Andy Collins v Shaun Grigg

[dean33]

Still a bit early to judge however which team looks to be the winner from this trade? Might be premature at this stage as might need to wait another 12-24 months to give an accurate assessment.

 

[ChisBlues]

Carlton vs Richmond ladder positions and Premiership prospects since trade ??

 

[j-ham]

They're both shit.

 

[PuntRoadEnd]

Collins wont break back into that side ever but regardless ,Grigg by every street in Australia

 

[CarltonKid07]

Carlton need neither

 

[PuntRoadEnd]

They're both shit.

Your typical blues aficionado right here folks

 

[ChisBlues]

Collins wont break back into that side ever but regardless ,Grigg by every street in Australia

Grigg is a great fit for the Tiggers.
Fat, slow, terrible disposal and will probably finish 9th in the Tiggers B&F

 

[PuntRoadEnd]

Grigg is a great fit for the Tiggers.
Fat, slow, terrible disposal and will probably finish 9th in the Tiggers B&F

I can tatse your envy at letting this gem in the rough go

Collins on the other hand has stagnated and will probably never realize his potential.

 

[ChisBlues]

I can tatse your envy at letting this gem in the rough go

He is shit. That is what you taste

 

[PuntRoadEnd]

He is shit. That is what you taste

Your loss our gain flog

 

[gandaal]

Grigg would be a fringe player at Carlton. Collins is a dud.

Richmond won the trade but Carlton didnt lose much in the process.

 

[j-ham]

Says a lot that neither of them could crack a regular game at Carlton yet are best 22 at Richmond.

 

[ChisBlues]

Your loss our gain flog

ROFL - Says a lot about you when you consider shit as a gain

 

[PuntRoadEnd]

Says a lot that neither of them could crack a regular game at Carlton yet are best 22 at Richmond.

Keep underrating him flogs but his season stats and form show his one of the comps most improved players

Just shows that the blues were a sleep at the wheel when 'developing him'

 

[PuntRoadEnd]

ROFL - Says a lot about you when you consider shit as a gain

I can see it hurts you deeply

 

[ChisBlues]

I can see it hurts you deeply

Ahhhhhh the Dawsons Creek retort when you have lost the argument.
Brilliant one Mr Potato Head

 

[PuntRoadEnd]

Re: Andy Collins v Shaun Grigg..oh yeah

.Now where were we? ... oh yeah


Griggs >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

inanimate object >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Collins

 

[PuntRoadEnd]

Still cryin flog

 

[PuntRoadEnd]

Ahhhhhh the Dawsons Creek retort when you have lost the argument.
Brilliant one Mr Potato Head

Andy Collins v Shaun Grigg was the argument Your attempts to derail it have been lamentable

Truth is Griigg >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Collins every day of the year


spudhead

 

[Big Red is back]

Still a bit early to judge however which team looks to be the winner from this trade? Might be premature at this stage as might need to wait another 12-24 months to give an accurate assessment.

Neither would get a game at Carlton both would be key players at rich.

Injury troll?

 

[Big Red is back]

Ahhhhhh the Dawsons Creek retort when you have lost the argument.
Brilliant one Mr Potato Head

You got him lol

 

[ChisBlues]

Andy Collins v Shaun Grigg was the argument Your attempts to derail it have been lamentable

Truth is Griigg >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Collins every day of the year


spudhead

Jack Watts would be your gun CHF if you got him.
Grigg is your gun midfielder.

Shit players look better in shit teams.
You know how shit tastes though dontcha

 

[brett15]

Good teams make depth players look better, not surprised Grigg looks better at Richmond.

 

[THECHIEFTON]

Neither would get a game at Carlton both would be key players at rich.

Brock McLean still gets a game.

 

[Monkey King]

Still a bit early to judge however which team looks to be the winner from this trade?

LOL. Collins was more a booby prize than a trade. Grigg had already walked and the Tigers had the first preseason pick; basically the Blues took whatever they could get.

Personally I would have just preferred they let him walk and battle it out with Houli for the who would be taken. Collins is the type of dud you usually only find on club lists like Richmond's.

Well done to Grigg though, has slipped nicely into a soft, outside role with the Tigers. Can't say he would have done the same with the Blues.