Strategy Blair Hartley Project 2015 II

[BILC]

Our first for Carltons second + Yarran?

 

[Bazzar]

Cant remember which footy show it was last night, but they said the Tiges should be going for both Motlop and Yarran.

 

[Groupie_]

Cant remember which footy show it was last night, but they said the Tiges should be going for both Motlop and Yarran.

easier said than done

 

[Thrillhouse!]

Cant remember which footy show it was last night, but they said the Tiges should be going for both Motlop and Yarran.

Classifieds

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk

 

[David3030]

Agree.
Wouldn't complain.
Maybe another nibble at Trengrove with our 2nd might be on the cards,Considering its 12mnths on and his value would have dropped.

Signed a 2 year extension at the Shemons I believe

 

[ReaperX]

If Stevie J is cut off by the Cats, should we consider picking him up as a mature aged recruit and plonking him in our forward line for 1-2 years?

I would personally love the idea, in all honesty he's still playing fantastic footy for the Cats, but considering they have about 9 guys over 30 on their list, it's understandable that they'd want to develop some of their young guns, and therefore would potentially look to move him on.

Provided of course that we picked him up as either a UFA or a DFA, and that it didn't interfere with our other plans for securing talent such as Yarran, Motlop, or whoever else, I think we'd be mad to not at least consider the possibility. To be fair, the same discussion was had about Chappy before he went to Essendon, but I think Stevie J has shown that he's still got the capacity to play a permanent small forward role very very well.

For anybody who watches On The Couch, they said that Stevie J is one of only 8 players in the competition who currently averages more than 20 possessions and 1 goal per game.

For the record, two of the other eight players were Brett Deledio and Dustin Martin, and another one was Steven Motlop. So if we managed to secure Motlop as well, we'd have 4 of the 8 players on that list running around for us, which would make us a very dangerous outfit.

Also, given the news about the retirement of Chris Newman, and also previously Nathan Foley (our two oldest players), it certainly would not be a stretch to get him on the list at 31 years of age, considering that our next oldest player would be Ivan Maric at 29 years old (turning 30).

The upside of bringing Stevie J into our team would far outweight any potential risks or negatives, and if he is indeed cut loose by the Cats, we should consider it very seriously.

Thoughts?

 

[RobsJourney]

Totally agree, if he comes across free and cheap, do it.
We will be lacking in older players and at best he is still a gun.
Also knows how to win a flag.

 

[DeseRigs]

Could be a handy sub in the grand final next year.

 

[Tig22]

Do you think he'd be after a lot of money though? I do.
I also reckon other teams would outbid us for him, if he doesn't just retire instead.

 

[mattt]

I'd take him for a year or two.

Seems to be getting increasingly thuggish of late though... bit more of a sniper. Not sure if it's the 'culture' we want to introduce.

 

[Nostradumbass]

I reckon he'll stay at Geelong.

 

[Danog]

The Giants offered 2 first round picks for him last year. Crazy that the Cats didn't take it.

 

[ReaperX]

Do you think he'd be after a lot of money though? I do.
I also reckon other teams would outbid us for him, if he doesn't just retire instead.

Depends on what you'd define as "alot of money"

I'd happily part with 700k over 2 years for him, maybe 400k next year, and down to 300k in 2017.

It'd probably be somewhat of a paycut compared to his Geelong contract, but then again, it'd surely be better than the 100k he would earn in the bush league.

Not sure if many clubs would go for him, given his age. Our club is one of the few that doesn't have anybody over 30 years old, but is still a team that will be looking to contend from next year onwards, and so can afford to offer him something.

Freo, Hawks, Swans, North, and even the Dogs have a bunch of guys over 30 already.

Eagles might be the only other team who are in our situation, but I doubt Stevie would uproot to WA, and the Eagles already have his position covered anyway.

Stevie J to Richmond would be a perfect match for mine, tbh.

 

[Ned_Flanders]

Body shot, no

 

[RobsJourney]

The Giants offered 2 first round picks for him last year. Crazy that the Cats didn't take it.

surely not ?!?! crazy offer

 

[Nostradumbass]

surely not ?!?! crazy offer

Yeah they did.

 

[tugga]

No

 

["The Roar Is Back"]

Cant remember which footy show it was last night, but they said the Tiges should be going for both Motlop and Yarran.

It was footy classified.
This shit about dimma being two faced is a crook of shit. He stated that he thought the system was flawed in that clubs could speak to players mid contract and it be played out within the media.
At no stage did he say he wouldn't he is playing within rules he thinks need altered.

 

[Grockadoc]

Don't like him as a person, but would be handy to put on a flank to have Menadue develop in the VFL. So if he comes relatively cheap, I wouldn't be against it.

 

[ReaperX]

No

Could you possibly elaborate on this opinion a bit more?

 

[tigerninja]

Too self centered. Can see him rocking up to the players on arrival and the first thing he would say to them is "you've got front row tickets to the stevie J show".

 

[DrMike]

Advanced warning: Merging opposition player threads into this one then starting a new thread, too many happening which is the purpose of this thread

 

[theyellowsash]

would rather put the time into lennon or a younger forward. of course if we go very deep into finals he could be worth it for a couple of years to push us that last little bit towards a premiership, but i still dont think we go past week 1 of finals yet so i dont think we are in a position to take a player of his age as a top up.

 

[aislegi]

I'd take him for a year or two.

Seems to be getting increasingly thuggish of late though... bit more of a sniper. Not sure if it's the 'culture' we want to introduce.

Also started/taught Joel Selwood that head-duck malarkey

 

[sregit]

Crazy idea. His hart wouldn't be in it and he'd only be chasing the dollars. He's finished. Look to the future. We need 25 year olds not over 30s looking for a final pay day.