If we were to put that into "Picks" terms and base it on the current ladder and use Freo as the proxy, that deal would end up being
Richmond: 2, 12, 15
West Coast: Reid + 23
When put into draft terms like that, there is no way that deal is worth it for just 1 player. If we were to go with Freo for example there is a greater chance that at least 1 of those players would be a 200 gamer. All the eggs into the basket of Reid could end very very poorly if he were to do a knee or something.
I would not even hesitate to do that deal if I were Richmond. It is roughly the equivalent of picks 2 and 8 for 19yo Harley Reid. If it went to an all club pick bidding war he would fetch a higher price than that, comfortably higher. More like something along the lines of picks 1 and 4 I would think.