Big Reds annual top 50

[Big Red is back]

Guys never easy to compile my top 50 and especially tough doing it at work in 1 hour however nevertheless here it is. Critera is the same as Mike it assumes the players are up and running and full fitness

• Lance Franklin
• Gary Ablett
• Chris Judd
• D Cox
• Brendan Fevola
• Mathew Richardson
• M Pavlich
• C Cornes
• Nick Riewoldt
• J Brown
• Mathew Scarlett
• Jimmy Bartel
• B Harvey
• A Cooney
• Joel Selwood
• Luke Hodge
• Sam Mitchell
• D Kerr
• Paul Chapman
• Joel Corey
• Dane Swan
• K Cornes
• Nathan Bock’
• S Burgone
• A Goodes
• S Black
• J Roughead
• S Johnson
• D Bradshaw
• A. Didak
• B Johnson
• Sam Fisher
• Heath Shaw
• Scott Thompson
• Nathan G Brown
• Andrew Mackie
• Paul Medhurst
• Glass
• L Hayes
• L Ball
• Drew Petrie
• D Hille
• M Lloyd
• A.Sandilands
• B Kirk
• B.Sewell
• C Ling
• R. Okeefe
• D Morris
• Luke Power
• B.Goddard (woops 51)

Enjoy

Big Red

 

[Reasonable]

[*]David Johnson

Who the **** is that?

 

[Tex_21]

Who the **** is that?

Geelong reserves player. Very underrated-good pick up by BigRed

 

[Big Red is back]

Geelong reserves player. Very underrated-good pick up by BigRed

Dont be silly guys

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

So unless I'm mistaken, you're admitting that Judd and Fevola are the only decent players in the Carlton squad?

 

[Bigeasy]

You have Shaw, Mackie, Ball and Hayes in front of Luke Power?

 

[GAJ!]

The Carlton supporter has 2 blues players in the top 5

 

[blues4flag]

And Mike Sheahan had two in the top 6.

No doubting the ability of Fev and Judd.

 

[blues4flag]

So unless I'm mistaken, you're admitting that Judd and Fevola are the only decent players in the Carlton squad?

There's only 50 decent players in the competition now?

I'd hate to be the one to tell the other 580 that they're all spuds...

 

[choco123]

No Murphy, Gibbs or Waite (like the Carlton poster's one on the main board)?

Sacrilege!

 

[blue gunslinger]

they may not be there at the moment but they will be there. Not too much on the Bear's horizon is there

 

[thatswhatimtalkinabout]

And Mike Sheahan had two in the top 6.

No doubting the ability of Fev and Judd.

You are so much better than this.

Admitedly you haven't ever shown it, but I reckon you may be.

One day.

Sometime.

Not soon.

There's no rush.

 

[choco123]

they may not be there at the moment but they will be there. Not too much on the Bear's horizon is there

Yep, I reckon Waite's shown a lot of promise over his last 6 or so seasons at Carlton. Watch for this exciting youngster to explode onto the AFL scene in 2009 (could have interchanged the 9 for an 8, or a 7, or a 6, or a 5 etc. etc.)

Please, please learn basic English Peashooter. You are simply confirming my suspicion that you edit the 'wablues' site, what with your hilarious attempts at grammar.

 

[Big Red is back]

You have Shaw, Mackie, Ball and Hayes in front of Luke Power?

Correct I think Luke is alittle past his best but nevertherless a fine player

 

[Big Red is back]

No Murphy, Gibbs or Waite (like the Carlton poster's one on the main board)?

Sacrilege!

Gibbs was very close, each of them would be in the 50 to 100 range

So far my feeling is I have done better than Mike S

 

[Neville Bartos]

Terrible effort, yet you've somehow managed to a better job than Sheehan and Rucci. That's how shocking their efforts were.

And to be honest, I was shocked to see that you had Luke 'Soft possession, back pocket, wasted draft pick, seriously overweight" Hodge in your Top 50 at all

 

[Big Red is back]

Terrible effort, yet you've somehow managed to a better job than Sheehan and Rucci. That's how shocking their efforts were.

And to be honest, I was shocked to see that you had Luke 'Soft possession, back pocket, wasted draft pick, seriously overweight" Hodge in your Top 50 at all

Please feel free to provide your top 50 and or atleast add some constructive criticism.

Hodgey is a very good player but as you will note I have placed elite mids, the best defender since SOS and elite fwds ahead of him.

 

[portfan36]

Mathew Stokes should be in there somewhere. And somewhere in the top 30 I reckon. Theres not too many small guys that can be match winners like him.

 

[TwiggleyFanClub]

What, no Jack Anthony???!?!! What sort of dud top 50 is this????

 

[Neville Bartos]

Please feel free to provide your top 50 and or atleast add some constructive criticism.

Hodgey is a very good player but as you will note I have placed elite mids, the best defender since SOS and elite fwds ahead of him.

Just remind me how a guy who plays 12 rounds as a midfielder and 5 rounds as a defender is classified?

The most I will give you is that Hodge is a utility, as is Chad Cornes, Matthew Pavlich and Richo, so make sure you rate all of them below Priddis, Cross and Carazzo

 

[blues4flag]

You are so much better than this.

*smile begins to breakout across blues4flag's face*

Admitedly you haven't ever shown it, but I reckon you may be.

One day.

Sometime.

Not soon.

There's no rush.

*blues4flag plummets back down to Earth*

 

[The Kipster]

I always thought you were a knob end with no footy knowledge 'BigRed' and now I know it

 

[Big Red is back]

Mathew Stokes should be in there somewhere. And somewhere in the top 30 I reckon. Theres not too many small guys that can be match winners like him.

mmm.. potentially boy can play, maybe his grand final tarnished me