped to 7-9 and now 7-8

So its almost like they forgot to update that 9-11 in between to like an 8-10 or a 10-11

 

[pK75]

Nah, he was 9-11 (4 weeks ago) and then repeated 9-11 (3 weeks), then he dropped to 7-9 and now 7-8

So its almost like they forgot to update that 9-11 in between to like an 8-10 or a 10-11

The freo pessimist in me always looks at the worst case scenario, so 11,11,9,8 in the last 4 weeks. Think you’re right and they missed the 10 week update.

 

[Vintage]

The freo pessimist in me always looks at the worst case scenario, so 11,11,9,8 in the last 4 weeks. Think you’re right and they missed the 10 week update.

Original update 6 weeks ago was 12-14.

So it’s come down by 5-6 weeks in 6 weeks.

Hopefully the 7-8 weeks is ready for senior selection, though I doubt it.

 

[Vimal Anand]

On SM-A205YN using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[apuchar]

If Aish played another game like he did against West Coast his position was very much up for discussion

Everybody was rubbish though

 

[FreoGirl]

Been a very good pick up Aish. Bit of a barometer for the team really

he lives with Fyfe - I wonder if they share head bands lol

 

[noise36]

Top of the ladder!!!

 

[dockerfemme]

Top of the ladder!!!

It is a bit misleading as it is across the entire list, not a best 23 or similar.

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

It is a bit misleading as it is across the entire list, not a best 23 or similar.

Yeah I was wondering why it was so high. If you want to include McDonald, it's still really only half that as a more accurate rep. I assume it's including Corbett and Kuek which is beyond irrelevant

 

[Vintage]

Yeah I was wondering why it was so high. If you want to include McDonald, it's still really only half that as a more accurate rep. I assume it's including Corbett and Kuek which is beyond irrelevant

Yeah, games missed by nominal best 26 players would be much better indicator. Carlton probably struggling the most, we’ve lost a few with cox, Rick, switta, amiss, Chapman, Darcy, maybe count McDonald too?

 

[freoextra]

From the limited vision and photos put out by the club its looks like Amiss, Switta, and more surprising Draper are all ready to go. Must admit I was not expecting Draper to be in sprinting and tackling exercises, he looks good.

 

[s_wd6]

 

[yakamoto]

Draper’s hamstring awareness was probably caused by standing to attention during Saturday’s rematch ceremony.

 

[ubiquitous226]

Yeah, games missed by nominal best 26 players would be much better indicator. Carlton probably struggling the most, we’ve lost a few with cox, Rick, switta, amiss, Chapman, Darcy, maybe count McDonald too?

I reckon Richmond would have something to say there.

Agree those stats are very misleading, best 22ish is best but then it becomes subjective.

The first rung is key players, which would roughly be your top 10
Second is best 22ish, as in who would be first picked on the park
Last I'd suggest would be specific roles, you could only lose 2-3 players but if it's in a specific role or one you have poor depth it can create bigger issues