I don’t know if they will finish that high… They have definitely improved for sure, however given they hadn’t won a game outside of VIC/TAS since Round 2, 2022, I was hoping for at least a competitive game…
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Coach Adam Simpson Megathread est. 2017 - Skip to 2024: Simpson coaching tenure officially ends
- Thread starter Byron_Clanger
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
I don’t know if they will finish that high… They have definitely improved for sure, however given they hadn’t won a game outside of VIC/TAS since Round 2, 2022, I was hoping for at least a competitive game…
I mean, is he?
He may be a very capable coach but I've seen people shit all over Webster constantly, yet whatever line he coaches seems to do fine.
Schofield coaches the mids directly, so I doubt he'd have no input into what happens in regards to their planning.
They should be 7th right now, if they didn't shit the bed vs Port.
They're not a bottom 4 side, like everyone seems to think.
Or it could also be the assistant coaches have to do things Simmo’s way - in other words it’s “my way or the highway” as I understand that’s why Jamie Graham ended up leaving or at least one of the reasons
.
- Mar 19, 2020
- 16,490
- 46,537
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Get ready for some hurt feelings
We won the 2018 premiership in spite of Adam Simpson not because of him. Everyone knows that in reality it was Sam Mitchell who should have been on the podium with Shannon Hurn, not Adam Simpson if we were being honest about who was responsbile for what
Its no surprise or coincidence that we fell away right after Sam Mitchell left and 5 years later Sam Mitchells team is running circles all over us in a glorified training drill.
We won the 2018 premiership in spite of Adam Simpson not because of him. Everyone knows that in reality it was Sam Mitchell who should have been on the podium with Shannon Hurn, not Adam Simpson if we were being honest about who was responsbile for what
Its no surprise or coincidence that we fell away right after Sam Mitchell left and 5 years later Sam Mitchells team is running circles all over us in a glorified training drill.
Of course he has input mate. But if he sits in MC and says hey Simmo I am sick to death of the inconsistency of player x, I don't want him in the midfield anymore. Then coach Simpson says well bad luck because thats where he is playing then that is not ideal is it.
Now is this happening? I would suspect that assistants certainly have their say, but ultimately it comes down to one man, and that man is the head coach.
You may be right that Schofield certainly is not our next coach and as much as i am a fan of him he has probably been with Simmo to long now. Needs to go elsewhere to be a senior coach.
That would be the best outcome.
Clear the air, Simmo gets to go out at the end of the season and we still look for a new coach in the meantime.
Nope I can't have that mate. Simmo was the coach and he gets the credit. Thats how it has to be. And really what do you think Sami Mitchell did? We won the flag because Collingwood beat Richmond in the preliminary final. we were not the best side that year.
If Simpson isn't head coach of WCE, Mitchell never comes to coach and we don't win the flag.
So even if it could be attributed to Mitchell, it would never have happened to begin with.
pantskyle
Angry Ape
- Oct 1, 2007
- 128,677
- 134,609
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Storm-Man Utd-Heart-Luton-Patriots
Whatever we decide to do with Simmo whether jump now or end of season hopefully we're in Big Cox's ear.
- Mar 19, 2020
- 16,490
- 46,537
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Good point to be honest
Whilst Simpson probably does indeed have most of the power when it comes to selection, all the coaches(including Horsley) have a say on who they think deserves a shot, so who really knows what's being said behind closed doors?
The only established coach that I want and might be remotely gettable is Chris Scott.
Geelong is winding down, he's been there forever and he might be ready for a new challenge. He's also managed to have sustained success with awful ruckman, perfect fit!
Geelong is winding down, he's been there forever and he might be ready for a new challenge. He's also managed to have sustained success with awful ruckman, perfect fit!
Or big Cox is in our ear. Wait.
- Mar 19, 2020
- 16,490
- 46,537
- AFL Club
- West Coast
100% agree with the 2nd part
At very least, Simmo was a sum of the parts around him as opposed to the clear driver however. It definetly fell away when Mitchell left. Cant ignore that as the outcome
Absolutely. We should be rolling out the red carpet for him.
Would much rather give an untried assistant a go.
Long time senior coaches get stuck in their ways far too much and get left behind, be it gameplan, picking the same types, etc.
Need to get someone younger and fresh, with their own ideas.
Simmo gets the credits (in the bank) when we were good and gets the criticism when we're shit.
Premiership is on him, overhauling the gameplan when Mackenzie and Brown went down and steering us to a Grand Final in 2015 is on him, the club falling apart in the hub is on him and whatever the **** we've been shitting out for the last three years is on him too.
Premiership is on him, overhauling the gameplan when Mackenzie and Brown went down and steering us to a Grand Final in 2015 is on him, the club falling apart in the hub is on him and whatever the **** we've been shitting out for the last three years is on him too.
Maybe we've been playing so badly because we dont have Big Cox?
Liam Duggan wondering why did it happen m, even after coach speech after game shows that no one knows what’s going on or players simply not good enough to execute.
Simpson saying we have to own it is not good enough. What does that mean? Do players even know how to own it? I can go around saying “I own it” but if I don’t feel it, means shit.
And also, when it comes to owning it, what does NOT OWNING it look like?
Enough meaningless crap. Odds are we aren’t winning another game. Reid can’t handle a tag and can’t handle players needling him to throw him off his game. So that Reid exceptionalism is likely to be offline for rest of season whilst he adapts to all that and stops reacting (or playing for free kicks).
Simpson saying we have to own it is not good enough. What does that mean? Do players even know how to own it? I can go around saying “I own it” but if I don’t feel it, means shit.
And also, when it comes to owning it, what does NOT OWNING it look like?
Enough meaningless crap. Odds are we aren’t winning another game. Reid can’t handle a tag and can’t handle players needling him to throw him off his game. So that Reid exceptionalism is likely to be offline for rest of season whilst he adapts to all that and stops reacting (or playing for free kicks).
You don't get to the point we are just because of "years of middling draft picks and being on top". If it were just that we'd be shallow bouncing a 2-3 year rebuild with some top up guns like we've done half a dozen times previously through our history.
What we are doing is basically restarting a club from scratch without draft concessions. Even if we nail every draft pick from now and get every trade spot on I've seen nothing that makes me think Simmo is capable of aligning the talent available into a modern gamestyle. He has overseen years of glaring tactical deficiencies that have never been resolved. Years of shocking player development. Shocking recruitment. Poor fitness standards.
Nothing is changing and nothing will change.
Last edited:
We can only guess mate.
We were the best side and we absolutely demolished Richmond when we played them in the season. We would have beaten them in a grand final. If not for poor kicking, we could have beaten Collingwood by 5 goals and probably would have done the same to the Tigers.
IMO you will get that change when you get a new coach. I don't want that change for the last 8 weeks of the season. I think the players at North etc can get used to the "Uh oh new coach...better straighten up a fly right" and therefore the change starts to not bring that natural improvement you get if you waste it on a caretaker in the short term for a slight hit and lower draft pick that could happen due to it if you snag another win or 2.
I like that we let Worsfold coach out until the end despite the last 6 or so games of the season being just as shit as we are seeing now. I would like them to at the very least let Simpson limp to the finish line in this season and then get that natural improvement with change starting pre-season and generate that momentum into a new season.
hmm... (looks at a chart of anatomy)
- Status
Similar threads
- Poll
