List Mgmt. 2025 List management

[Docker82]

We’ve all seen this before.

Andy heading into 2025 unsigned.

I’m not confident we keep him.

Yea, we’ve seen a free agent leave Freo. It was Chris Mayne eight years ago (nine by next year).

 

[eastfreo75]

McVee isn't really as needed as Pickett

Moneyball.

Pickett is better, greater need and will cost a lot more. He is contracted for years, and Melbourne won't him go for cheap.

McVee is out of contract. Massive different. Demons has no leverage.

 

[Docker82]

Moneyball.

Pickett is better, greater need and will cost a lot more. He is contracted for years, and Melbourne won't him go for cheap.

McVee is out of contract. Massive different. Demons has no leverage.

If we finish as high as we probably should McVee would nearly cost us a first rounder. Just a second rounder wouldn’t cut it - put it that way.

 

[Taylor]

Then it can be:

Second round pick, fourth round pick and future second

for

McVee, second round pick and future fourth round pick


/\

This is the Ed Langdon trade btw.

 

[Docker82]

Then it can be:

Second round pick, fourth round pick and future second

for

McVee, second round pick and future fourth round pick


/\

This is the Ed Langdon trade btw.

Melbourne also finished second last in 2019.

 

[eastfreo75]

If we finish as high as we probably should McVee would nearly cost us a first rounder. Just a second rounder wouldn’t cut it - put it that way.

Late first round is a pick in the early twenties.

I’m ok with that.

 

[Sherriff Incorporated]

Late first round is a pick in the early twenties.

I’m ok with that.

A late first round pick will be taken in the late first round bar free agent compensation in 2025 due to bid matching changes . Many clubs were unhappy with the draft compensation given to StKilda this year and North Melbourne the year before (including Carlton and Collingwood) so for that reason alone I think the formula for draft compensation will be less waited towards teams losing a player this year.

 

[theGav56]

Then it can be:

Second round pick, fourth round pick and future second

for

McVee, second round pick and future fourth round pick


/\

This is the Ed Langdon trade btw.

Brilliant

 

[Docker82]

A late first round pick will be taken in the late first round bar free agent compensation in 2025 due to bid matching changes . Many clubs were unhappy with the draft compensation given to StKilda this year and North Melbourne the year before (including Carlton and Collingwood) so for that reason alone I think the formula for draft compensation will be less waited towards teams losing a player this year.

Lol. Teams other than the team being compensated have always been unhappy with free agency compensation since the stupid system was put on place. Nothing will change.

 

[Taylor]

Melbourne also finished second last in 2019.

They can finish second last in 2025, I'm ok with that.

I know what you mean but we had a second round pick only 4 spots worse than theirs.

 

[Dockeroo]

I don’t think Brayshaw will leave at all and the fact that he didn’t sign at Christmas is not relevant. However I’d be mildly raising my eyebrows if he’s not signed by round 1.
That indicates at the very least he’s listening to offers (as he should by the way, it’s a professional sport after all).

If we are only offering him say, $1m a year and another club are offering him $1.5m, he’s got an obligation to stop, take his time and consider it fully with his partner and family.
We all would do the same if in that situation.