Prediction 2025 Carlton Predictions

[The Old Dark Navy's]

Let's make some predictions for the 2025 season. If you can think of other things to add, feel free to request them.

1. How many home and away games will Carlton win in 2025?

2. If we make finals, how far will we go?

3. Name our top 3 Brownlow votegetters in order.

4. How many Carlton debuts will we have in 2025 (including players who have played elsewhere previously). Name them.

5. Who will be our 3 leading goalscorers in 2025. Name them in order. Predict their goal tallies if you want to.

6. Name your 3 breakout Carlton players of 2025 (in comparison to their recent form, so out of form players bouncing back counts).

7. Who will be our go to 2nd key defender behind Weitering?

8. A few players have been touted for position changes in 2025. Which position change will be the most successful?

9. This one is awkward. Each year we have to delist a certain amount of players to participate in the draft. Predict the 5 most likely delistings, retirements or trades for Carlton.

10. Name our top 5 B&F placegetters.

 

[Juice030103]

1. 15
2. Prelim/granny loss (can’t decide cause both hurt)
3. Cripps Walsh Cerra
4. Jagga Haynes Lemmey Wilson
5. Curnow Coleman, Harry 45-50, Motlop 30
6. Ollie hollands Elijah hollands Cowan
7. Sos
8. Sos
9. Sadly doc retires, monahan and Fantasia, Hewett doesn’t get offered another contract (bold I know), kemp potentially goes elsewhere
10. Cripps, Weiterbot, Cerra, Walsh, TDK

 

[tarczonandjane]

Great questions, ODN! I don’t know if I have any good answers, but here goes:

1: home and away wins - 13.5 (I am keeping expectations in check)

2: finals - we will make finals and bow out in the first week

3: top 3 in the Brownlow - Cripps, Walsh, TDK

4: debuts - Haynes, Jagga, Lucas C, Ben C, Billy Wilson, Lemmey, Phillips (7)

5: leading goal scorers - Charles, Harry, E Hollands

6: breakout players - Cerra, Binns, C Durdin

7: second defender - hopefully Lewis Young, if not then Phillips, if not then Haynes

8: most successful position change - Ollie Hollands. Neither the JSOS or Kemp moves will work out

9: delistings - Doc to retire, Fantasia to retire, Motlop, Kemp (won’t play well enough for a trade), Young, Cincotta

10: Top 5 B&F - Weitering, Cripps, Charles, Walsh, Acres

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Let's make some predictions for the 2025 season. If you can think of other things to add, feel free to request them.

1. How many home and away games will Carlton win in 2025?

2. If we make finals, how far will we go?

3. Name our top 3 Brownlow votegetters in order.

4. How many Carlton debuts will we have in 2025 (including players who have played elsewhere previously). Name them.

5. Who will be our 3 leading goalscorers in 2025. Name them in order. Predict their goal tallies if you want to.

6. Name your 3 breakout Carlton players of 2025 (in comparison to their recent form, so out of form players bouncing back counts).

7. Who will be our go to 2nd key defender behind Weitering?

8. A few players have been touted for position changes in 2025. Which position change will be the most successful?

9. This one is awkward. Each year we have to delist a certain amount of players to participate in the draft. Predict the 5 most likely delistings, retirements or trades for Carlton.

10. Name our top 5 B&F placegetters.

1. 17

2. Prelim Final

3.
Sam Walsh, Patrick Cripps, Elijah Hollands

4.Three - Jagga Smith, Billy Wilson, Nick Haynes

5.
Harry McKay - 72
Charlie Curnow - 65
Corey Durdin - 34

6.
Sam Walsh
Elijah Hollands
Corey Durdin

7. Nick Haynes

8. Zac Williams

9.
Sam Docherty (retire)
Orazio Fantasia (delist)
Marc Pittonet (trade)
Lewis Young (delist)
Jesse Motlop (trade)

10.
Sam Walsh
Harry Mckay
Jacob Weitering
Patrick Cripps
Elijah Hollands

 

[FitzroyBlueBagger]

1. Win 15/16 games

2. Finals, Top2 H&A, Grand Final

3. Cripps 3rd BM, Walsh, DeKoning

4. Jagga, Haynes, Wilson

5. Charlie 67, Harry 53, Williams 32

6. Cerra Walsh Charlie injury free

. Motlop Moir Durdin youngsters

7. Haynes/Young first half season
. Silvagni second half season

8. Ollie back line Silvagni KPD

9. Fantasia Young Haynes Pittonet possible trade, if we can manage to replace him for a better depth ruck more suited to the games needs…
Probably a trade, who? a piece to benefit our list/draft needs…

10. Cripps, DeKoning, Walsh, Weitering, Cerra

 

[Pralaya]

1. 15 wins – I think we'll take a big step forward this year.
2. Finals – We'll make it, but a heartbreaking prelim loss seems likely.
3. Brownlow – Cripps, Walsh, Cerra.
4. Debuts – Haynes, Lemmey, Phillips.
5. Goals – Curnow (70), McKay (60), Motlop (35).
6. Breakouts – Hollands, Cowan, Durdin.
7. Second key defender – Young or Phillips, depending on form.
8. Position change – Ollie Hollands in the backline.
9. Delistings – Doc (retire), Fantasia (delist), Kemp, Motlop, Pittonet (trade).
10. Top 5 B&F – Cripps, Walsh, Weitering, Cerra, Curnow.

 

[AndyNicka]

1. 14-9 Finishing 6th

2. Semi Finals

3. Cripps, Walsh, Charlie

4. Haynes, Jagger, Wilson, B.Camporeale, L.Camporeale (campo boys to get 1-2 games each) and a smokey in Harry Charleson.

5. Charlie - 80, Harry 50, Mots 28

6. Mots, Lord, Ollie

7. Haynes or Young

8. Ollie to the half back flank.

9. Lemmey, Monahan, Orazio, little Durds (delisted), Kemp (trd)

10. Cripps, Walsh, TDK, Charlie, Cez

 

[The Blue Weirdo]

Question 6 is the interesting one...Mots, Cow and Lord.

 

[Blue and Silver]

Let's make some predictions for the 2025 season. If you can think of other things to add, feel free to request them.

1. How many home and away games will Carlton win in 2025?

2. If we make finals, how far will we go?

3. Name our top 3 Brownlow votegetters in order.

4. How many Carlton debuts will we have in 2025 (including players who have played elsewhere previously). Name them.

5. Who will be our 3 leading goalscorers in 2025. Name them in order. Predict their goal tallies if you want to.

6. Name your 3 breakout Carlton players of 2025 (in comparison to their recent form, so out of form players bouncing back counts).

7. Who will be our go to 2nd key defender behind Weitering?

8. A few players have been touted for position changes in 2025. Which position change will be the most successful?

9. This one is awkward. Each year we have to delist a certain amount of players to participate in the draft. Predict the 5 most likely delistings, retirements or trades for Carlton.

10. Name our top 5 B&F placegetters.

Sure, the off-season needs it's distractions

1. 17

2. Grand Final (Premiership)

3. Sam Walsh, Patrick Cripps, Adam Cerra

4. 7: Haynes, Jagga, Wilson, O'Keefe, Lemmey, L. Camporeale, B. Camporeale.

5. Charlie Curnow - 75 Harry McKay - 54 Jesse Motlop - 36

6. Jaxon Binns, Adam Cerra, Jesse Motlop

7. Jack Silvagni

8. Jack Silvagni

9. Monahan, Fantasia, McGovern, Newman, Kemp

10. Sam Walsh, Charlie Curnow, Patrick Cripps, Adam Cerra, Harry McKay

I think that we go all the way.

I haven't predicted that before. But I feel really good about a lot of the list and where they are at

On Pixel 7a using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Red_man2008]

1: home and away wins - 16

2: finals - GF appearance from there who knows

3: top 3 in the Brownlow - Walsh (winner), Cripps, Jagga

4: debuts - Haynes, Jagga, Wilson, HOK

5: leading goal scorers - Charles, Harry, Motlop, Williams, Moir

6: breakout players - Cowan (a new level), Motlop (2 goals a game average), Moir (a regular inside 50)

7: second defender - we will play all season with 2 versatile 3rd defenders

8: most successful position change - Ollie and JSOS

9: delistings - Doc to retire, Fantasia to retire, Young to delist

10: Top 5 B&F - Walsh, Cripps, Jagga, Charles, Harry

 

[Beyond Blue]

1. 17-6 Finishing 2nd
2. Runner Up (to GWS)
3. Walsh, Cripps, Charlie
4. Haynes, Smith, Wilson, B.Camporeale
5. Charlie 81, Harry 54, Williams 29
6. Cowan, Motlop, Moir
7. Haynes
8. Silvagni to the backline
9. Docherty (retire), Monahan & Fantasia (delisted), Pittonet & Kemp (traded)
10. Walsh, Charlie, Cripps, Weitering, Harry

 

[Bletch]

Let's make some predictions for the 2025 season. If you can think of other things to add, feel free to request them.

1. How many home and away games will Carlton win in 2025? 15

2. If we make finals, how far will we go? Prelim

3. Name our top 3 Brownlow votegetters in order. Walsh, Cripps, Charlie

4. How many Carlton debuts will we have in 2025 (including players who have played elsewhere previously). Name them. 7
Haynes
Wilson
L Campo
O'Keeffe
Smith
Lemmey
+1 SSP

5. Who will be our 3 leading goalscorers in 2025. Name them in order. Predict their goal tallies if you want to.
Charlie 60
H 55
Zac 30

6. Name your 3 breakout Carlton players of 2025 (in comparison to their recent form, so out of form players bouncing back counts).
Cerra
Lord
Smith

7. Who will be our go to 2nd key defender behind Weitering?
Start Haynes, but will be pushed out, perhaps JSOS or one of the SSP picks

8. A few players have been touted for position changes in 2025. Which position change will be the most successful?
Ollie H

9. This one is awkward. Each year we have to delist a certain amount of players to participate in the draft. Predict the 5 most likely delistings, retirements or trades for Carlton.
Haynes - will stay on as an assistant coach
Monahan
Fantasia
Kemp - StK will come after him again
Doc - feel bad about this one in particular, but body may not be up to it. Like Haynes, stay on as an assistant.

10. Name our top 5 B&F placegetters.
Walsh
Cripps
Charlie
Cerra
TDK

 

[athensblue]

1. How many home and away games will Carlton win in 2025? 17

2. If we make finals, how far will we go? it's time 30 yrs on

3. Name our top 3 Brownlow votegetters in order Crippa, Cerra, Newman

4. How many Carlton debuts will we have in 2025 (including players who have played elsewhere previously). Name them.
Haynes
One Campo
SoS, Doc and Mots will seem like debuts

5. Who will be our 3 leading goalscorers in 2025. Name them in order. Predict their goal tallies if you want to.
Charlie, H, Mots


6. Name your 3 breakout Carlton players of 2025 (in comparison to their recent form, so out of form players bouncing back counts).
Cerra, SoS , Lord

7. Who will be our go to 2nd key defender behind Weitering?
 SoS

8. A few players have been touted for position changes in 2025. Which position change will be the most successful?
Elijah, more midfield time

9. This one is awkward. Each year we have to delist a certain amount of players to participate in the draft. Predict the 5 most likely delistings, retirements or trades for Carlton.
Fantasia, after a good year
Haynes
Durds, Binns and Young traded



10. Name our top 5 B&F placegetters.
Cripps
Walsh
sos
Charlie
Cerra

 

[bradfisher14]

1. How many home and away games will Carlton win in 2025?

17

2. If we make finals, how far will we go?

All the way.

3. Name our top 3 Brownlow votegetters in order.

Cripps
Walsh
Curnow

4. How many Carlton debuts will we have in 2025 (including players who have played elsewhere previously). Name them.

Haynes, Smith, L. Camporeale, Wilson, Lemmey, O'Keefe

5. Who will be our 3 leading goalscorers in 2025. Name them in order. Predict their goal tallies if you want to.

Curnow
McKay
Kemp

6. Name your 3 breakout Carlton players of 2025 (in comparison to their recent form, so out of form players bouncing back counts).

Cerra
Motlop
O. Hollands

7. Who will be our go to 2nd key defender behind Weitering?

Silvagni

8. A few players have been touted for position changes in 2025. Which position change will be the most successful?

Kemp

9. This one is awkward. Each year we have to delist a certain amount of players to participate in the draft. Predict the 5 most likely delistings, retirements or trades for Carlton.

Docherty and Haynes retire. Fantasia, Monahan and Cincotta delisted.

10. Name our top 5 B&F placegetters.

Walsh
Cripps
Weitering
E. Hollands
De Koning

 

[Soapy V]

Why not. Subjective and mine are based on not many injuries in 2025

1. How many home and away games will Carlton win in 2025? 17

2. If we make finals, how far will we go? Win it all

3. Name our top 3 Brownlow votegetters in order. Cripps Walsh Cerra

4. How many Carlton debuts will we have in 2025 (including players who have played elsewhere previously). Name them. Haynes Smith O’Keefe Wilson B.Campo L.Campo


5. Who will be our 3 leading goalscorers in 2025. Name them in order. Predict their goal tallies if you want to. Charlie 48 McKay 32 Williams 28

6. Name your 3 breakout Carlton players of 2025 (in comparison to their recent form, so out of form players bouncing back counts). Ollie at HB. Motlop, Boyd

7. Who will be our go to 2nd key defender behind Weitering? Silvagni

8. A few players have been touted for position changes in 2025. Which position change will be the most successful? Ollie to HB

9. This one is awkward. Each year we have to delist a certain amount of players to participate in the draft. Predict the 5 most likely delistings, retirements or trades for Carlton. Young, Haynes, Cottrell, Fantasia, Pittonet

10. Name our top 5 B&F placegetters.

Weitering TDK Cripps Cerra Walsh

 

[CCurnow3votes]

1. How many home and away games will Carlton win in 2025? 16

2. If we make finals, how far will we go? Grand final vs Oldiewood - we win by a generation.

3. Name our top 3 Brownlow votegetters in order. Walsh, Cripps, Cerra.

4. How many Carlton debuts will we have in 2025 (including players who have played elsewhere previously). Name them. 5 - Campo x 2, Jagga, Haynes, O’Keefe.

5. Who will be our 3 leading goalscorers in 2025. Name them in order. Predict their goal tallies if you want to. King Charles 82, Haratio 56, Motlop 28.

6. Name your 3 breakout Carlton players of 2025 (in comparison to their recent form, so out of form players bouncing back counts). Cerra, Motlop, Moir.

7. Who will be our go to 2nd key defender behind Weitering? Haynes.

8. A few players have been touted for position changes in 2025. Which position change will be the most successful? Kemp 3rd Forward Banana

9. This one is awkward. Each year we have to delist a certain amount of players to participate in the draft. Predict the 5 most likely delistings, retirements or trades for Carlton. Monaghan, Carroll, SOS, Pitto, Durdin.

10. Name our top 5 B&F placegetters.
Walsh
Cripps
Cerra
Newman
King Charlie the 1st.

 

[Bryce Bubbles]

1. 17
2. Grand Final, win our 17th
3. Cripps, Walsh, TDK
4. Smith, Haynes, Lemmey and campo(lucas)
5. Curnow 73, Harry 68 and Kemp 33.
6. SOS Cerra and Cowan
7. SOS
8. Kemp forward
9. Carroll Durdin 2 Irish and Binns
10. Cripps Walsh TDK Cerra and weiterbot

 

[marcmurphy3]

1. How many home and away games will Carlton win in 2025? 17

2. If we make finals, how far will we go? Premiership

3. Name our top 3 Brownlow votegetters in order. Cripps Cerra Walsh

4. How many Carlton debuts will we have in 2025 (including players who have played elsewhere previously). Name them. Haynes, Smith, Wilson, L.Camporeale, B.Camporeale, O'Keefe

5. Who will be our 3 leading goalscorers in 2025. Name them in order. Predict their goal tallies if you want to. Charlie 68, McKay 52, Williams 33

6. Name your 3 breakout Carlton players of 2025 (in comparison to their recent form, so out of form players bouncing back counts). O.Hollands, TDK, A.Cerra

7. Who will be our go to 2nd key defender behind Weitering? Haynes

8. A few players have been touted for position changes in 2025. Which position change will be the most successful? O.Hollands

9. This one is awkward. Each year we have to delist a certain amount of players to participate in the draft. Predict the 5 most likely delistings, retirements or trades for Carlton. 1.Fantasia 2. Cincotta 3. Durdin 4. Binns (trade) 5. Kemp (trade)

10. Name our top 5 B&F placegetters.
1. Cerra
2. TDK
3. Cripps
4. Walsh
5. McKay