Big V

[Jack-Packenham]

If a Victorian state of origin team was being picked now, who would make it.

My team

B : GILBEE SCARLETT WIRRPANDA
HB : HODGE LUCAS MCPHEE
C : CHAPMAN WEST DAL SANTO
HF : B JOHNSON HALL O'KEEFE
F : G ABLETT J BROWN FEVOLA
FOLL : EVERITT GOODES JUDD
INT : EGAN RICHITELLI POWER MITCHELL

thoughts ????

 

[Ron]

Wirrpanda sounds like some kickarse toy.
Some kind of awesome Panda with guns and shit, yeah that'd rock.

 

[iveplayedeverywhere]

If a Victorian state of origin team was being picked now, who would make it.

My team

B : GILBEE SCARLETT WIRRPANDA
HB : HODGE LUCAS MCPHEE
C : CHAPMAN WEST DAL SANTO
HF : B JOHNSON HALL O'KEEFE
F : G ABLETT J BROWN FEVOLA
FOLL : EVERITT GOODES JUDD
INT : EGAN RICHITELLI POWER MITCHELL

thoughts ????

Just posted a new thread on this topic... Check it...

 

[Tas]

Missing B. Harvey

 

[peternorth]

egan?

 

[Big Nasty]

man I hope they bring it back. In say 5 years time would Hawkins play for Vic or the Allies.

 

[Big Nasty]

egan?

Yeah Matthew Egan. Your ignorance just and many other peoples ignorance of him just shows how underated a defender he is.

 

[discoduck]

If a Victorian state of origin team was being picked now, who would make it.

My team

B : GILBEE SCARLETT WIRRPANDA
HB : HODGE LUCAS MCPHEE
C : CHAPMAN WEST DAL SANTO
HF : B JOHNSON HALL O'KEEFE
F : G ABLETT J BROWN FEVOLA
FOLL : EVERITT GOODES JUDD
INT : EGAN RICHITELLI POWER MITCHELL

thoughts ????

if you can't find a spot for lucas in the forward line, you don't give him a guernsey. imho, you don't play players out of position for victoria. i think you'd find a spot, however. hall hasn't done much yet - lucas can have his spot.

however, i am struggling to think of a chb who's playing well to this stage. um, matt egan from geelong? i see you've got him on the bench - that will allow brad sewell to have a spot - very deserved.

 

[Strike Swiftly]

whats the point of playing lucas at chb? he has been running hot at chf. defeats the point of picking him if you play him there.

 

[Strike Swiftly]

why not have fletcher at chb. been playing well there.

 

[Lonie_from_50]

My attempt, probably missed someone

B: Lindsay Gilbee, Matthew Scarlett, Heath Shaw
HB: Cameron Bruce, Dustin Fletcher, David Mundy
C: Adam Goodes, Scott West, Nick Dal Santo
HF: Paul Chapman, Jonathan Brown, Ryan O'Keefe
F: Brad Johnson, Brendan Fevola, Barry Hall
Foll: Peter Everitt, Chris Judd, Sam Mitchell
I/C: Luke Hodge, Jeff White, Brent Harvey, Scott Lucas

 

[turtz]

My attempt, probably missed someone

B: Lindsay Gilbee, Matthew Scarlett, Heath Shaw
HB: Cameron Bruce, Dustin Fletcher, David Mundy
C: Adam Goodes, Scott West, Nick Dal Santo
HF: Paul Chapman, Jonathan Brown, Ryan O'Keefe
F: Brad Johnson, Brendan Fevola, Barry Hall
Foll: Peter Everitt, Chris Judd, Sam Mitchell
I/C: Luke Hodge, Jeff White, Brent Harvey, Scott Lucas

Take out all melbourne players. Don't deserve a Red and Blue jumper let alone the treasured Big V!

 

[Big Nasty]

My attempt, probably missed someone

B: Lindsay Gilbee, Matthew Scarlett, Heath Shaw
HB: Cameron Bruce, Dustin Fletcher, David Mundy
C: Adam Goodes, Scott West, Nick Dal Santo
HF: Paul Chapman, Jonathan Brown, Ryan O'Keefe
F: Brad Johnson, Brendan Fevola, Barry Hall
Foll: Peter Everitt, Chris Judd, Sam Mitchell
I/C: Luke Hodge, Jeff White, Brent Harvey, Scott Lucas

where the hell is Gablett

 

[Footylover1]

If a Victorian state of origin team was being picked now, who would make it.

My team

B : GILBEE SCARLETT WIRRPANDA
HB : HODGE LUCAS MCPHEE
C : CHAPMAN WEST DAL SANTO
HF : B JOHNSON HALL O'KEEFE
F : G ABLETT J BROWN FEVOLA
FOLL : EVERITT GOODES JUDD
INT : EGAN RICHITELLI POWER MITCHELL

thoughts ????

Way too early to be picking state of origin sides

 

[Footylover1]

where the hell is Gablett

And where is Darren Jolly? lol

 

[Lowie01]

My attempt, probably missed someone

B: Lindsay Gilbee, Matthew Scarlett, Heath Shaw
HB: Cameron Bruce, Dustin Fletcher, David Mundy
C: Adam Goodes, Scott West, Nick Dal Santo
HF: Paul Chapman, Jonathan Brown, Ryan O'Keefe
F: Brad Johnson, Brendan Fevola, Barry Hall
Foll: Peter Everitt, Chris Judd, Sam Mitchell
I/C: Luke Hodge, Jeff White, Brent Harvey, Scott Lucas

Super team that, it's hard to argue with it on any count. Johnno would be captain, of course.

 

[Big Cox]

You forgot Mitch Brown

 

[Big Nasty]

You forgot Mitch Brown

c'mon mate

 

[Papa G]

My attempt, probably missed someone

B: Lindsay Gilbee, Matthew Scarlett, Heath Shaw
HB: Cameron Bruce, Dustin Fletcher, David Mundy
C: Adam Goodes, Scott West, Nick Dal Santo
HF: Paul Chapman, Jonathan Brown, Ryan O'Keefe
F: Brad Johnson, Brendan Fevola, Barry Hall
Foll: Peter Everitt, Chris Judd, Sam Mitchell
I/C: Luke Hodge, Jeff White, Brent Harvey, Scott Lucas

If you have to include a Collingwood player - surely it wouldn't be Heath Shaw. Not a bad player, but far from elite. I would put Dane Swan in ahead of him or even Ben Johnson

 

[Big Cox]

c'mon mate

. Maybe next year huh

 

[Lonie_from_50]

If you have to include a Collingwood player - surely it wouldn't be Heath Shaw. Not a bad player, but far from elite. I would put Dane Swan in ahead of him or even Ben Johnson

I put the two best rebounding Victorian defenders in...Lindsay Gilbee, and Heath Shaw

 

[Lonie_from_50]

. Maybe next year huh

Nathan J.

 

[Sedition]

The only way the Vic's are gonna win anything is by playing SOO. That's why they obsess about it.

 

[St-KriS]

I put the two best rebounding Victorian defenders in...Lindsay Gilbee, and Heath Shaw

Gram would be worth a mention to yeah? I think he's had a better season than Bruce so far anyway.

 

[carn_the_cattas]

Based on recent form, Jimmy Bartel would be up there.