Anthony Miles

[DrummoSolo]

If offered both players tomorrow, I'd take Miles.
That is not to jump off Greene and say he won't be a good player down the track, but Miles form this year is top shelf.
Miles not only gets it out - which is perfect for Richmond - but he also spreads well and can find the football uncontested.
In all, I think Miles is more effective as a player than Greene.

Which is a perfectly reasonable opinion, of course, my post was more for the people implying he's a shit player.

 

[Westicle]

Some players prefer to see ball, wait for someone to fish the ball out, fiix hair, take ball. Not looking at anyone in particular Dyson Heppell and Brandon Ellis.

However people calling him a star is a bit much unless they call someone like Matt Priddis a star. Both do the same job, both have the same limitations. He's not a great technical kick of the ball (tends to pop it up rather than drill it). Decision making is quite good though. He's not an A grader (We're talking the elites of Pendlebury, Ablett etc) but He's a A- upside, currently B grader.

OK... I will pay that because it is pretty damn funny. But humour aside, I think you're underselling Heppell there and forgetting the fact that Ellis only turned 21 this week. Both are good players regardless of whether you like their hairstyle.

Calling Dusty a dumb footballer only betrays your own ignorance though. He is a very good decision maker and a smarter footballer than some blokes with a 30+ IQ points head start (Dan Jackson, Will Minson etc). Will probably never join MENSA, but for the purposes of doing his job, he has all the smarts he needs.

 

[thecotch]

Will get worked out and return to mediocrity next year...

A bit like mizungu?

 

[The Cryptkeeper]

We got him at the back end of the rookie draft.
Absolutely crazy

That is mental.

The kid can seriously play.

Well done to the Tigers on some astute recruiting.

 

[thecotch]

A true diamond in the rough. Maturity beyond his years. A real positive in a disappointing season,

 

[doggies ftw]

That's the only bad thing with these expansion teams - there is a shitload of talent and a lot of it won't be noticed

That's the only good thing about these expansion teams tbh, there is plenty of talent that can be gotten on the cheap that is now starting to trickle feed through to the other clubs who are smart enough to spot it. Miles is a gem, same with Hombsch, Bruce looks alright and we've got Darley with pick 70 last year who hasn't done a whole heap but has a heap of upside and I really like the look of him.

Think there's plenty more talent to be had from that list, GC on the other hand... Can't see much to get excited from outside of their best 25 or so.