Bluemour Melting Pot XXVII

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.

Log in to remove this ad.

Wow what a night after days of nothing.

Took forever to catch up.

If we are shopping off two firsts and a player for Oliver. We need a 2nd coming back our way.

Then 2 seconda for Saad which they can package up anyway they want.

Pick 8, Future 1st, JSOS/Kennedy for Oliver and Melb future second and then Pick 29, Melb future second (29?) for Saad would be a great result.
 
I must say, as much as I think Fogarty is a decent player and I'd be happy to have him on the list, it does seem strange that we'd consider giving up Macreadie for him given the abundance of midfielders we have and the relative dearth of tall defenders behind our front liners. We've just ditched Silvagni and Goddard and it's unlikely we'll have pick 8 to pick a top line young key defender. I wonder who they have in mind...

We have Cuningham, Dow, Stocker, Kemp, Philp, SPS, Kennedy, Fisher, Ramsey and Gibbons who would all love midfield time in the 1s and I don't see Fogarty as a major upgrade on them. If we want a small forward I'd prefer someone who has lived and breathed small forward life, who just loves kicking goals and has a history of doing so.

Nobody has said we are considering giving up Macreadie for Fogarty.
 
Just wondering the purpose and timing of the Damo, Rendell & SOS session to close the show today, which was shoehorned in while callers were overlooked.
What are the trades worth........ Saad? Rendell 14-15, SOS 20, Damo "similar". Pre emptive face saving for "our mate" when correct value is recieved rather than continuing to posture for #8 alone??????

Following the blurb about Rendell's contacts and Carlton holding up all of *'s trades. Will be interesting following tonight's predictions from our ITK bunch.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

There's more chance of me ending up of Essendon's list that Gov.
Gunna miss you. Any chance you do a MM and destroy the place from the inside?
 
Possibly, but Id say with Marchbank returning, Gov and Levi able to fill in its kind of covered for now, though another wouldnt go astray.
Ben being rookied Would give us the cover we need really.
 
Whichever way this thing breaks I think it would be wrong to screw over Saad - besides he's a terrific player, he's nominated us and we need him. But having said that we should bring him across on our terms and not * terms.
We should bring him across on mutually agreeable terms.

Unfortunately one party seems intent on being belligerent about things.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top