AFL - Best 50 players

[Blacky]

The same Adam Goodes that got most of his kicks from the backline, must be a star.

Must be a thumping kick considering he had the most inside 50s in the game against your ****.

 

[jo172]

It seems you've forgotten about McLeod.

# 33

 

[claf-43]

Chad Cornes at position 21

your list = no credibility

So I guess the coaches and bookies have got it all wrong.... and should ask you

 

[SIR SAINT HOTDOG]

I do find it fascinating that there are 4 St Kilda players on the list which is higher than the AFL average yet they wont be playing in September in all likelihood.

And there are apparently 25 players in the AFL better than Lance Franklin who is going to finish third in the Coleman medal despite missing two games.

This list is bogus.

the list is based overall not this years performances.

Riewioldt and Hayes definately cement their spot in the top 20 overall players. Dal should be lower and Fisher although having a great year is debatable

 

[MC_9]

I have based my list on this year performances

1.J Brown
2. Kerr
3 Ablett
4 C Cornes
5 Pavlich
6 B Harvey
7 MccLeod
8 Riewoldt
9 Bartel
10 Hodge
11 Ling
12 K Cornes
13 Scarlett
14 S Black
15 Franklin
16 Glass
17 Cox
18 B Johnson
19 Judd
20 S Burgoyne
21 Richo
22 Lloyd
23 Mooney
24 Corey Jones
25 Lappin
26 Ebert
27 Mitchell
28 Fletcher
29 Foley
30 Kirk
31 Sewell
32 Lade
33 Goodes
34 Rutten
35 Lynch
36 H Shaw
37 Hunter
38 Milburn
39 Lucas
40 Hird
41 Lockyer
42 Dal Santo
43 West
44 T Cloke
45 McIntosh
46 O'Keefe
47 A Selwood
48 Fevola
49 Goodwin
50 Adcock

Mitchell would be much higher then 27, this is the guy that is 4th fav for the brownlow.

 

[rancidpants13]

Lloyd has been more consistent than Franklin he just hasn't kicked many big bags.

franklin is a better player this year.....i can't see how even lloyd's missus could argue that....lloyd WAS a great player, but he's not what he was....
franklin is a potential superstar, if not already a superstar, i'd back him every day of the week to be more a matchwinner than lloyd is now

 

[walkers a legend]

fit nick stevens = gun

hes one of the elite midfielder of the comp

 

[McDougallcankick5]

Andrew Embley?

 

[SIR SAINT HOTDOG]

fit nick stevens = gun

hes one of the elite midfielder of the comp

LOL

 

[kingyubbo]

Mitchell would be much higher then 27, this is the guy that is 4th fav for the brownlow.

Agreed, and I don't think Adcock would be sitting at 50. Definitely better than all from 44-48. How is T. Cloke and Fev there? Espiecially Fev?

Also Corey Jones at 24 and Dal Santo at 42 are way too high for their years thus far. Dal Santo has been way down on form and doesn't have as much output as he used to. Jones has had a shocking season by his standards.

 

[Juddy88]

Going on this year, Ablett has been better than Kerr and just as good or if not better than Jonathan Brown.

Kerr has been superb this year and would be close to if not, brownlow favourite if it wasn't for his suspensions.

 

[AGC]

Please put Cox in the Top 10. Take his ruckwork out, and he would be in the top 20 or so mids in the AFL. If the list is based on influence, he should definately be in there.

 

[SIR SAINT HOTDOG]

I have based my list on this year performances

1.J Brown
2. Kerr
3 Ablett
4 C Cornes
5 Pavlich
6 B Harvey
7 MccLeod
8 Riewoldt
9 Bartel
10 Hodge
11 Ling
12 K Cornes
13 Scarlett
14 S Black
15 Franklin
16 Glass
17 Cox
18 B Johnson
19 Judd
20 S Burgoyne
21 Richo
22 Lloyd
23 Mooney
24 Corey Jones
25 Lappin
26 Ebert
27 Mitchell
28 Fletcher
29 Foley
30 Kirk
31 Sewell
32 Lade
33 Goodes
34 Rutten
35 Lynch
36 H Shaw
37 Hunter
38 Milburn
39 Lucas
40 Hird
41 Lockyer
42 Dal Santo
43 West
44 T Cloke
45 McIntosh
46 O'Keefe
47 A Selwood
48 Fevola
49 Goodwin
50 Adcock

Order is terrible.

Why is Fev, A Selwood, Lade, Hunter, and S Burgoyne there?

 

[Blacky]

Am I the only one who thinks Nick Malceski should be in there, or do I have my red and white goggles on?
He may have the best skills in the comp.

 

[Wonder Years]

Riewoldt isnt as good as Pav and how is Brett Kirk above Bartel??

 

[McDougallcankick5]

I will say it again, Andrew Embley

 

[deeboy]

Good to see that James McDonald continues to be the most underated player in the competition!

 

[gwono]

Please put Cox in the Top 10. Take his ruckwork out, and he would be in the top 20 or so mids in the AFL. If the list is based on influence, he should definately be in there.

Bullshit

 

[MC_9]

Good to see that James McDonald continues to be the most underated player in the competition!

agreed.

 

[Rough_Edges]

Kirk is a ****ing star, aweomse attacking game and sensational defensive game.

Bartel is good, but his cheap as chips.

 

[Blacky]

Unless I have miss him, where is Tyson Edwards?

 

[Cat in Newcastle]

Thought Kane Cornes might be higher!

 

[94_Eagles]

Kane Cornes 43rd, lol.

 

[Predator.]

Biggest load of shit list I have ever seen.

If you do not have Chad Cornes top 5, you need to watch more closely.
But no, you can't even squeeze him into the top 20.

What's more, Port, sitting 2nd, can't manage a player in the top twenty.

Geez they must be a champion team then.

 

[greenlight]

Hird is still in the best 20 as far as im concerned.....