Delisted #29: Joel 'Scarface' Smith – banned for four years and delisted

Remove this Banner Ad

love supporting the Melbourne footy club :rainbow:

Will be open season now on secrets that journos have closed ranks to preserve. Between Clarry and Smith, it is public interest rather than private stories. Would not be surprised if we started next year with a new coach at the very least

Nobody self destructs better than us.

Time for a clean out, take a broom through the entire place.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Completely and utterly backed ourselves into a hole here. Imagine how the group and media are gonna react to this if we don't support him the same way we supported Oliver.

Whos doing coke the week of the finals when he already missed the flag injured
 
Last edited:
Completely and utterly backed ourselves into a hole hear. Imagine how the group and media are gonna react to this if we don't support him the same way we supported Oliver.

Whos doing coke the week of the finals when he already missed the flag injured

Would be fine with it if we cut them both.

The coach can piss off too.
 
Wheels falling off culturally
100% this.
Don't care how little or deep Goodwin is involved in creating this culture, but given his recent history, he just has to go.
(who am I kidding, he's balls deep in it)

If not, how many more drug related issues would it take before you change your mind? 1 more? 2?
 
Last edited:
Would be fine with it if we cut them both.

The coach can piss off too.
Yep if there's anything saving this club we need to sweep a broom through the issues now. Judd left WC to escape the shit. Not gonna be surprised if we lose a player who's more cleanskin at this rate.
 
This what happens when youre too soft coz youre a "players coach" , as a coach you still need to be able to put the fear of god into players.

Not blaming Goody for all the issues coz they are grown adults, but ive got no doubt he's let them get away with stuff others wouldnt so they keep pushing the boundaries knowing he/we will let them off.
 
Don't care how little or deep Goodwin is involved in creating this culture, but given his recent history, he just us to go.

If not, how many more drug related issues would it take before you change your mind? 1 more? 2?

It’s important to remember that the issue is he got caught - coke use is rife in the AFL. Many players from all clubs use it weekly, that is fact.

This doesn’t excuse Smith for doing it in the days before a game, but to blame it on Goody is a stretch imv.

That being said, we definitely have issues and the club should announce a review immediately. I would like to see the playing group come out and institute a ban on alcohol for the 2024 season but that’s probably out of the question.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Nobody self destructs better than us.

Time for a clean out, take a broom through the entire place.
Not sure who leads the charge on that one. Roffey and Pert have backed Goodwin to the hilt.

All set up for Glen Bartlett's glorious return. Like Chairman Mao he will utilise a cultural revolution to overthrow his usurpers.
 
Not sure who leads the charge on that one. Roffey and Pert have backed Goodwin to the hilt.

All set up for Glen Bartlett's glorious return. Like Chairman Mao he will utilise a cultural revolution to overthrow his usurpers.

At the very least the entire club needs an independent review from top to bottom.
 
It’s important to remember that the issue is he got caught - coke use is rife in the AFL. Many players from all clubs use it weekly, that is fact.

This doesn’t excuse Smith for doing it in the days before a game, but to blame it on Goody is a stretch imv.

That being said, we definitely have issues and the club should announce a review immediately. I would like to see the playing group come out and institute a ban on alcohol for the 2024 season but that’s probably out of the question.
This post is fine, if you ignore the giant elephant in Gawns living room
 
Not sure who leads the charge on that one. Roffey and Pert have backed Goodwin to the hilt.

All set up for Glen Bartlett's glorious return. Like Chairman Mao he will utilise a cultural revolution to overthrow his usurpers.
Keen for Bartlett's Great Leap Forward! We can seize the Jaguars from the Jaguar sponsorship and re-allocate them to the members!
 
Keen for Bartlett's Great Leap Forward! We can seize the Jaguars from the Jaguar sponsorship and re-allocate them to the members!
I've already ordered my copy of the Little Red and Blue Book.
 
Come back.....please.....

b445e66b78f11719de77409af3ae5ddd865fc4e8
 
Come back.....please.....

b445e66b78f11719de77409af3ae5ddd865fc4e8
Yup.
You tell me we have a group that's actually hungry to win cause there's mountains of evidence saying it's a group happy with one flag. They've achieved it.
 
Come back.....please.....

b445e66b78f11719de77409af3ae5ddd865fc4e8
Reminder that Peter Jackson originally picked Josh Mahoney as his successor for CEO, and the AFL overruled him to give the job to Gary Pert after Collingwood sacked him.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Delisted #29: Joel 'Scarface' Smith – banned for four years and delisted

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top