Recruiting AFL Trade & Free Agency XII - 💰💰💰

Remove this Banner Ad

I don't disagree with the first list.

Goldy is 50/50 either way. Menzie wouldn't go before him simply through the fact he's shown to be AFL capable at 21 and isn't made of tissue paper. Kelly and Setterfield are similar in ability but Kelly stays on the park and in a different position. Hind too.

If he plays the year out he gets a one year extension. If there's another 6+ week injury we have to consider other alternatives.
You know I’m a massive fan boy of Setterfield but my opinion on keeping him on isn’t from the heart - its an honest opinion when summing up the list. Yeah the injuries are a problem but he’s good enough so you either back him in or cut him and replace, if there is someone good enough. Berry is the one. When I look at other FAs like Parfitt or Graham. Id defs take Setterfield for another season
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Looks like Jay Rantall is giving VFL another crack with Werribee. We know he can run like the absolute clappers, if he goes well he's available to sign at the end of the year as a DFA for some wing depth.
 
Looks like Jay Rantall is giving VFL another crack with Werribee. We know he can run like the absolute clappers, if he goes well he's available to sign at the end of the year as a DFA for some wing depth.
Yeah, but he's also a horrible kick.
 
Jon Ralph having an early throw at the stumps… Going with Stengle staying at Geelong (based on a hunch, and zero intel).

Don’t blame him having a crack at a 50/50, he’ll be the hero if right and no one will hold him accountable if wrong.
 
Jon Ralph having an early throw at the stumps… Going with Stengle staying at Geelong (based on a hunch, and zero intel).

Don’t blame him having a crack at a 50/50, he’ll be the hero if right and no one will hold him accountable if wrong.
So he's gone.

Smells a lot like the classic Geelong buy low sell high rinse then repeat.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

He wouldn’t just flat out make it up though, would he?
He frequently does. Last year he made up a rule that "clubs aren't allowed to trade FA compensation picks" out of nowhere.
 
Why would he sign when he doesn’t get games. He’s been good in the VFL I’d imagine there’s a few teams hoping to snag him.

Really deserves a run at being KPD2 the run home allowing Ridley to play as 3rd tall
Because hes shown plenty at VFL and 200cm bean poles take time

Thats the whole issue other clubs would be offering him deals

Laverde and Mckay allow Ridley to play 3rd tall
 
Why would he sign when he doesn’t get games. He’s been good in the VFL I’d imagine there’s a few teams hoping to snag him.

Really deserves a run at being KPD2 the run home allowing Ridley to play as 3rd tall

I think he’d be waiting to see what happens with Weideman and Reid.

Can’t be 6th in line in your 3rd season.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Recruiting AFL Trade & Free Agency XII - 💰💰💰

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top