Brownlow Medal 2013

[Substance]

Watson is on track for 66 votes.

 

[Lensen]

didn't see the swans/GC game, any chance k.jack votes?

 

[Rooster Cogburn]

didn't see the swans/GC game, any chance k.jack votes?

Possibly, he tagged Ablett in midfield and pretty much shut him down, with Nick Smith picking him up when he rested forward.

I reckon:

3 McVeigh
2 ROK
1 Jack

Though Ablett will probably steel a vote

 

[NSLK]

didn't see the swans/GC game, any chance k.jack votes?

I'd lock him in for one.

 

[yamahamoto]

Possibly, he tagged Ablett in midfield and pretty much shut him down, with Nick Smith picking him up when he rested forward.

I reckon:

3 McVeigh
2 ROK
1 Jack

Though Ablett will probably steel a vote

No way Ablett will get a vote in this game...didnt even do anything...your initial 3,2,1 is pretty much spot on...

 

[Rooster Cogburn]

No way Ablett will get a vote in this game...didnt even do anything...your initial 3,2,1 is pretty much spot on...

I agree, but he's been given points many, many times in the past when he probably didn't deserve.

Tom Harley got laughed at by the other commentators when he suggested he should get 3. I didn't catch the start of the convo, so I don't know if he was serious or not.

 

[X_box_X]

didn't see the swans/GC game, any chance k.jack votes?

I came in here to see if anyone fancied him. It would be a hell of an effort to win the Brownlow, but it would be an incredible story.

 

[chrisdon16]

Watto has 6 votes, 5 at worst so far after 2 rounds. Get on him to back to back while the odds are still good. Lets just hope he doesn't snap his shin :/

 

[yamahamoto]

Selwood would be on minimum 5 ...3 last game and at least a 2 yesterday

 

[NSLK]

J Riewoldt
Cotchin
Conca

McVeigh
O'Keefe
Jack

Fyfe
Liberatore
Mzungu

Dangerfield
Sloane
Hanley

Westhoff
Boak
Wingard

Watson
Heppell
Bellchambers

Bartel
Selwood
Swallow

Elliot
Garlett
Pendlebury

Mitchell
Birchall
Rioli

Discussion would be good - not 100% sold on the vote for Mzungu, Bellchambers, Wingard or the 2/3 for Coll/Carl.

 

[TheJanuaryMan]

St Kil v Rich

3. B. Deledio (Rich) - kept them moving all game, under the umpire's nose
2. T. Cotchin (Rich) - massive second half, first half really quiet
1. J. Riewoldt (Rich)

Syd v GC

3. J. McVeigh (Syd)
2. R. O'Keefe (Syd)
1. K. Jack (Syd)

WB v Freo

3. N. Fyfe (Freo)
2. T. Mzingu (Freo)
1. A. Cooney (WB)

Bris v Adel

3. P. Hanley (Bris)
2. P. Dangerfield (Adel)
1. R. Sloane (Adel)

PA v GWS

3. J. Westhoff (PA) - not many clearer 3 vote games this year
2. C. Wingard (PA)
1. T. Boak (PA)

Ess v Melb

3. J. Watson (Ess)
2. D. Heppell (Ess)
1. S. Crameri (Ess)

Geel v North Melb

3. J. Selwood (Geel)
2. A. Swallow (NM)
1. J. Bartel (Geel)

Coll v Carl

3. J. Elliott (Coll)
2. Q. Lynch (Coll)
1. C. Judd (Carl)

WCE v Haw

3. S Mitchell (Haw)
2. G. Birchall (Haw)
1. J. Kennedy (WCE)

progressive: 6 - J. Watson, J. Selwood
4. T Cotchin, A Swallow, K. Jack

 

[NSLK]

Thoughts on last night? Did Fyfe do enough for best on? Goddard, Hibberd, Ryder, Carlisle and Stanton all chances.

 

[yamahamoto]

Ffye was everywhere so I think he got the 3. Ryder was also impressive and the late goal might get him the 2. Carlisle deserved 1 at least. Well that's my thought anyway

 

[liam_13]

Jack @ $23 is good value. Would be going head-to-head with Watson right now.

And considering Hodge has polled 15+ votes 4 times in his career, and had his best game in years today (possibly indicating a return to form), $201 is value imo.

 

[Duritz]

3 to cox yesterday?

 

[yamahamoto]

Between him and Scott selwood

 

[NSLK]

My Top 10 after Round 3:

1. Watson (6 votes)
= Fyfe
= Cotchin
= Boak
4. J Selwood (5 votes)
= Mitchell
= McVeigh
= Armitage
8. Jack (4 votes)
= Pendlebury
= Westhoff

 

[JDC!]

My Top 10 after Round 3:

1. Watson (6 votes)
= Fyfe
= Watson
= Boak
4. J Selwood (5 votes)
= Mitchell
= McVeigh
= Armitage
8. Jack (4 votes)
= Pendlebury
= Westhoff

Who have you given Richmond votes to? Would think Cotchin and/or Deledio would have grabbed a few at this stage.

 

[NSLK]

Who have you given Richmond votes to? Would think Cotchin and/or Deledio would have grabbed a few at this stage.

2nd Watson was supposed to be Cotchin.

Deledio, Riewoldt and Martin on 3.

 

[wce_dyl]

Any value on Josh Kennedy (syd ) @ $17?

 

[TheJanuaryMan]

FREO v ESS

3. B. Goddard (Ess)
2. N Fyfe (Freo)
1. J. Carlisle (Ess)

NORTH MELB v SYD

3. J McVeigh (Syd)
2. N. Malceskis (Syd)
1. D. Hannerbery (Syd)

MELB v WEST COAST

3. D. Cox (WC)
2. C. Masten (WC)
1. M. Priddis (WC)

GWS v St KILDA

3. D. Armitage (St K)
2. L. Montagna (St K)
1. N. Dal Santo (St K)

GEEL v CARL

3. A. Christensen (Geel)
2. C. Judd (Carl)
1. M. Stokes (Geel)

GOLD COAST v BRIS

3. J. Brennan (GC)
2. J. Brown (Bris)
1. D. Rich (Bris)

RICH v WB

3. T. Cotchin (Rich)
2. B. Deledio (Rich)
1. D. Martin (Rich)

COLL v HAW

3. L. Hodge (Haw)
2. S. Burgoyne (Haw)
1. L. Franklin (Haw)

PT ADEL v ADEL

3. T. Boak (Pt A)
2. J. Westhoff (Pt A)
1. R. Sloane (Adel)

Progressive:

7. T. Cotchin (Rich)
6. J. Watson (Ess), J. Selwood (Geel), J McVeigh (Syd)
5. N. Fyfe (Freo), J. Westhoff (PA)

 

[GrandBlue]

Scott Thompson out of contention.

Also, 100% sure Selwood is on at least 6 votes at this point.

 

[kaiserchief13]

Selwood, Watson and Westhoff leading at the moment on 7-8

 

[TheJanuaryMan]

good to see a bit more discussion in this thread now, didn't seem much happening.

SYD V GEEL

3. J. Selwood (Geel)
2. M. Stokes (Geel)
1. D. Hannebery (Syd)

HAW v FREO

3. S. Burgoyne (Haw)
2. G. Birchall (Haw)
1. N. Fyfe (Freo)

RICH v COLL

3. T. Cloke (Coll)
2. D. Swan (Coll)
1. S. Sidebottom (Coll)

ST K v ESS

3. J. Watson (Ess)
2. D. Heppell (Ess)
1. B. Goddard (Ess)

WCE v CARL

3. M. Murphy (Carl)
2. C. Yarran (Carl)
1. B. McLean (Carl)

GC v PA

3. H. Hartlett (PA)
2. T. Boak (PA)
1. J. Westhoff (PA)

MELB v GWS

3. J, Grimes (Melb)
2. D. Shiel (GWS)
1. M. Evans (Melb)

ADEL v WB

3. R. Sloane (Adel)
2. P. Dangerfield (Adel)
1. A. Otten (Adel)

NM v BRIS

3. S. Thompson (NM)
2. D. Wells (NM)
1. J. Ziebell (NM)

LEADERS: 9 – J. Watson (Ess), J. Selwood (Geel)
7. T. Cotchin (Rich)
6. J. Westhoff, T. Boak, H. Hartlett (PA), J. McVeigh (Syd), N. Fyfe (Freo), R. Sloane (Adel)

 

[yamahamoto]

i think Gumbleton might sneak the 1...he had a huge game...12 marks...with a few big contested marks in the 50s as well