AFL Players vote Hodge v Judd - The verdict is in

[Big Red is back]

So far half way through Judd 68 vs Hodge 0... I am backing Hodge to finish hard and close in and win

LOL!!

Hope this puts all the stupid Dawks fans to sleep re this issue, I cannot handle reading anymore stupid comments from these peanuts re this comparison

Bump. Gee have a feeling rise repeat and refresh this for 2009 as well.

 

[anti.]

wasnt the MVP last week?

 

[Big Red is back]

Nope on at the minute

 

[Big Red is back]

Leaderboard update votes

Judd 105 Hodge 0

 

[Mentallo]

Leaderboard update votes

Judd 105 Hodge 0

Simple answer to that.

Hodge = lose man in defence.
Judd = Inside contested player.

Anyone with 2 legs and 2 arms can play the spare man in defence role.

 

[Barry Zuckercorn]

What would the players f*cking know?!?! Leave it to the professionals - the umpires.

 

[PoidaCat]

Selwood > Judd.

 

[ndot]

Selwood > Judd.

close... only a brownlow, norm smith and a couple all-australian honours seperate them

selwood would hardly get a mention if bartel and ablett werent playing alongside him.

 

[PoidaCat]

Judd would hardly get a mention if Kerr and Cousins didn't play alongside him.

 

[Alan_87]

close... only a brownlow, norm smith and a couple all-australian honours seperate them

selwood would hardly get a mention if bartel and ablett werent playing alongside him.

Yeah but a pretty silly to compare previous years of Judd since Selwood is only in his second year lol

 

[Hawks2Tassie]

It's unfortunate but official: Selwood more valuable and courageous than Hodge according to his peers.

 

[YOTC]

it's unfortunate but official: Selwood more valuable and courageous than hodge according to his peers.

hahahahah! GOLD!

 

[PoidaCat]

It's unfortunate but official: Selwood more valuable and courageous than Hodge according to his peers.

ROFL!

 

[mess]

Still don't care. Hodge is better.

 

[mess]

What facts? I watch games, not polls you fruit.

And ditch that ****ing avatar already, bet's over.

 

[Judd2Sewell]

What facts? I watch games, not polls you fruit.

And ditch that ****ing avatar already, bet's over.

Clearly it's one of the Geelong, North or Carlton posters.

Maybe we could bust out a few of our own?
- North2Obscurity
- Carlton2theIRS
- GeelongINGeelong

 

[jonoman89]

Judd would hardly get a mention if Kerr and Cousins didn't play alongside him.

Haven't seen either of them next old CJ lately?

Ba bow....

 

[thatswhatimtalkinabout]

Haven't seen either of them next old CJ lately?

Ba bow....

Hahahaha - you are that used to shit that you now celebrate it.

Hope Judd can actually fix the environment.

 

[Big Red is back]

Looks like the dawks fans have come around.. good work boys

 

[SodaPop]

It's unfortunate but official: Selwood more valuable and courageous than Hodge according to his peers.

It's unfortunate a Cats supporter resorts to setting up an account under a hawks banner

Scared are we???

What's hilarious is the other ******* cats BF members actually believe you barrack for the Hawks

 

[SodaPop]

Looks like the dawks fans have come around.. good work boys

Mate...it's been 10 days since we spanked you and left FevLOLa stranded on 99 goals...it's time to move on

Now go back to the "Trade and Drafts board" where all Carltank supporters usually hang out

 

[Big Red is back]

Mate...it's been 10 days since we spanked you and left FevLOLa stranded on 99 goals...it's time to move on

Now go back to the "Trade and Drafts board" where all Carltank supporters usually hang out

LOL!! Suggest it is official the Dawks fans have moved on from this silly topic re Chubby v Judd. Thankgod

 

[Stereophonic]

I find it funny that WCE fans used to argue this all the time, and Carlton fans did not give a shit, now all of a sudden they are entering into the Judd v Hodge debate


Priceless!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[SodaPop]

LOL!! Suggest it is official the Dawks fans have moved on from this silly topic re Chubby v Judd. Thankgod

You keep Ju$$as and we'll keep Hodge

 

[Collins-Langford-Ayres]

Happy with who we have.

Judd was an exceptional player, however at a young age it appears his best is past him, yet Hodge continues to take massive strides and according to the very realiable champ data stats, was the second best player in the comp this year.

We're a very happy team at HAWTHORN.