MarcMaverick
Ultra Vegito Blue
- Nov 20, 2008
- 13,977
- 12,977
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- The Super Saiyans, Tasmania Devils
Did you rename the OP because i said he was smooth?
Yes. He ch-ch-ch-chose to rename it because of you.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Did you rename the OP because i said he was smooth?
Gun. Contributes every week unlike Hannan, ANB, Melksham.
He played well but he did **** all last week lol.
Definitely a consistent contributor and an upgrade on Watts, though. Happy to call that a big win 2/3 of the way into his first season, which is an indictment on Jack.
Him and gawn were the only two we could rely on to take a mark yesterday. Just shows you don't need to go to the draft for a forward.
What I meant was you don't need to just look to recruit from the under 18s there's still some great talent out there in the vfl sanfl wafl ect, which is more common since expansion. We did some good trading to get weideman because there wasn't many good forwards coming through the under 18s. Yet we end up getting this vfl player who's so reliable with his hands a few years later.
What I meant was you don't need to just look to recruit from the under 18s there's still some great talent out there in the vfl sanfl wafl ect, which is more common since expansion. We did some good trading to get weideman because there wasn't many good forwards coming through the under 18s. Yet we end up getting this vfl player who's so reliable with his hands a few years later.
That's the risk using high picks on forwards from under 18s. It's a big investment they take a while to develop, if they're no good you've wasted a lot of years. I know midfielders are dime a dozen but you know a lot quicker if they're no good. Curnow aside we could have kept that pick for 2016 and got a powell pepper instead.Terrible drafting though. Weid is so shit compared to Curnow. Gee that burns
He didn't even play U18s because of his injury. As others have said, Weideman doesn't look out of place - his tackling and leading patterns are good. Its just actually clunking them and kicking them that he struggles with, which is a concern given he takes the third defender.That's the risk using high picks on forwards from under 18s. It's a big investment they take a while to develop, if they're no good you've wasted a lot of years. I know midfielders are dime a dozen but you know a lot quicker if they're no good. Curnow aside we could have kept that pick for 2016 and got a powell pepper instead.
Hawkins?Who was the last key forward who was complete dog shit 3 seasons in and turned out to be good? He will be gone off the list soon.
Hawkins?
So he came good after an average second season then.Played 22 games and kicked 34 goals in his 3rd season.
So he came good after an average second season then.
Tom Lynch (Adelaide version) was delisted by St Kilda at the end of his 3rd seasonWho was the last key forward who was complete dog shit 3 seasons in and turned out to be good? He will be gone off the list soon.
Who was the last key forward who was complete dog shit 3 seasons in and turned out to be good? He will be gone off the list soon.
Lynch isn't a key forward, I'll give ya Josh Kennedy but that's more exception than rule. Key forwards just like anyone should be showing more than weid 3 seasons in.Tom Lynch (Adelaide version) was delisted by St Kilda at the end of his 3rd season
Josh Kennedy had played 29 games for 18 goals at the end of his 3rd season
Lynch was drafted as a KPF, in fact there is 2cm difference in height between them.Lynch isn't a key forward, I'll give ya Josh Kennedy but that's more exception than rule. Key forwards just like anyone should be showing more than weid 3 seasons in.