Club History Best Player per Guernsey Number in the AFL

[Concussion]

Hitchcock was number 2 wasn't he?

 

[finbarr]

I'm pretty sure Broges took the number one mantle when Primus was injured a lot late in his time, and Ladey slowed down. As i said, i don't dispute your call. Although, if we didn't have the likes of Lobbe and Ryder right now, i'd take Brogan over Wingard at this very moment. Chad needs to find his promising form, and be consistent to convince me fully.

Wasn't Brogan still playing basketball when he was Chad's age? No one's doubting Broges was a good player but Chad Wingard he ain't. And I'd take Chad over Brogan even if we had Renouf as our number one ruck right now.

 

[Eddie Dingle]

Naish gets the 4 obviously.

 

[Changaneen]

Wasn't Brogan still playing basketball when he was Chad's age? No one's doubting Broges was a good player but Chad Wingard he ain't. And I'd take Chad over Brogan even if we had Renouf as our number one ruck right now.

I've run out of debate on that one Yea i'd have Chad over 95% of any AFL player at the moment. Still very young, and a long road ahead of him. And he's a local boy, he aint going anywhere which is a relief.

I like his cameos in the middle. To me he's looking more Gary Ablettesque than Robbie. I'd like Chad to play more in the middle he seems to break through with class when he's on song. I'm going to have to back down and change my mind re the Broges comparison. I just want Chad more consistent, now!! I'm very impatient.

 

[Changaneen]

Naish gets the 4 obviously.

Neesh?

 

[finbarr]

I've run out of debate on that one Yea i'd have Chad over 95% of any AFL player at the moment. Still very young, and a long road ahead of him. And he's a local boy, he aint going anywhere which is a relief.

I like his cameos in the middle. To me he's looking more Gary Ablettesque than Robbie. I'd like Chad to play more in the middle he seems to break through with class when he's on song. I'm going to have to back down and change my mind re the Broges comparison. I just want Chad more consistent, now!! I'm very impatient.

He's still a work in progress with this year showing an obvious step up in midfield time. He's still a very young guy. By the time he hits his 24th birthday look out.

 

[Shaxx Attaxx]

Ebert > Mead for 33

 

[raman]

Ebert > Mead for 33

 

[RussellEbertHandball]

Hitchcock was number 2 wasn't he?

Not to start with, he was a rookie.

 

[PAFC04]

I torn between the two:

JMAC or Chad??

 

[Schulzenfest]

47. Cameron Cloke

Nah, at least Irons played one good game.

I torn between the two:

JMAC or Chad??

Chad was a superstar of the competition for a decade, J-Mac played for us for one (pretty average to be honest) year. He was a fantastic bloke and a great loss, but let's not turn him into something he wasn't.

 

[El_Scorcho]

I torn between the two:

JMAC or Chad??

Jmac has a special place in the hearts of every Port Adelaide person, but he was just a solid player for us.

Chad was a champion of the game.

 

[El_Scorcho]

Gray over Carr

Francou in 10, Boak in 1, Gav in 4

Wingard over Brogan might be a touch premature, but why delay the inevitable?

 

[Porked04]

OP is kidding if Chapdick was our best ever no. 30.

Darryl Poole was by far better than Chaplin. Poole actually cared about the club and saved his cheap shots for the opposition on-field rather than against his ex-club off-field

 

[tribey]

Ebert > Mead for 33

 

[glitch01]

Ebert > Mead for 33

As much as I was a Brett Ebert fan (I know, should never admit that here......) Meady has to be the best No. 33. He was a good old fashioned defender and was the epitome of a Port club man.
Will never forget the day he was thrown into the ruck and the Meady chant filled the stadium. Can never question Ebo's commitment or effort but Mead was like a rock in our early years.

 

[TeeKray]

John Butcher actually has some kind of claim to #32 - 22 goals in 12 games.

 

[cuthbert30]

OP is kidding if Chapdick was our best ever no. 30.

Darryl Poole was by far better than Chaplin.

yep ....by a long long way

 

[Concussion]

OP is kidding if Chapdick was our best ever no. 30.

Darryl Poole was by far better than Chaplin. Poole actually cared about the club and saved his cheap shots for the opposition on-field rather than against his ex-club off-field

That's the reason he put the thread on our board, I suppose.

 

[Byrons Firen]

Michael Wilson #15? what about my Avatar as #15. Both played in the 04 GF but can't have been in the same jumper.
Am I having a senior moment. For impact,skill and charisma #15 is Byron Pickett

 

[finbarr]

Chokito would possibly feel he has strong claims on #15.

 

[Rising Power]

Who was the best 69?

[Edit: And I've just realised that this was my 1000th post. Classy.]

 

[Concussion]

Michael Wilson #15? what about my Avatar as #15. Both played in the 04 GF but can't have been in the same jumper.
Am I having a senior moment. For impact,skill and charisma #15 is Byron Pickett

Wilson wore number 21 in GF

 

[Chokito]

15: Wilson > Pickett > Rodan> Amon > Chokito

 

[Byrons Firen]

Thought I'd check those #'s and came across this
O