Brownlow Medal Predictor 2011

[criticize]

murphy should be ahead of judd at this stage in the count.

judd should not poll votes in rnd 1- played 1 good quater disposal by foot was shocking.
murphy, gibbs, jack all better.

rnd 2 against the gold coast- any one could poll here gibbs and muprhy racked them
heaps of blokes kicked bags, judd did a bit of both.
2votes?

rnd 3- vs pies cant see any carlton players polling

rnd 4- ess should not poll- fletch jobe yarran

rnd 5- ade 2 votes with murphy 3 or vice versa

rnd6- syd lock for 3 votes

rnd7- st.k hard game to predict the umpires votes, duigan, yarran, fisher, jamison, gibs the likely sorts.



he should be on 7 (IMO) he will probably be on 9 though and possibly as high as 11.



for the record i think murphy should have 2 vs rich, 3 vs gc, 3 vs ade, for 8. likely to be a less with judd theivery.

 

[criticize]

swan is also very ovverated as far as a brownlow goes.


rnd 1- port- heap of touches and a few goals disposal disquting- i think he should get 2 Johnson getting 3, swan probaly gets 3 though.


rnd 2- nth- swan and pendles fighting it out pendles better for mine.

rnd 3 carl- no votes here crap for 3 quaters lots of junk in the last

rnd 4- rich- good game 3 votes

rnd 5-ess- pendles for 3- swan did not get a single vote in all of the anzac day voters sheets

rnd 6- bull- didnt do much on a hard day where no one did that great a fair few ahead of him in line for the votes-

Rnd 8- did nothing in the first or the last raked up cheap possies in the 2nd and 3rd turnovers galore.



highest 9- should be (imo) 7

 

[Ghost of Grinter]

Put it this way, Judd missed the first 3 games last year and still won it.

Being the captain massively enhances ones chance, probably doubles it.

Murphy wont take votes off Judd, either will Gibbs, they might have
better games - but they wont take the votes.

The brownlow needs to be looked at anyway, Dane Swan and Ablett
were so far ahead of the rest of the comp last year and its a slap in the
face to have a bloke miss 3 games, get a few 20 touch 3 voters and
romp in whats supposed to be the games MVP award for throughout the year.

 

[Billyc]

If Moloney got up, he'd be the worst Brownlow medallist since the last time a Melbourne player won the Brownlow Medal.

 

[dacloud]

Well, Judd would deserve it at this point, which means he probably won't win it.

pretty much sums it up.
very rarely goes to the player who deserves it most.

 

[criticize]

pretty much sums it up.
very rarely goes to the player who deserves it most.

Except for the part which states Judd deserves it.