WaynesWorld19
Moderator
- Moderator
- #1
Interesting
JHF versus Rozee versus Butters ?
JHF versus Rozee versus Butters ?
Opinion 2025 Fantasy - Player X vs Y vs Z
- Thread starter WaynesWorld19
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Thelethal97
Debutant
- Mar 18, 2023
- 136
- 116
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Clarry, Ash, Doch
Can't ignore Clarry, too much upside with a full preseason, even if he only goes high 90s
Barrybran
Premium Platinum
- Jun 18, 2016
- 54,649
- 103,936
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Perth Scorchers
This is a good one. Rozee is underpriced for what he can do. JHF is underpriced because he should comfortably improve. Butters should be the best of the three but I'm not touching him this year.
- Oct 10, 2016
- 892
- 910
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Why Doch last?
JDWCE
Norm Smith Medallist
Coming off ACL + age probably the reason
Sheezel, JHF and Langford (3 rook mids and 1 rook fwd)
or
Sinclair, Rozee and Curtin (2 rook mids and 2 rook fwd)
Sheezel is probably 5-8 points on Sinclair, Rozee is 10-17 points on JHF, So second is ahead but Curtin could be anything, Langford if he plays surely scores more, just how much?
I just think there's so much value in the mids if i go 3 rooks i can only pick one of Green, Rozee and Taranto...
or
Sinclair, Rozee and Curtin (2 rook mids and 2 rook fwd)
Sheezel is probably 5-8 points on Sinclair, Rozee is 10-17 points on JHF, So second is ahead but Curtin could be anything, Langford if he plays surely scores more, just how much?
I just think there's so much value in the mids if i go 3 rooks i can only pick one of Green, Rozee and Taranto...
I’ve gone down from Sheezel to Sinclair as think they will be pretty close.
Sinclair pumped out a 110ave the last 9 rounds once he went more midfield. If he maintains that, that’s what I think Sheezel will max out at as well.
Yeah im seeing Sheezel go 105-108 imo. But if i have spare cash ill just upgrade my top line.
But Macrae coming in means he might play less mid.
That’s true. He’s part the reason I’m not as sold on the Poo being a breakout. Will no doubt have a good game here and there but think Macrae may take his mid minutes there.
I think they want Poo in there for the future so doubt they'd take him out over the older guys, i do think Sinclair will stay back.
Copy and pasted from the SuperCoach board, take with a grain of salt.
This is from a pre season report a few days ago.
Jack Sinclair
While rolling through the midfield across the last two years, the dual All-Australian looks set to remain at half back for now. A lighter day on the track for Sinclair, completing running early with the recovering Anthony Caminiti and Angus McLennan, he worked his way into drills and match simulation where he played the distributor role.
WaynesWorld19
Moderator
- Thread starter
- Moderator
- #13
And do we know if Docherty's role is locked .....won't surprise if he goes back this season
Hmm possibly back to the drawing board then!
Distributor role off half back sounds juicy! Someone's got to take Bonner's junk possessions. Makes me second guess my NWM pick but I'll wait to see preseason games first.
Have 4 variations of 3 different player combos onfield, 1 from backline, mid and ruck. What order would you go?
farrell-langford-dekoning 155k left
hawli-petracca-dekoning 36k left
hawli-peatling-marshall 24k left
burton-langford-marshall 2k left
farrell-langford-dekoning 155k left
hawli-petracca-dekoning 36k left
hawli-peatling-marshall 24k left
burton-langford-marshall 2k left
I think it's a bit early to commit to Farrell or Burton just yet. L. Evans seems just as likely to take kick-ins. Worth waiting to see how their roles play out during the preseason games.
I like option 3. You get a definite keeper in Marshall and Peatling should make some decent cash if given a midfield role.
Yeah cant do much till we see it in preseason and even then it's not a given.
Was leaning towards 3 already. But yeah it means fielding 2 rook defenders and only 2 rook mids, which im a little worried about but means i can get the value in the mids where as i don't see it in the defenders apart from Burton/Farrell.
Phar Ace
Brownlow Medallist
And Opening Round gives you a 'sighter' of just one of those mentioned
