Toast 250 Shades of Gray

[Hot Port]

Robbie, Robbie, let him entertain you!
Robbie great!

Best commentaries of all time!

 

[Arsene Wenger]

My top 5 in our AFL era

1 Gray
2 Warren
3 Chad
4 Peter B
5 Boak / Wanganeen

 

[El Zorro]

My top 5 in our AFL era

1 Gray
2 Warren
3 Chad
4 Peter B
5 Boak / Wanganeen

Very humble of you mate.

 

[Janey]

My top 5 in our AFL era

1 Gray
2 Warren
3 Chad
4 Peter B
5 Boak / Wanganeen

2nd? Now you’re just being modest.

snap

 

[Arsene Wenger]

Very humble of you mate.

you guys are fkd. I am not Warren

 

[El Zorro]

My top 5 in our AFL era

1 Gray
2 Warren
3 Chad
4 Peter B
5 Boak / Wanganeen

Mine would be pretty close. I still think winning a flag gives you extra points (even if it is outside your control).

1. Tredders
2. Gray
3. Chad
4. Wangas
5. Peter B

 

[Eddie Dingle]

you guys are fkd. I am not Warren

I have never been so humbled. Being called fkd by you is a lifetime highlight.

Thanks Waz.

 

[Eddie Dingle]

FWIW my Top 5 AFL Era

1. Arsene Wenger
2. Chadbro
3. Robbie Gray
4. Gavin Wanganeen
5. Darren Pfeiffer Travis Boak

 

[TeeKray]

My top 5:

1 - Wingard
2 - Tredrea
3 - Gray
4 - Boak
5 - Wanganeen

 

[backtozero]

1. Gray/Tredders - I'm not splitting them
2. Wanganeen
3. C. Cornes
4. Boak
5. P. Burg
6. Schulz

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

My top 10 AFL PAFC players.. May be controversial

1- Tredrea
2- Gray
3- Boak
4- Wanganeen
5- Chad Cornes
6- Kane Cornes
7- Wingard
8- Peter B
9- Lade
10- Jonas

 

[Enviable Tradition]

you guys are fkd. I am not Warren

And honestly if he was then continually drawing attention to it would likely hound him off of the board.

Time to move on from an old meme.

 

[Eddie Dingle]

And honestly if he was then continually drawing attention to it would likely hound him off of the board.

Time to move on from an old meme.

Don’t you dare try and tell me how to love Warren Tredrea. Don’t you dare.

 

[Ford Fairlane]

My top 5:

1 - Wingard
2 - Tredrea
3 - Gray
4 - Boak
5 - Wanganeen

I thought you would have included Hinkley for his coaching contribution

 

[Schulzenfest]

1. John Butcher
Tied for second - Everyone else except Ben Jacobs
468th - Ben Jacobs

 

[VineValerian]

My top 10 AFL PAFC players.. May be controversial

1- Tredrea
2- Gray
3- Boak
4- Wanganeen
5- Chad Cornes
6- Kane Cornes
7- Wingard
8- Peter B
9- Lade
10- Jonas

Would agree with most of those placings.
Maybe Primus gets a look in, although he had a lot of injuries.

 

[Ford Fairlane]

Ricciuto says he's the bestest!

 

[MrMeaner]

Absolutely one of our best. I have him just behind Tredders in my assessment but there isn't much between them.

I had forgotten how bad that 2012 knee injury was. It was extraordinary to come back from that. To do so and have a season like 2014 was extraordinary.

I also love the story Ford shared about his TAC days. He didn't start in the Port but he might have well have been.

 

[Ray Nolan]

The only thing holding him back from being our greatest AFL player is the lack of a flag. Until then, Tredders has him covered. That said, Robbie has been an incredible servant for our Football Club, we've been truly blessed to have him. Hopefully he's got another couple of seasons in him.

 

[Arsene Wenger]

And honestly if he was then continually drawing attention to it would likely hound him off of the board.

Time to move on from an old meme.

good point. I am herewith taking some time away from the board for personal reasons.

 

[jonasshirtfront]

What a player, and he's still dragging us over the line at 32 years of age. At this point I can't separate him and Tredrea for the best in our AFL era, he's an out and out champion.

Went into the midfield and was a ball winning machine, dancing through packs and shaking off tackles with a wiggle of the hips, while also kicking absolute bags of goals when he was required up forward. Love him.

 

[HHHAMMERtime]

That 2014 season was the best overall season by a player I’ve seen in my 15 years watching footy in my opinion. 5.8 clearances a game, 1.68 goals, 12 contested possessions, 12.84 uncontested. That is an average of 25 touches, 6 clearances and 1.6 goals a game for a season. Absolutely astounding. One of the biggest disgraces that he didn’t win the Brownlow that year!

Cannot state how much I love this bloke, makes me so happy that he played at Port Adelaide because I know if he played anywhere else I’d just be jealous that we didn’t have him.

still having game winning moments even now. Don’t think anyone else deserves to reach this milestone more given the horrible ACL injury and and then the cancer.

 

[FishingRick04]

you guys are fkd. I am not Warren

Of course not, but Lord Tredrea however

 

[FishingRick04]

Tredrea
Gray
Primus
Wanganeen
Chad

Locked and loaded.

Primus caused the AFL to change a rule FFS he was that good.

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

Tredrea
Gray
Primus
Wanganeen
Chad

Locked and loaded.

Primus caused the AFL to change a rule FFS he was that good.

How can you not have boak