Trades 2025 Round 3 Trades

[Jiska]

Bice has a Bye. You can wait a week.

 

[toxic]

Hello experienced kents , thoughts on these ?

Solid trades, not sure on Reid - rate his footy ability, not his SC scoring.
As I assume Reid is a bench rookie, would you go early on Bice or Clay Hall instead of Reid

 

[Rustymagoo]

I know its supposed to be rookie correction week but I think I will be doing these trades. I feel like I have most of the good rookies and know that I cant get them all. I hope that these are upgrades:


Leaving my team like this with less than 10k itb:



Might just wait a week on Bice.

 

[gutsroy]

I was unwilling to blow up my side to get a decent playing 2nd ruckman.

The early bye rounds and the pressure they take off avoiding donuts was part of the calculated risk I took when I decided to run him at R2.

Admittedly I was anticipating an injury, not being so bad as an actual ruckman that the man he was recruited to replace looked a better option after a single game haha.

I completely understand your decision to move him on.

I hope you end up regretting it though obviously

SC aside, I hope he sticks it up me, tbh
Imagine you got stuck behind a bloke you just couldn’t get past at GWS in the pecking order, decide to pull up stumps and move across the country, finally get back to being first ruck despite your trials and triibulations in the offseason, then you come up against a bloke who is just a bad matchup for you first up, you’re maybe a touch off your tucker, and you end up behind BJ Williams in the pecking order after a single game.
Bailey J is a good Kananook boy, from memory, and he’ll give you everything he’s got, but he’s just an honest toiler.
Flynn would be more than a touch flat and I hope he gets another crack soon.
@big Flynny: Scoops respects the terms of the TRO and I promise that wasn’t me outside your window last night.
I was at home quilting. No witnesses, sadly, maaaate, but you can take my word for it , Matty, no need to call the cops, maaaate

 

[gutsroy]

M Reid and COS can both work out, but there are definite clouds on the horizon in both cases.
Fyfe and Young, Kolo and Stewart either quick return or not missing out the squeeze on them both.
Can't figure rout if that is worth a boost, Bice is a given next week within the quota

 

[morningbrown]

Changed my mind a bit

Still done JHF to Simpkin and Day to Cerra. Have gone with dumping Durham(I love him but the scoring isn’t there for an M4) and gone up to Rowell. Still leaves me 110k ITB. Next week Short and FOS are gone.

 

[swindle]

Probably this, maybe a different rook to cos

 

[Lord De Goey]

With Lindsay in flex I think it’s quite apparent that I’ve started with the wrong structure. I’m reluctant to sideways premiums, especially ones I expect to bounce back, but would it be worthwhile trading Trac to fix my structure?

It’s a shame I can’t quite afford one of Whitfield, Zorko or Sinclair as I’d say these trades would be a no brainer

 

[Makeshift Park]

Changed my trades again.
Short to Dale
Paton to Lindsay
Jhf to Simpkin
220k left to upgrade fos or Tsatas to baz next week.
I'm going to skip cos I don't think he plays full time and Chris Scott.
View attachment 2260129

Not worried about round 12 mate?

 

[Lord De Goey]

Disregard that I think I’ll just keep my trades nice and simple

 

[iDon]

M Reid and COS can both work out, but there are definite clouds on the horizon in both cases.
Fyfe and Young, Kolo and Stewart either quick return or not missing out the squeeze on them both.
Can't figure rout if that is worth a boost, Bice is a given next week within the quota

I reckon Reid has more stability then COS, but its a -BE game and we need cash, think either are fine to pick up.

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

Does Connor O’Sullivan have any JS?

Doesnt Kolo come back soon?

Would consider a trade for him if Cats fans think he is safe. If not, ill wait for Bice.

 

[buttox]

Not worried about round 12 mate?

Not really. Plenty of water to go under the bridge by then

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

Isnt Tsatas only missing a game they reckon? And its best 18 this week. Why is everyone trading him?

 

[Makeshift Park]

Not really. Plenty of water to go under the bridge by then

Fair enough.

No matter what way you slice it, the forward line is gonna bloody tricky that week.

JHF, Daniel, Darcy, Simpkin and Sanders will all be out.

 

[buttox]

Fair enough.

No matter what way you slice it, the forward line is gonna bloody tricky that week.

JHF, Daniel, Darcy, Simpkin and Sanders will all be out.

Yep but jhf to simpkin is a wash for that.
Both r12 bye.
Dale coming in in defence adds one though. But I reckon he's a must have and at 530k will never be cheaper.

 

[Makeshift Park]

Yep but jhf to simpkin is a wash for that.
Both r12 bye.
Dale coming in in defence adds one though. But I reckon he's a must have and at 530k will never be cheaper.

I agree.

I ask because I'm facing the same problem.

 

[SC fish]

Isnt Tsatas only missing a game they reckon? And its best 18 this week. Why is everyone trading him?

To get bubble boys I missed.

 

[buttox]

I agree.

I ask because I'm facing the same problem.

View attachment 2260365

I don't think we can carry spud mid pricers or premos in best 18. Good trades

 

[AFDogs]

Day > Callaghan
Perryman > Holmes
Tsatas > Lindsay

Locked in. Need to try and stay in the top 300.

Holmes absolutely kissed on the dick last week so looking for more of that action now he's in my team. Feel like I've made the right moves as long as Day doesn't go absolutely nuts. Hopefully cops a nice Bedford tag before his bye.

 

[gutsroy]

What about Henderson?
Forgot about him, numbers are alright., stack up fine vs either MReio or COS , how's the JS?

 

[rye]

FOS / Tsatas --> M Reid
Hastie --> Henderson

COS is probably slightly preferable to M Reid if you think he has job security. I don't.

 

[gutsroy]

I reckon Reid has more stability then COS, but its a -BE game and we need cash, think either are fine to pick up.

Yeah, hadn't thought about Henderson, but also an option
Paid more attention to Lindsay last week.
ZReid, Prior, Tsatas all potential issues, depending, moving Paton / one of them might justify a boost
Reid looks very good, but ,$ wise, COS / Henderson probably better in the short run

 

[Deliverance]

I know its supposed to be rookie correction week but I think I will be doing these trades. I feel like I have most of the good rookies and know that I cant get them all. I hope that these are upgrades:

View attachment 2260282
Leaving my team like this with less than 10k itb:

View attachment 2260284

Might just wait a week on Bice.

Rookies aren't the only (or best) cash cows

 

[gutsroy]

Isnt Tsatas only missing a game they reckon? And its best 18 this week. Why is everyone trading him?

Think just because he likely misses two weeks and it slows cash generation.Parish would impact.
Want to hold him personally, ok for the TOG

 

[Borgan]

Locked in Perryman to Dale.
Deciding between:

1. Stewart to Freijah
FOS to Callaghan, leaves me with 13k and 16 premos

2. Stewart/Short to Whitfield
FOS to Henderson, 50-130k with 15 premos

3. Stewart to Whitfield
Short to Freijah, 100k and 15 premos