SweatOnMySkin
Team Captain
Becomes a question of how valuable either club sees that pick. Geelong's 2025 is an unknown but there's an inherent devaluation of future picks by clubs anyway. Current currency si always worth more vs a pick you can use ona player you wont be able to use for 2 yearsI’m probably in the minority on our board, but I believe Geelong should trade our future R1 for Smith. Would rather keep our picks for this year’s draft (which is supposedly deeper/better), whilst Dogs very likely to end up with a better pick which is a better reflection of his value. Unfortunately clubs rarely get full value for OOC players (especially those coming off an ACL and a couple of subpar/injury interrupted seasons) and Dogs will be no different with Smith.