All australian

SaInts SKill · Apr 19, 2005

weagles_fan said:
No Judd,what is wrong with you?A bit envious are we?

well you didn't put dal santo in and he has had a better start consistancy wise than Judd has this year..

weagles_fan · Apr 19, 2005

pazza said:
No..far from it..

Let me get this right you don't wish your team had Judd?

Stafford678 · Apr 19, 2005

Rough_Edges said:
any comments?

Richo's been the dominant Forward so far this season , far better then Hall, Pavlich so far, usualy the coleman medlist gets a spot in the AA and right now richo is the coleman medalist so to speak

pazza · Apr 19, 2005

weagles_fan said:
Let me get this right you don't wish your team had Judd?

Once again, it would be nice to have him..I know we'll never get near him.

His form has been sluggish until the last 2 weeks. Take the rose-coloured glasses off for a minute and look at the other 15 sides.

James · Apr 19, 2005

pazza said:
No..far from it..just that others (read McLeod and Kouta) have been better so far.

Erm...no

Kouta has been good, leads the comp for clearences, but not great, overall, certainly not AA.

Nowhere near Judd. Not even counting his first three rounds which were good, Judds 36 possie 360degree spinning pack breaking goal in rd4 would be enough to warrant AA selection at present.

It is only rd 4 afterall. Hope Kouta can step up even more for the remainder of the season though.

weagles_fan · Apr 19, 2005

pazza said:
Once again, it would be nice to have him..I know we'll never get near him.

His form has been sluggish until the last 2 weeks. Take the rose-coloured glasses off for a minute and look at the other 15 sides.

Yes but in these 2 weeks he has been brilliant.

James · Apr 19, 2005

Stafford678 said:
Richo's been the dominant Forward so far this season , far better then Hall, Pavlich so far, usualy the coleman medlist gets a spot in the AA and right now richo is the coleman medalist so to speak

Richo would be a dead cert for AA on current form.

zero · Apr 19, 2005

judds first two games were ok to good, his last two were BOGs. he, bruce and richardson are the only certainties for an AA team picked right now...

Ten Ton Hammer · Apr 19, 2005

Stafford678 said:
Richo's been the dominant Forward so far this season , far better then Hall, Pavlich so far, usualy the coleman medlist gets a spot in the AA and right now richo is the coleman medalist so to speak

Richo has been the best forward so far this season but Hall has been good also and i dare say if had kicked straight he would be leading the coleman!

11.12 goals so far for Hall this season.

snakebite01 · Apr 20, 2005

Johncock would have to be pushing pretty bloody hard for a back pocket.

Chadwiko · Apr 20, 2005

Lonie_from_50 said:
B: Josh Hunt (Geel) - Leigh Brown (Kang) - James Clement (Coll)
HB: Glen Archer (Kang) - Trent Croad (Haw) - Lindsay Gilbee (WB)
C: Corey Enright (Geel) - Chris Judd (WCE) - Andrew Embley (W.C.E)
HF: Cameron Bruce (Melb) - Barry Hall (Syd) - Shannon Grant (Kang)
F: Aaron Hamill (St.K) - Matthew Richardson (Rich) - Nathan G. Brown (Rich)
Foll: Peter Everitt (Haw) - Chad Fletcher (WCE) - Luke Ball (St.K)
I/C: Dean Cox (W.C.E) - Jess Sinclair (Kang) - Brad Johnson (W.B) - Peter Walsh (P.A)

That is just off my head, I could do a detailed one, but I will have to think and look at the stats and performances etc.

Thoughts?

100% agreement. Could'nt have said it better myself. I'd probably swap Enright for Licuria maaaybe. But apart from that its spot on.

Chadwiko · Apr 20, 2005

zero said:
judds first two games were ok to good, his last two were BOGs. he, bruce and richardson are the only certainties for an AA team picked right now...

I'd say Leigh Brown has been the benchmark FB so far this year.
Add him to the certaintess if the AA team were announced today.
I'd also say Spider Everett would be the certain Ruck as well.

The_Flying_Egg · Apr 20, 2005

For the Dogs Brad Johnson and Little Lindsay Gilbee should be in there

Lindsay has been on fire, IMO our best player over the first 4 rounds. He is one of the best kicks going around, and has 8 goals while spending most of his time down back

afc9798 · Apr 20, 2005

Rough_Edges said:
B: J. Hunt L. Brown J. Clemnt
HB: J. Sinclair T. Croad Wirrapunda
C: Dal Santo Judd Enright
HF: N.Brown M.Pavlich C.Bruce
F: A.Hamill B.Hall A. Davey

Followers: Everitt Ball Cousins

interchange: B. Johnson T. Johnstone C. Fletcher R. Robertsn

Thats mine. - Any thoughts?

You couldn't find room for a single Adelaide player, despite the fact they are 3rd on the ladder with 3 wins and the highest %? I would Have thought that Ricciuto, McLeod and Mattner deserved consideration as they have all been high in the best each week so far.

Pavlich has plyed one servicable game this year and other than that has done nothing. Jess Sinclair, not AA material/. Anyway, each to their own.

worthy · Apr 20, 2005

weagles_fan said:
Taken the scrutiny on board and developed the new team.Here it is:

B: Josh Hunt (Geel) - Leigh Brown (Kang) - David Wirrpunda (WCE)
HB: Glenn Archer (Kang) - Trent Croad (Haw) - Lindsay Gilbee (WB)
C: Luke Ball (StK) - Ben Cousins (WCE) - Chad Fletcher (WCE)
HF: Cameron Bruce (Melb) - Barry Hall (Syd) - Shannon Grant (Kang)
F: Adem Yze (Melb) - Matthew Richardson (Rich) - Nathan G. Brown (Rich)
Foll: Peter Everitt (Haw) - Chris Judd (WCE) - Paul Licuria (Coll)
I/C: Dean Cox (WCE) - Corey Enright (Geel) - Brad Johnson (W.B) - Nick Dal Santo (StK)

That's not bad, would love to sqeeze Crawf in there but can't find anyone to justifiably take out.

Nightwolf · Apr 20, 2005

worthy said:
That's not bad, would love to sqeeze Crawf in there but can't find anyone to justifiably take out.

Its amazing how many Hawks could actually compete for a spot in the side thus far, when we are sitting with 1 win, second last....

snakebite01 · Apr 20, 2005

afc9798 said:
You couldn't find room for a single Adelaide player, despite the fact they are 3rd on the ladder with 3 wins and the highest %? I would Have thought that Ricciuto, McLeod and Mattner deserved consideration as they have all been high in the best each week so far.

Pavlich has plyed one servicable game this year and other than that has done nothing. Jess Sinclair, not AA material/. Anyway, each to their own.

I am happy to keep flying under the radar at the moment.

It shows we've got everyone contributing evenly so far instead of 1 or 2 stars carrying the team. If by year's end we still have no players in the AA team then we've either imploded and finished crap or we will be sitting comfortably in the top 8, possibly top 4 due to even contributions from our players.

Reyes_9 · Apr 20, 2005

Josh Hunt Dustin Fletcher David Wirrapunda
Jess Sinclair Leigh Brown Lindsay Gilbee
Andrew McLeod Chris Judd Andrew Embley
Cameron Bruce Matthew Richardson Shannon Grant
Nathan Brown Barry Hall Brad Johnson
Everitt Chad Fletcher Paul Licuria
Barnaby French Luke Ball Nick Dal Santo Brad Green

Gets! · Apr 20, 2005

Andrew Mcleod anyone?

Martin Mattner?

Pie 4 Life · Apr 20, 2005

FB Ben Johnson Shane Wakelin Jess Sinclair

HB James Clement Trent Croad Peter Bell

C Cameron Bruce Nick Stevens Sam Mitchell

HF Shannon Grant Fraser Gehrig Daniel Bradshaw

FF Chris Tarrant Matthew Richardson Daniel Wells

R Peter Everitt Andrew McLeod Paul Licuria

INT Kepler Bradley Warren Tredra Stephen Milne Mark Williams

IMO

Rod Stroker · Apr 20, 2005

Reyes_9 said:
Josh Hunt Dustin Fletcher David Wirrapunda
Jess Sinclair Leigh Brown Lindsay Gilbee
Andrew McLeod Chris Judd Andrew Embley
Cameron Bruce Matthew Richardson Shannon Grant
Nathan Brown Barry Hall Brad Johnson
Everitt Chad Fletcher Paul Licuria
Barnaby French Luke Ball Nick Dal Santo Brad Green

Finally someone mentions Brad Green. To date he has had a better, more consistent year that Johnstone and Yze.

Not a bad squad that one...

Longy413 · Apr 20, 2005

Pie 4 Life said:
FB Ben Johnson Shane Wakelin Jess Sinclair

HB James Clement Trent Croad Peter Bell

C Cameron Bruce Nick Stevens Sam Mitchell

HF Shannon Grant Fraser Gehrig Daniel Bradshaw

FF Chris Tarrant Matthew Richardson Daniel Wells

R Peter Everitt Andrew McLeod Paul Licuria

INT Kepler Bradley Warren Tredra Stephen Milne Mark Williams

IMO

Welsh and Fletcher are more deserving from an Essendon point of view.

Pie 4 Life · Apr 20, 2005

Herald Sun Rankings Point of View:

FB: Jess Sinclair (Roos) Dustin Fletcher (Ess) Mark Johnson (Ess)

HB: Lindsay Gilbee (WBD) James Clement (Coll) Nick Stevens (Carl)

C: Chris Judd (WCE) Ben Cousins (WCE) Sam Mitchell (Haw)

HF: Shannon Grant (Roos) Barry Hall (Syd) Jude Bolton (Syd)

FF: Chris Tarrant (Coll) Matthew Richardson (Rich) Jason Akermanis (Bris)

R: Peter Everitt (Haw) Paul Licuria (Coll) Nick Dal Santo (StK)

INT: Dean Cox (WCE) Andrew McLeod (Adel) Cameron Bruce (Melb) Luke Hodge (Haw)

EM: David Wirrpunda (WCE) Shane Wakelin (Coll) Graham Johncock (Adel)

Using the ranking points and basic stats, this is the team, What do you all think?

Longy413 · Apr 20, 2005

Pie 4 Life said:
Using the ranking points and basic stats, this is the team, What do you all think?

Pretty close to the mark.

Funkalicous · Apr 20, 2005

It's interesting how each team deserves 2 or 3 All-Australians at this stage of the year.

WBBL Season 10 - Oct '24 to Dec '25

All australian

All Australian

Brownlow Medallist

Premiership Player

Hall of Famer

Cancelled

Brownlow Medallist

Cancelled

Norm Smith Medallist

Club Legend

Premiership Player

@ChadwikoTWW

@ChadwikoTWW

Norm Smith Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

Cancelled

Norm Smith Medallist

Premiership Player

Senior List

Brownlow Medallist

Hall of Famer

Hall of Famer

Brownlow Medallist

Hall of Famer

Brownlow Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

All australian

Similar threads

Log In or Create New Account