AFL Banter

Remove this Banner Ad

To be fair to Will Schofield he did a lot better on Jack Riewoldt than the first guy on him. The first guy got moved off after Riewoldt kicked his 4th about half way through the first quarter.
 
Alan Toovey and Aaron Joseph are both hopeless.

I thought schofield did a decent job, Riewolt only took 3-4 marks on him and considering 90% of inside 50's went too him it wasnt a bad effort.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Surkin said:
Who is the worst player in the AFL at present. My vote goes to Jaxon Barham of Collingwood.
Click to expand...


Adam Mcphee
Lachie Hansen
Tom Murphy
Setanta (although been effective for Blues this yr)
Justin Westoff
Mark Blake
Raph clarke
Jason Laycock
Kyle Reimers
Will minson
Alan Toovey

Thats proberly my top 10 i enjoy the most watching run around with little idea or purpose....

Almost all of these players are picked each week because they are a "structure/Decoy" player or at best a "stopper"....
 
Raf Clarke for sure.

Bit harsh on reimiers i reckon, played about 5 games this year and done well, has some potential. Blokes like mcphee, blake, minson and murphy are fair enough. Been playing for years and get picked every week.

Josh Fraser is a ******.

Good to see you added toovey, he is a ****** and pies supporters cheering "toovs" is the most pathetic thing ever.
 
B: N.Brown, Dawson, Slattery
HB: Toovey, Hansen, R.Clarke
C: Armfield, Joseph , Browne (All Carlton centre line)
HF: Neagle, Miller, Warren
F: Vickery, Hale, R.Roberts
R: Blake, Picken, Barham
I: Spencer, Nicoski, Tiller, Watts


Went out to Balwyn on Saturday and got to see a few blokes who have captained this team in past years in Ben Holland and Patrick Bowden.
 
i refuse to put anyone under the age of 21.Jack Watts Jarrod Grant & Aarron Joeseph would be a shoe in....

FB-Raph Clarke Lachie Hansen Zac Dawson

CHB-Scott Stevens Tom Murphy Alan Toovey

C-Adam Mcphee Richy Tambling Kyle Reimers

CHF-Setanta OHalphin Brad Miller Jay Shultz

FF-Justin Westoff Will Minson Kepler Bradley

Foll-Mark Blake Keiren Jack Xavier Ellis

Inter from- Matt Newton Josh Fraser Simon Taylor Cam Cloke
Tim Callan Adam Thompson Xavier Clarke

and the following players have played themselves out of this team in the last few seasons-

Ted Richards
Heath Grundy
Mark Jamar
Jack Reiwoldt
Tom Lonergan
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Keiren Jack has been very good for the Swans this year.

Kepler has been good when he has played as well but probably still deserves to be there on the strength of his previous 6 seasons.

Also I reckon Jarrod Grant will end up a gun. Makes a lot of stuff ups at the moment and looks like a heroin addict but there is just something about the kid.
 
Kieran Jack, you must be joking. He will be a gun, if he's not already. Reimers doesn't deserve a spot in that side either. At least he's got natural talent, just not consistent enough yet.

McAffer from Collingwood and Robin Nahas are glaring omissions. Probably the two of the four worst players in the comp. The other two being Barham and Dawson.
 
I know a few of the boys who used to play with Nahas down at Oakleigh Chargers and they reckon he has the biggest penis on the planet.
 
He isnt call THROBBIN ROBIN for no reason surkin...

Keiran Jack is and will not be a gune. He will be a good honest contributor at best. A gun is someone like cotchin,gibbs,scully,trengrove so to call him a gun is a bit flattering. My thoughts of him is a good honest battler.

Macaffer is a huge miss.Cant believe i didnt have him in!

Reimers is in the Macaffer mould with a bit more hair and speed....
 
Nathan Brown makes reference to it every week on the Sunday Football Show. Calls him the "little big man" and the other week he said "robbie nahas is a big, big player and I expect him to do big long things".

Most people would have no idea what he is talking about but i almost fell off my chair when I heard him say that.
 
I reckon a lot of people would know what he's talkin about Surkin. It's pretty common knowledge that he has a rod like a trunk...

He is a terrible, terrible footballer though and definitely in the top four of the AFL in that department.

Ontheburst, have you seen many Sydney games this year? Seriously, he's a more than handy player. Certainly doesn't deserve a mention in a worst players of the comp side.
 
Tumbleweed said:
I reckon a lot of people would know what he's talkin about Surkin. It's pretty common knowledge that he has a rod like a trunk...

He is a terrible, terrible footballer though and definitely in the top four of the AFL in that department.

Ontheburst, have you seen many Sydney games this year? Seriously, he's a more than handy player. Certainly doesn't deserve a mention in a worst players of the comp side.
Click to expand...

I have to agree with you. A very much improved player.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

AFL Banter

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top