-
LIVE: Sydney v Brisbane Lions - 2:30PM AEST Sat
Squiggle tips Lions at 61% chance -- What's your tip? -- Ticketing Buy, Sell -- Teams on Thurs »
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 4 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Ags
- Thread starter Super_Dal
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Apr 18, 2005
- 31,422
- 27,384
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
ACC isnt far behind with teams like Parade, Friars, De La and St Bernards
Dasha39
Debutant
bazlik said:
*Sigh* I thought I ended this talk of APS, but fine.
Congradulations mate, you were missing the recruits. How about I do what you boys do, I'll take them all on scholarships to Ivanhoe. Imagine that for a moment, we've just recruited more than half a starting football team. So now that would mean that in just a few moments, you lost every player that is not on a scholarship. Ivanhoe has just purchased, for a few hundred grand (don't quote me on how much, I don't really do the figures on how much these boys don't have to pay for school) the title of best team in the AGSV, they are now better than any team in the APS, and possibly Victoria. Hailebury is now 'stuck' with playing people who have just come through the school. Unlucky, your now in Ivanhoe's position.
Now, in the one game that seems to have sparked this debate, you were missing all of these players, who have been bought by your school in the last year or so, meaning the normal, human people who go to learn at your school don't even get a crack at playing 1sts footy, coz it's full of ring ins. Ivanhoe, who, admittedly, does not have as many TAC cup boys as Hailebury, were also down their three TAC cup boys. However, I would like the point out a diffence between the TAC boys from the two schools. One of the three has been at the school since prep, another has been at the school for a fair while not quite sure how long, and I don't know whether the third bloke is scholarshiped or now.
What I'm really trying to say through all that, is that the guys who have come through the years at each school are better at Ivanhoe. When the TAC cup boys were removed and put on a level playing field, guess who won.
That argument can't be beat by what you boys seem to have been saying, which I'll quote roughly as "We had our TAC boys out", which I'm tranlating to "We didn't have our recruits"
On an unrelated note, did Mentone seriously beat Trinity? Wow...
Dasha39
Debutant
Yes it is.juDDa said:
The fixture this week is -
Camberwell vs Mentone
Yarra Valley vs Assumption
Marcellin vs P.E.G.S
Ivanhoe vs Peninsula
and Trinity have the bye
- Thread starter
- #33
Moto_GP said:
good question, could go through every team and pick the best couple
what do other people think....a few ive seen or heard of include
IGS: gianfagna, riddell and colbert
MARCELLIN: McCasker, Coghlan and Montagna
PEGS: Tanner, Williams
TRINITY: Iezzi....other couple of midfielders (sorry cant think of names)
CAMBERWELL: Carey
who else would people include?
what about the AGS side for 2005?...any thoughts
macca_2111
Team Captain
Super_Dal said:
I'd include Ryan Anderson from Marcellin
Dasha39
Debutant
Super_Dal said:
Yeah, Ivanhoe vs Peninsula was a great contest, Ivanhoe won by about a goal and a bit, I'll get the exact results when they come up.
Dasha39
Debutant
McPhee said:
Ivanhoe...are...nothing!? I feel shocked and amazed that a team that has only lost one game, and have dub deep in some good contests to come out on top can be nothing.
Guess I'll just have to take your word for it.
- Jun 20, 2005
- 50
- 0
- Other Teams
- Essendon
- Banned
- #45
Jones, easily number 1 in the AGS
2 & 3 could be a toss up between anderson and Sylv
Tim Scarpella of Peninsula recentally tagged GianFAGna and killed him, didnt get a kick the hole day, except for when he kicked out!!
J McCarthy, any one noticed him brother of Matt Mc Carthy Listed Geelong AFL footballer who is number 26# in the Peninsula best everyweek
J Grant = GUN u/16 last 29 Vic Metro
Z Rodwell & D Whelan
2 & 3 could be a toss up between anderson and Sylv
Tim Scarpella of Peninsula recentally tagged GianFAGna and killed him, didnt get a kick the hole day, except for when he kicked out!!
J McCarthy, any one noticed him brother of Matt Mc Carthy Listed Geelong AFL footballer who is number 26# in the Peninsula best everyweek
J Grant = GUN u/16 last 29 Vic Metro
Z Rodwell & D Whelan
del_santos
Draftee
- Jul 18, 2005
- 10
- 0
- Other Teams
- Freo (yes this is a joke)
re the AGS side for 05...
what about Clarke (CGS) and Mackay (TGS)?
very good midfield players
is there anyone from Mentone?
what about Clarke (CGS) and Mackay (TGS)?
very good midfield players
is there anyone from Mentone?
Madison Hardimann. Super athlete, super smart, super looking. Assumption have been keeping him under wraps and will look to unleash come August 12th. Utility, at 191 cm's he is a key position prospect or can adapt to a Riewoldt/Goodes type game on the wing. Definitely one to watch.
