Andrew Gaff V Reece Conca

Gaff v Conca

  • Total voters
    215

Remove this Banner Ad

I haven't seen enough of Conca to comment. But it should be taken into account that Gaff is now playing with a hard tag every week. He's starting to learn to break them, but when free he dominates.
Racks up heaps of solid possessions and good inside 50 delivery.

His major downside is he only has a left foot.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Will point out that Conca is yet to complete a preseason due to injures. I reckon he will be a star, unfortunately David King agrees with me so I'm probably wrong
 
Gaff seems to be floating around the 70m mark from goal often, waiting to run it or be the link to full forward. I'd like to see him be a bit more inside the pack instead of forward of the ball.
 
forwardflanker said:
Conca. Gaff is one of the softest players in the AFL and can't shake a tag. Seriously he makes Sidebottom look like one of the hard men of the AFL
Click to expand...

Beaten the tag comfortably in the last 2 weeks against Hawthorn and Essendon. Has gone in hard everytime he's needed to this year and thrown his body on the line in finals so i don't really get the ''soft'' tag.
 
WCEbrody said:
Beaten the tag comfortably in the last 2 weeks against Hawthorn and Essendon. Has gone in hard everytime he's needed to this year and thrown his body on the line in finals so i don't really get the ''soft'' tag.
Click to expand...
Bro gaff is soft. But he's an outside player who weighs 40kg, what do people expect.
 
WCEbrody said:
Beaten the tag comfortably in the last 2 weeks against Hawthorn and Essendon. Has gone in hard everytime he's needed to this year and thrown his body on the line in finals so i don't really get the ''soft'' tag.
Click to expand...

Beat the tag in the first half. Well held by Melksham from midway through the third

Would take Gaff
 
In the lead up to the draft, I really hoped Gaff would slip to us at pick 6 and was initially a bit underwhelmed we chose Conca. I can still remember some fans saying if Gaff ever wanted to come home, Conca could be put up for trade/swap with some kind of sweetener.

Conca though has impressed me with his attack on the ball and decision making (some people say he butchers the ball but I'm yet to see that). IMO, he will take Tuck's spot in the midfield as the prime ball winner. Has Tuck's fanatical attack on the ball but with better skills.

For now, I wouldn't trade him (haven't seen a lot of Gaff but given WC would want to strengthen their midfield, can't see them wanting to part with him either).

Both good young players but my bias says Conca :D
 
Conca, much more rounded player. If Concas kicking sharpens up he will be elite imo... inside outside player, hard body, great in traffic and importantly runs hard both ways and tackles hard
 
Gaff is hardly soft. Just slight.

Good poll. Both sets of supporters no doubt voting for their own player will ruin it though.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

lmach said:
Gaff. I don't like what I've seen from Conca thus far while Gaff is already copping a hard tag each week at 20 years of age.
Click to expand...

Gaff cops the tag because there is hardly anyone else worth whole tagging in there team, Priddis butchers the ball naturally and plays predominantly inside so really not worth while tagging, it's really between Shuey and Gaff and most teams these days run with 2 players that they can use to shut down a couple of opposition players, even if one is a mild tag.

It's a reason why players like Conca and Ellis don't cop the hard tags, because they either tag Cotchin or Deledio and our lower tier midfielders are left to do as they please.
 
MightyTiger said:
Gaff cops the tag because there is hardly anyone else worth whole tagging in there team, Priddis butchers the ball naturally and plays predominantly inside so really not worth while tagging, it's really between Shuey and Gaff and most teams these days run with 2 players that they can use to shut down a couple of opposition players, even if one is a mild tag.

It's a reason why players like Conca and Ellis don't cop the hard tags, because they either tag Cotchin or Deledio and our lower tier midfielders are left to do as they please.
Click to expand...
Shuey is tagged most weeks because he is our most damaging mid. Masten will be tagged soon.
 
Don't usually comment in these threads but Conca has surpassed Gaff this year due to his inside ability.

Both are B graders at the moment.
 
Right now they are fairly even it probably comes down to which type of midfielder you need. If you need a link up outside player that can run all day you would take Gaff. If an inside midfielder who has some pace is your highest priority then you would go Conca.

I'd probably take Conca myself because I feel he has a bit more hurt factor when he plays well. However this could easily change in about 6 games time because there really isn't much to use as basis to prefer one over the other.
 
Some Idiot said:
You would probably take Gaff on performance, but Conca wins his own ball and isn't as soft, so actually I go with him despite his weaknesses
Click to expand...
Gaff isn't soft, he's just built like a stick insect
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Andrew Gaff V Reece Conca

Similar threads

jakefooty23
  • Poll
Mac Andrew vs Sam Darcy
Replies
6
Views
622
number1_joshhunt_fan
number1_joshhunt_fan
Elmer_Hauser
  • Poll
Andrew Brayshaw v Chad Warner
Replies
4
Views
837
Zevon
Zevon
R00StaR
  • Poll
Warlord V JHF
2 3
Replies
59
Views
3K
TheUnicorn
TheUnicorn
justlookingaround
  • Poll
Which Semi Final was better Sydney vs Geelong 2005 or GWS vs Brisbane 2024
Replies
3
Views
327
Blackhawk42
Blackhawk42
Young Gun #6
  • Poll
Walsh v Rozee v Butters v Smith
2 3 4 5
Replies
105
Views
8K
Hippster
H
Pee Tear Griffin
  • Poll
Butters v Gulden
Replies
15
Views
2K
rye
rye
M Malice
  • Poll
Jamie Elliott v Charlie Cameron.
Replies
6
Views
953
Mitchell Madness
Mitchell Madness
Back
Top