Teams 2025 Rate My Pre-Season Team

[A Bit Dusty]

Just a heads up kents if you didn't know you can copy & paste you team in one go clicking on this.

 

[A Bit Dusty]

This is what I mean when I say that people vastly overestimate the amount of scoring players will achieve.

Here is a list of all Supercoach averages of 125+ in reverse chronological order:

2024:

126.8 Marcus Bontempelli

2023:

129.7 Marcus Bontempelli
128.0 Tim English

2022:

127.8 Rory Laird
127.1 Clayton Oliver

2021:

128.6 Jack Macrae
126.0 Jack Steele

2020:

139.9 Max Gawn
134.4 Lachie Neale

2019:

130.0 Brodie Grundy
128.4 Max Gawn

2018:

130.5 Brodie Grundy
129.1 Tom Mitchell
127.5 Max Gawn
127.1 Jack Macrae

2017:

136.4 Patrick Dangerfield

2016:

131.8 Patrick Dangerfield

2015:

128.8 Todd Goldstein

2014:

136.7 Gary Ablett Jr.
126.2 Scott Pendlebury

2013:

128.8 Gary Ablett Jr.
126.6 Scott Pendlebury

2012:

139.2 Gary Ablett Jr.

2011:

127.7 Scott Pendlebury
125.2 Dean Cox.

I don't have easy access to stats before 2011.

You could be right, but you're basically saying that Butters and Daicos will be the best 2 players in Supercoach in 2025, with the small caveat if you prefer aggregate over average, and reckon 120 over 23 games beats 125 over 22 games, or if you think the average split will be lower at the start of the season (Say 115 over the first 8 weeks then
130ish for the rest of the season
).

Without those caveats, you're basically picking Butters and Daicos M1 and M2 right now.

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Everyone remember what Nick Watson did this year?
Well Joe Berry will be better again and No one is picking him

 

[Floating Doughnut]

Everyone remember what Nick Watson did this year?
Well Joe Berry will be better again and No one is picking him

View attachment 2193180

Not no one.

Christian Moraes is the other one @ Alberton turning heads apparently
or is this not correct Nelso

 

[Jim Irwins Heart]

 

[MacStradbroke]

First crack at it this year, pretty similar to a lot of other teams posted.

• keen to run with Trac & Oliver at their starting prices if travelling well heading into r1.
• Will Ashcroft I’m not sure has run games out well enough to be selected so far, but the Grand Final might just be his coming out party, he was phenomenal in that game. A few options in this price range though.
• will start a ruck in the flex position, whether that Flynn or a big dog!
• Tried leaving out Bont, agree there is no value, but it’s Bont, team feels light without him.
• No idea how Pedlar is tracking, and his mid minutes are probably goneski with Peatling coming in and Rankine, Soligo, etc needing more time in there, but I do rate him. More than likely won’t last in the team.
• Xerri & TDK like most, not sure who the other options are. Meek bye issue, Gawn has to slow down at some point, and had English last year…that was a brutal watch at times.

 

[Choppers]

View attachment 2193272

First crack at it this year, pretty similar to a lot of other teams posted.

• keen to run with Trac & Oliver at their starting prices if travelling well heading into r1.
• Will Ashcroft I’m not sure has run games out well enough to be selected so far, but the Grand Final might just be his coming out party, he was phenomenal in that game. A few options in this price range though.
• will start a ruck in the flex position, whether that Flynn or a big dog!
• Tried leaving out Bont, agree there is no value, but it’s Bont, team feels light without him.
• No idea how Pedlar is tracking, and his mid minutes are probably goneski with Peatling coming in and Rankine, Soligo, etc needing more time in there, but I do rate him. More than likely won’t last in the team.
• Xerri & TDK like most, not sure who the other options are. Meek bye issue, Gawn has to slow down at some point, and had English last year…that was a brutal watch at times.

Xerri and TDK both have R12 byes. Meek Rd4 and 15

 

[ArdentEagle]

View attachment 2193272

First crack at it this year, pretty similar to a lot of other teams posted.

• keen to run with Trac & Oliver at their starting prices if travelling well heading into r1.
• Will Ashcroft I’m not sure has run games out well enough to be selected so far, but the Grand Final might just be his coming out party, he was phenomenal in that game. A few options in this price range though.
• will start a ruck in the flex position, whether that Flynn or a big dog!
• Tried leaving out Bont, agree there is no value, but it’s Bont, team feels light without him.
• No idea how Pedlar is tracking, and his mid minutes are probably goneski with Peatling coming in and Rankine, Soligo, etc needing more time in there, but I do rate him. More than likely won’t last in the team.
• Xerri & TDK like most, not sure who the other options are. Meek bye issue, Gawn has to slow down at some point, and had English last year…that was a brutal watch at times.

My humble opinion - Looks good except for the DPP switching ability (this far out)

 

[Floating Doughnut]

View attachment 2193272

First crack at it this year, pretty similar to a lot of other teams posted.

• keen to run with Trac & Oliver at their starting prices if travelling well heading into r1.
• Will Ashcroft I’m not sure has run games out well enough to be selected so far, but the Grand Final might just be his coming out party, he was phenomenal in that game. A few options in this price range though.
• will start a ruck in the flex position, whether that Flynn or a big dog!
• Tried leaving out Bont, agree there is no value, but it’s Bont, team feels light without him.
• No idea how Pedlar is tracking, and his mid minutes are probably goneski with Peatling coming in and Rankine, Soligo, etc needing more time in there, but I do rate him. More than likely won’t last in the team.
• Xerri & TDK like most, not sure who the other options are. Meek bye issue, Gawn has to slow down at some point, and had English last year…that was a brutal watch at times.

Forget the cyclist mate at least early on , currently off track injured and will find it hard this year.

 

[stevebbb]

View attachment 2193260

Completely forgot about Ashcroft. Locked and loaded.

Full MPM in 2025 is a go!

 

[Better Loosen Up]

Merry Christmas ya filthy animals

Have a great day!

 

[SELFCONFESDAFLNERD]

$890k itb

Relatively happy with this effort. Fit a few PODs in there and im confident in almost every player ive selected being undervalued. Will take a lot of will power to not make several upgrades prior to round 1 but if i can leave 500k+ in the bank and still be happy with my team, ill have reached my goal.

 

[TryAnHit]

$890k itb

Relatively happy with this effort. Fit a few PODs in there and im confident in almost every player ive selected being undervalued. Will take a lot of will power to not make several upgrades prior to round 1 but if i can leave 500k+ in the bank and still be happy with my team, ill have reached my goal.


View attachment 2193497

That team either wins or you have deleted the SC app by round 4

 

[SELFCONFESDAFLNERD]

That team either wins or you have deleted the SC app by round 4

Most likely the latter haha

 

[Eagling]

$890k itb

Relatively happy with this effort. Fit a few PODs in there and im confident in almost every player ive selected being undervalued. Will take a lot of will power to not make several upgrades prior to round 1 but if i can leave 500k+ in the bank and still be happy with my team, ill have reached my goal.


View attachment 2193497

I do like the idea of leaving a lot of change in the bank, but I think you've got a few issues. Don't think Ginbey presents much value; if you're looking to gamble on someone from West Coast playing in defence then Ryan Maric (F/M $223, 800) seems to be a better option. Don't see Brodie doing anything this year either. I can see Rivers and Weddle both being undervalue but are either getting to that 100+ level?

 

[A Bit Dusty]

I do like the idea of leaving a lot of change in the bank, but I think you've got a few issues. Don't think Ginbey presents much value; if you're looking to gamble on someone from West Coast playing in defence then Ryan Maric (F/M $223, 800) seems to be a better option. Don't see Brodie doing anything this year either. I can see Rivers and Weddle both being undervalue but are either getting to that 100+ level?

I can't see Rivers and Weddle being anywhere near Top 10 scoring defenders. Who gets the Barrass role now is it Maric?

 

[Eagling]

I can't see Rivers and Weddle being anywhere near Top 10 scoring defenders. Who gets the Barrass role now is it Maric?

I'd say Harry Edwards; I think Maric is being groomed for that 3rd tall/outlet role.

 

[marcmurphy3]

I looked at Flynn’s history yesterday …. didn’t realise how poor a scorer he is …. best season ave in the 70’s

Fingers crossed he represents better value than on paper

Hes gone 84+ 3 times?

 

[ArdentEagle]

Flynn may not even be 1st choice ruck and even if he is, he can be injury prone.

Odd choice for mine and I am a blind supporter.

 

[Floating Doughnut]

First real play around .
Really want to start Matty Roberts but not knowing where Mills is playing and that new Arthur Shelby look a like
Bice rebound defender, need some ps games .

 

[Jiska]

1.0

All players below 150k placeholders.

Come at me.

 

[Jiska]

$890k itb

Relatively happy with this effort. Fit a few PODs in there and im confident in almost every player ive selected being undervalued. Will take a lot of will power to not make several upgrades prior to round 1 but if i can leave 500k+ in the bank and still be happy with my team, ill have reached my goal.


View attachment 2193497

That’s really redefining mid-price madness

 

[Jiska]

Wait. WTF. Has there been a pricing change? No 102k players anymore?

 

[weltschmerz]

Wait. WTF. Has there been a pricing change? No 102k players anymore?

Rock bottom rookie price is 99k. Prices have shifted downward to account for an extra player in the flex role.

 

[Jiska]

Nice set-up, Buttman.

JHF, Pou, Rivers, and Flynn were all in my first iteration, and Kiddy would be there too if not for the injury.

Kiddy injury? But you have Mills, Oliver, Petracca, B Smith and T Lynch. Take the leap.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Wait. WTF. Has there been a pricing change? No 102k players anymore?

Same team budget, but we have to pick 31 players now .....there's been a 3% overall reduction in player pricing and on a $10M budget ...that's $300K allocated for player #31