Player Watch #22: Josh Caddy - Retired

[TigerImposter]

He slightly got better when the rain came down and reduced the game to his scrappy level, but against an inferior opponent he was overall below average. Eagles will be rubbing their wings together when they see him floating back defensively as he’s a plodder.

 

[THE THIN MAN]

Caddy will be better for the run, can not question his courage when he was running with the flight of the ball.

 

[RFCGloryJC]

Sensational goal from the pocket.
Brilliant effort.
For me, it was the highlight of the night.
Up close and personal.

 

[Cdog71]

I think it’s great and adds another threat.
It also takes the expectation off Ellis to be more attacking, if Caddy can handle the responsability and sacrifice for the team to be defensive, it’s not like we need to ask or train much into him to take a chance to sneak a goal or two it’s already in his nature

 

[JAKLAUGHING]

May still end up forward with JR out!

 

[tora tora tora]

Sensational goal from the pocket.
Brilliant effort.
For me, it was the highlight of the night.
Up close and personal.

OK he gets another week on his defensive wing. See if he can start developing his game. Can Kmac play Ellis' wing?

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

We’re kidding ourselves if we think he’s best 22. Plays with lead boots and has no idea how to defend. Surely the experiment is over with KMac Pickett and Ross all better options.
Makes us look too bloody slow and he’s often where the ball aint.

Has the turning circle of a B Double.

 

[Grrr]

To be fair he needs to be given more than a week to see if he can play wing.

 

[fargothegreat]

May still end up forward with JR out!

Jack is out??

 

[JAKLAUGHING]

Jack is out??

Nahhhh...just thinking out aloud here if JR doesn't hit that scoreboard harder the MC may look at Caddy up forward in his place!

 

[matt_y106]

Nahhhh...just thinking out aloud here if JR doesn't hit that scoreboard harder the MC may look at Caddy up forward in his place!

Lol no


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[tiger_tough]

Get's another week just for going back with the flight without hesitation in the 3rd ( I think). Was tough.

Not sure wing is his position. I'd like to see him playing high half forward.

 

[cairo tiger]

chol ahead of him atm, more tricks

 

[tiger_tough]

chol ahead of him atm, more tricks

More tricks? 3 disposals (2 of them effective), 6 hitouts, 3 marks and 3 score involvements in 62% game time.

If Caddy had those numbers there would be outrage. Chol has shown plenty and has big potential but that was a really poor game. Needs a spell.

Time to see how Nank and Soldo can work together.

 

[cairo tiger]

More tricks? 3 disposals (2 of them effective), 6 hitouts, 3 marks and 3 score involvements in 62% game time.

If Caddy had those numbers there would be outrage. Chol has shown plenty and has big potential but that was a really poor game. Needs a spell.

Time to see how Nank and Soldo can work together.

He has more adaptability- I don’t need to stats to back that up- caddy can only play fwd this kid can play fwd ruck and sweeping of backline

 

[TigerImposter]

More tricks? 3 disposals (2 of them effective), 6 hitouts, 3 marks and 3 score involvements in 62% game time.

If Caddy had those numbers there would be outrage. Chol has shown plenty and has big potential but that was a really poor game. Needs a spell.

Time to see how Nank and Soldo can work together.

Chol makes an opposition big man accountable whereas Caddy doesn’t.
Caddy doesn’t really make anyone accountable atm bc he doesn’t have a role to play whereas Chol does. This is the problem we have with him.

 

[Vassp]

You , can’t beleie im hearing this about caddy, he is in our top 15 for you know who’s sake.
How many did he kick last year. Obviously he has to get his mojo and body right.

 

[Poska]

You , can’t beleie im hearing this about caddy, he is in our top 15 for you know who’s sake.
How many did he kick last year. Obviously he has to get his mojo and body right.

How long do we allow him? Unfortunately time is running out. I don’t see him as best 22 anymore.

 

[TigerImposter]

You , can’t beleie im hearing this about caddy, he is in our top 15 for you know who’s sake.
How many did he kick last year. Obviously he has to get his mojo and body right.

That was last year and if you were on the ball his last month or more were mediocre. He was found out late last year and his lack of speed and height were both being exposed. I’m not one that delves on past form as it’s irrelevant to current form.

 

[Vassp]

How long do we allow him? Unfortunately time is running out. I don’t see him as best 22 anymore.

If we are serious ? How many players have been riding the recovery wagon?

 

[Vassp]

That was last year and if you were on the ball his last month or more were mediocre. He was found out late last year and his lack of speed and height were both being exposed. I’m not one that delves on past form as it’s irrelevant to current form.

Like you were on the ball with Lynch ? Hahah. I’m on it, l know a quality player when l see one.

 

[TigerImposter]

Like you were on the ball with Lynch ? Hahah. I’m on it, l know a quality player when l see one.

I was on the ball with him and he’s corrected most of the issues I had with him. Mute point.
Answer what I stated and not deflect the discussion to school kid levels.

 

[Vassp]

Ccddddddd

I was on the ball with him and he’s corrected most of the issues I had with him. Mute point.
Answer what I stated and not deflect the discussion to school kid levels.

ok I’ll play ball, caddy kicked 42 goals last year, so obviously he can play. This year he is struggling with injuries and form. Is he slow? Yes, but he is a tank and tanks are slower. Is he a great set shot and has goals smarts ? Yes..
He Is a hard match up, and am l the only one who can see how dangerous he is up forwards ? No because Wayne carey thinks likewise.

 

[tora tora tora]

Has the turning circle of a B Double.

Hits packs like a B double too

 

[TigerImposter]

Ccddddddd

ok I’ll play ball, caddy kicked 42 goals last year, so obviously he can play. This year he is struggling with injuries and form. Is he slow? Yes, but he is a tank and tanks are slower. Is he a great set shot and has goals smarts ? Yes..
He Is a hard match up, and am l the only one who can see how dangerous he is up forwards ? No because Wayne carey thinks likewise.

He’s slow as a wet week and there’s no position for him. Opposition sides have worked out his flaws and will expose us when he’s on the park.