Best player to come off a rookie list

[gandaal]

Anthony Carrazzo is a rookie elevation this year for us and he's been excellent in every game he's played for us so far. Hasn't had a bad one and there aren't too many who can say that.

 

[AllStar7]

Cameron Bruce came off the supp. list, after being spotted and picked up by Melbourne at age 19.

 

[gandaal]

guns?

all you've got there is 11 players who'll never play in a premiership for any club, in fact, you've got 11 players who'll struggle to get 20 finals appearances between the lot of them, and most of them have already been in 1!

Robert Hadrill is a very good player but that's about it.

 

[Ripper]

ROFL!!!

They all would get a game a Carlton ahead of TLo.

 

[gandaal]

Cameron Bruce came off the supp. list, after being spotted and picked up by Melbourne at age 19.

We're talking Rookie list here. Cameron Bruce was picked up in the national draft.

 

[gandaal]

They all would get a game a Carlton ahead of TLo.

Maybe that's why T-Lo is currently in the twos. And I seriously doubt that anyway.

 

[MarkT]

Mal Michael was a rookie IIRC. Some rate him the best key defender in the game.

 

[HighReeve]

Anthony Carrazzo is a rookie elevation this year for us and he's been excellent in every game he's played for us so far. Hasn't had a bad one and there aren't too many who can say that.

Anthony?

 

[nonchalance]

Essendon had five on the weekend - Rioli, Peverill, MJ, Lovett and Lovett-Murray.

Probably still behind the Eagles, though.

 

[guess_who]

Ben Davies and Zane Leonard look the goods.

 

[gandaal]

Anthony?

Nobody's perfect, although I do come close at times.

 

[Walsh Bay]

Brett Kirk, from rookie to captain

 

[Bestbird]

They all would get a game a Carlton ahead of TLo.

They would all be in the starting 22 down at Collingwood

 

[Longy413]

Essendon have had two Premiership rookies in Mark Johnson and Gary Moorcroft.

Mark Johnson the only rookie list player to win a club B&F?

 

[Macca19]

Chad Fletcher, Mal Michael are probably the cream.

Lockyer, M Johnson, Cox, Brogan, French, Kirk and Peverill are probably in the group under those two

 

[The Dustbin]

Robert Copeland

Elevated for Rnd 9 in 2001 - a 5pt loss to Adelaide, then part of the team to win 16 on the trot to take out the GF.

Robert Copeland is ********.

 

[rick James]

Hands down win by WCE.

1. 2005 To be AA Ruckman Cox.... 2nd best Everitt to be on AA bench

2. C.Fletcher 04 AA & same again in 05

I'd like to hear of any better?

Cameron Bruce, Jim Stynes, Aaron Davey

 

[pazza]

Best Rookie List Elevation Team

B: Lockyer, Michael, Johnson
HB: Teague, Kennelly, Tivendale
C: Rioli, Fletcher, Copeland
HF: Lovett-Murray, Brogan, Lovett
F: Davey, Cox, Lynch
R: Sandilands, Kirk, McDonald
Int: Walsh, Ward, Peverill, French

 

[TheReason]

Cameron Bruce, Jim Stynes, Aaron Davey

Bruce & Davey are a rung below Cox & Fletcher

Stynes a rung above, ATM

 

[TheReason]

Best Rookie List Elevation Team

B: Lockyer, Michael, Johnson
HB: Teague, Kennelly, Tivendale
C: Rioli, Fletcher, Copeland
HF: Lovett-Murray, Brogan, Lovett
F: Davey, Cox, Lynch
R: Sandilands, Kirk, McDonald
Int: Walsh, Ward, Peverill, French

Sandilands as 1st Ruck... WTF?

 

[Longy413]

Cameron Bruce, Jim Stynes, Aaron Davey

Bruce was drafted onto the Melbourne list.

And Stynes? The rookie list only started in about 1995.

 

[skywalk750]

I think Brent Moloney was from the rookie list as was Shannon Byrnes

 

[Longy413]

I think Brent Moloney was from the rookie list as was Shannon Byrnes

Moloney was taken in the PSD.

 

[skywalk750]

Moloney was taken in the PSD.

From WCE's rookie list?

 

[Milenko]

From WCE's rookie list?

Nah i think he just trained with us before you nabbed him in the PSD.