Re: Your Brownlow tip.
I hope a forward wins it this year as well i'm tired of midfielders always winning it!
thekid178 said:
I hope a forward wins it this year as well i'm tired of midfielders always winning it!
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Brownlow Medal
- Thread starter Ricketts
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Asgardian
Bigfooty Jedi
Re: Your Brownlow tip.
Carey always ruined his chances by giving the umps too much "advice"
From my club, Tredrea has to have a reasonable chance
Judd heads a long list of good midfield Brownlow chances
Carey always ruined his chances by giving the umps too much "advice"
From my club, Tredrea has to have a reasonable chance
Judd heads a long list of good midfield Brownlow chances
Wheels_83
Debutant
Re: Your Brownlow tip.
25 W.Tredrea (Port)
23 S.Black (Bris)
21 C.Judd (WCE)
18 J.White (Melb)
17 C.Cornes (Port)
16 P.Hasleby (Frem)
16 N.Lappin (Bris)
16 N.Riewoldt (St K)
Well, going by the votes in the Herald Sun (converting the 5-4-3 to 3-2-1) they've got Tredrea winning with 25, ahead of Black with 23.Ten Ton Hammer said:
25 W.Tredrea (Port)
23 S.Black (Bris)
21 C.Judd (WCE)
18 J.White (Melb)
17 C.Cornes (Port)
16 P.Hasleby (Frem)
16 N.Lappin (Bris)
16 N.Riewoldt (St K)
might i add who was the player of the year in the herald sun...
Peter Everitt.. just think he might not be bad value.. no1 from the team can steal votes away and has been very consistent all year.. maybe its just me being biased.. but i think he will poll well...
Peter Everitt.. just think he might not be bad value.. no1 from the team can steal votes away and has been very consistent all year.. maybe its just me being biased.. but i think he will poll well...
man of all mans
Debutant
- Jul 20, 2004
- 80
- 0
- AFL Club
- Geelong
- Banned
- #56
Who will win the Brownlow medal
I think Nick Riewoldt will win the Brownlow
I think Nick Riewoldt will win the Brownlow
Re: Who will win the Brownlow medal
Deserves it, but his best games came when the Saints were going through their bad patch. Unfortunately, Akermanis has had a great year. Even better than when he one it. Think he might do it again. Could his head get any bigger?
man of all mans said:
Deserves it, but his best games came when the Saints were going through their bad patch. Unfortunately, Akermanis has had a great year. Even better than when he one it. Think he might do it again. Could his head get any bigger?
Re: Who will win the Brownlow medal
Not being loyal to my own but l pick Mark Ricciuto to back it up again if he can get a few votes in the last 6 games, first 12- 15 games could have as many as 24 votes but this is only wishful thinking.
Cameron ling as a dark horse
KKP have a tough time polling votes in the Brownlow medal, Carey, Dunstall and Ablett have had super years during the 1990's and didn’t even come close to winning it.man of all mans said:
Not being loyal to my own but l pick Mark Ricciuto to back it up again if he can get a few votes in the last 6 games, first 12- 15 games could have as many as 24 votes but this is only wishful thinking.
Cameron ling as a dark horse
Re: Who will win the Brownlow medal
Akers won't get it, too many players taking votes off him.
Treadrea has got my vote !! (outstanding season).
Judd a smokie..................................
Anthony said:
Akers won't get it, too many players taking votes off him.
Treadrea has got my vote !! (outstanding season).
Judd a smokie..................................
Re: Who will win the Brownlow medal
Here's an original idea for a thread
I've ran throughit all on a game by game basis, being reasonably optimistic about votes for all of the favorites, and it ended up with Reiwoldt, Judd, and Simon Black all in the 22-25 votes range, with Black perhaps slightly off the pace behind the other two. If either of Judd or Reiwoldt don't poll at least 20+ votes it would be astonishing.
Tredrea is a bit harder to tip- by rights he could have anywhere up to 28-30 votes (!), but its just impossible to say whether or not the umpires will recognise a key forward- he could win by a landslide or he could poll nowhere.
Brisbane will have a number of other dark horses who could get across the line with a bit of luck- Lappin and Akka should by rights get around 20 votes as well, with the other guy right up there being Ling.
So yeah at this stage
-Judd/Reiwoldt are the best chances in that they are both effectively guaranteed 20-25 votes.
Tredrea could win by a huge margin or not even poll in the top 10. Black is slightly off the pace but still thereabouts, and frankly it would take some silly voting for any of the next pack - Lappin, Akermanis, Ling, White, Power, and a few others- to get home.
Here's an original idea for a thread
I've ran throughit all on a game by game basis, being reasonably optimistic about votes for all of the favorites, and it ended up with Reiwoldt, Judd, and Simon Black all in the 22-25 votes range, with Black perhaps slightly off the pace behind the other two. If either of Judd or Reiwoldt don't poll at least 20+ votes it would be astonishing.
Tredrea is a bit harder to tip- by rights he could have anywhere up to 28-30 votes (!), but its just impossible to say whether or not the umpires will recognise a key forward- he could win by a landslide or he could poll nowhere.
Brisbane will have a number of other dark horses who could get across the line with a bit of luck- Lappin and Akka should by rights get around 20 votes as well, with the other guy right up there being Ling.
So yeah at this stage
-Judd/Reiwoldt are the best chances in that they are both effectively guaranteed 20-25 votes.
Tredrea could win by a huge margin or not even poll in the top 10. Black is slightly off the pace but still thereabouts, and frankly it would take some silly voting for any of the next pack - Lappin, Akermanis, Ling, White, Power, and a few others- to get home.
Re: Who will win the Brownlow medal
Supporters see the game in a different manner to the umpires and they are the ones who give the votes, we don’t know on any give day if a superstar player have give the umpire a “what for” and this has resulted in him not getting any votes at all, and if it was a senior official he may not give that player any votes for any more games that season, even if he is the BOG. Greg Williams had like 42 touched in 1995 (maybe) last round and didn’t get any votes, l wonder why
What are the odds Scott Mclarin will not give James Hird any votes he has umpired in this season?
Mead said:Here's an original idea for a thread
I've ran throughit all on a game by game basis, being reasonably optimistic about votes for all of the favorites, and it ended up with Reiwoldt, Judd, and Simon Black all in the 22-25 votes range, with Black perhaps slightly off the pace behind the other two. If either of Judd or Reiwoldt don't poll at least 20+ votes it would be astonishing.
Tredrea is a bit harder to tip- by rights he could have anywhere up to 28-30 votes (!), but its just impossible to say whether or not the umpires will recognise a key forward- he could win by a landslide or he could poll nowhere.
Brisbane will have a number of other dark horses who could get across the line with a bit of luck- Lappin and Akka should by rights get around 20 votes as well, with the other guy right up there being Ling.
So yeah at this stage
-Judd/Reiwoldt are the best chances in that they are both effectively guaranteed 20-25 votes.
Tredrea could win by a huge margin or not even poll in the top 10. Black is slightly off the pace but still thereabouts, and frankly it would take some silly voting for any of the next pack - Lappin, Akermanis, Ling, White, Power, and a few others- to get home.
Supporters see the game in a different manner to the umpires and they are the ones who give the votes, we don’t know on any give day if a superstar player have give the umpire a “what for” and this has resulted in him not getting any votes at all, and if it was a senior official he may not give that player any votes for any more games that season, even if he is the BOG. Greg Williams had like 42 touched in 1995 (maybe) last round and didn’t get any votes, l wonder why
What are the odds Scott Mclarin will not give James Hird any votes he has umpired in this season?
- Banned
- #65
Re: Who will win the Brownlow medal
Tie between Chris Grant and Corey Mckernan, with Justin Charles being runner up.
Tie between Chris Grant and Corey Mckernan, with Justin Charles being runner up.
Re: Who will win the Brownlow medal
Ackemanis will score many votes. Is a good chance for another medal.
Ackemanis will score many votes. Is a good chance for another medal.
Re: Who will win the Brownlow medal
Considering the standard of the umpires' decision making this year, I'll say that Matthew Primus is going to win the Brownlow.
Considering the standard of the umpires' decision making this year, I'll say that Matthew Primus is going to win the Brownlow.
mango
Team Captain
Re: Who will win the Brownlow medal
tuff one this year so will go a. mcphee eachway
tuff one this year so will go a. mcphee eachway
- Banned
- #71
Re: Who will win the Brownlow medal
Tredrea.
Tredrea.
leapin_leo
Draftee
- Sep 7, 2004
- 11
- 0
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Other Teams
- Sydney
Re: Who will win the Brownlow medal
tredrea is the biggest tool in afl football..
tredrea is the biggest tool in afl football..
- Thread starter
- #73
Re: Who will win the Brownlow medal
http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?t=130014&page=1&pp=15&highlight=Brownlow
http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?t=130014&page=1&pp=15&highlight=Brownlow
- Thread starter
- #74
Ricketts said:
ditto.
Similar threads
