-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Best Spine in the Comp!!!
- Thread starter FevJunior
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Hudghton is your FB and he's highly ranked by all clubs..he's ageing now tho but Maguire is still your CHB.
Part of the reason Fisher had such a great season is that he played FB and CHB on the big KP fwds and did very well...then as your injuries returned he got freed up...dont believe u should be claiming him in your spine tho just yet.
Hudghton
Maguire
Hayes
Riewoldt
???
..its still strong on paper. Hudghton is unfortunately starting to get a lot more of those soft tissue injuries that giveaway his age. 1-2 yrs tops left.
Weagles the strongest spine for mine.
Glass
Hunter
Kerr
Hansen
Lynch
The Ruckmen should be the person in the middle if yuor talking about the spine.
Lynch
Hansen
Cox
Hunter
Glass
Llyod
Lucas
Hille
Fletcher
Micheals
N.Ablett
Mooney
Ottens
Egan
Scarlet
Lynch
Hansen
Cox
Hunter
Glass
Llyod
Lucas
Hille
Fletcher
Micheals
N.Ablett
Mooney
Ottens
Egan
Scarlet
Melbourne has actually got a decent spine developing.
FB: Frawley
CHB: Rivers
Centre: McLean
CHF: Bate/Dunn
FF: Newton
FB: Frawley
CHB: Rivers
Centre: McLean
CHF: Bate/Dunn
FF: Newton
- Mar 23, 2007
- 34,932
- 23,542
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Man U, Canucks and 49ers
How good a full forward is Kozi?
Turn it up mate, West Coasts spine is well & truly stronger than that.
How funny is life sometimes...a spine containing Lynch that some non Eagles supporters have conceded is the best. 
You are all missing the point. The best spine in the competition belongs to Robert Harvey. He has been carrying the Saints all these years and they still can't win a premiership.
Another option for best spine is Nathan Buckley. He has to have something going for him with a box head like that.
i think bulldogs spine is the best,
also who has the worst spine?!?!?!?!
Harris
Williams
West
????
????
Fremantle do
Parker (now grover)
Mcpharlin
Carr
Tarrant
Pavlich
Gilham v N. Ablett-> N.Ablett would win easily
Croad v Mooney-> Tough, but Mooney would win
Hodge v Bartel-> Bartel easily
Franklin v Egan-> Egan
Roughead v Scarlett-> Scarlett would win the contest, and rack up more possessions then anyone else on the field.
I guess it would be entrallling to see the Cats spine take control of the game.
- Apr 20, 2006
- 9,646
- 13,053
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Thorton
Waite
Juddy (Stevens)
Fisher
Fevola
Waite
Juddy (Stevens)
Fisher
Fevola
It's quite funny that in the Prelim final this year, the Roos had would have had one of the worst spines in the AFL, with injuries.
Firrito
Watt
Simpson
Hale
Edwards
Next year (with development, our spine looks excellent)
Firrito
Petrie
Harris
Thompson
Jones
Firrito
Watt
Simpson
Hale
Edwards
Next year (with development, our spine looks excellent)
Firrito
Petrie
Harris
Thompson
Jones
Wonder Years
Team Captain
- Apr 6, 2005
- 438
- 4
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
maybe but Tommy has hardly played and either has Nathan Ablett I think compared to Boyle they have much more room for improvement but so do Roughead and Franklin.
You do have Marky to come back as well but Dixon will be a bigger loss than most people think!
Smyth94
Norm Smith Medallist
Do you realise that Stanton perhaps only just turned 22. No room for improvement whatsoever? None? Nothing?
doggies_5
Team Captain
i think bulldogs spine is the best,
also who has the worst spine?!?!?!?!
Harris - 2007 b&f
Williams - most promising player at the bulldogs this year
West - 7 time b&f
Pick 5
Johnson - best small forward in the comp, 299 games under his belt
Just filled it out for you
If you think he will develop into an A grader - hahahahahahahahahaha! Seriously he isnt going to be that good!
Maguire can't play full back - he's too slow off the mark since his injury. Hudghton is still our best option there with Maguire @ CHB
Has the potential to be one of the best in the league. Pinch hitted down there a few times this year when Gehrig didn't play and looked more than handy.
Question is can the Saints afford to play him there with the other ruckmen we have on our list.
TheWiseOne
Club Legend
Essendon would probably go:
Michael
Fletcher/Ryder (AA/RS nominee)
McVeigh EFC B&F
Lucas (top 10 coleman in 07)
Lloyd (top 10 coleman in 07)
+McVeigh is a better option than Stants in the middle at the moment
Cant go past Eagles for the best.
However, Cats:
Scarlett
Egan
Ablett/Bartel
Mooney
Ottens
tough one to beat
Michael
Fletcher/Ryder (AA/RS nominee)
McVeigh EFC B&F
Lucas (top 10 coleman in 07)
Lloyd (top 10 coleman in 07)
+McVeigh is a better option than Stants in the middle at the moment
Cant go past Eagles for the best.
However, Cats:
Scarlett
Egan
Ablett/Bartel
Mooney
Ottens
tough one to beat
That's true, but consider that throughout the year we had injuries to Corey Jones, Daniel Wells and Nathan Thompson, and played in a final where Firrito was clearly injured. Jones, Wells and Thompson are easily in the Top 10, if not Top 5 players at the club, and Firrito is probebly our main defender. I realise the Saints have had a lot of injuries, but our injuries weren't exactly minimal.
Sjohnson spends a fair bit of time at FF. You could say Geelong's spine is all AA.
Similar threads
