Lions1993
Team Captain
Re: Who do you think will win the Brownlow?
J.Bartel
J.Bartel
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Brownlow tips
- Thread starter demon_fanatic
- Start date
- Tagged users None
The Cranium
BigFootyDesert Dweller
Re: Who do you think will win the Brownlow?
C. Judd
C. Judd
Re: Who do you think will win the Brownlow?
We need designated panelists awarding brownlow votes at each game. Its time to take it away from the umpires. Forwards will never get a decent go at it the way its happening now.
Perhaps one umpire, one media person, one ex player, and an ex coach can all put in their votes for each game, and come out with a 3,2,1 system that way.
Of course there would have to be people willing to do this once or twice a week as required, but im sure that won't be hard to find.
The medal loses credibility every year, especially with the introduction of things like champion data and the like.
We need designated panelists awarding brownlow votes at each game. Its time to take it away from the umpires. Forwards will never get a decent go at it the way its happening now.
Perhaps one umpire, one media person, one ex player, and an ex coach can all put in their votes for each game, and come out with a 3,2,1 system that way.
Of course there would have to be people willing to do this once or twice a week as required, but im sure that won't be hard to find.
The medal loses credibility every year, especially with the introduction of things like champion data and the like.
Chief
~ Shmalpha ~
- Admin
- #54
Re: Who do you think will win the Brownlow?
Vote here for a shot at a $100 prize:
http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?t=495527
Vote here for a shot at a $100 prize:
http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?t=495527
Re: Who do you think will win the Brownlow?
3. J.Bartel
2. N.Riewoldt
1. B.Harvey
3. J.Bartel
2. N.Riewoldt
1. B.Harvey
Re: Who do you think will win the Brownlow?
Not the worst I've seen. I've run a cross media analysis of the brownlow, round by round, and the most obvious thing that one can deduce is that ablett is an unlikely favourite. I have the excel spreadsheet available for anybody that wants a leg up...
Not the worst I've seen. I've run a cross media analysis of the brownlow, round by round, and the most obvious thing that one can deduce is that ablett is an unlikely favourite. I have the excel spreadsheet available for anybody that wants a leg up...
Re: Who do you think will win the Brownlow?
Bartel will win the Brownlow.
Bartel will win the Brownlow.
spartan hawks
Senior List
Re: Who do you think will win the Brownlow?
I think bartel and judd as my roughie.
I think bartel and judd as my roughie.
StringyDog
Party Pieman
Veteran
Western Bulldogs Board Tipping Champion
Pieman Winner
SuperCoach Club Board Championship League Member
Western Bulldogs - Honeychurch/Austin/Prudden Player Sponsor 2014
Western Bulldogs - Christian Howard/Mark Austin Player Sponsor 2013
Western Bulldogs - Christian Howard/Mark Austin 2012 Player Sponsor
Re: Who do you think will win the Brownlow?
Will have a fair idea by halfway mark, ABlett and Cooney would need to be on or over 20 by halfway otherwise Harvey or Bartel will win
Will have a fair idea by halfway mark, ABlett and Cooney would need to be on or over 20 by halfway otherwise Harvey or Bartel will win
Re: Who do you think will win the Brownlow?
This is no way a dig at Jimmy (I think he's a top player) but am I the only one who reckons he's not elite?
Maybe poor choice of description. Maybe not as elite as the top players in the comp. The Ablett's, Franklin's, Judd's etc?
Add if he won the Brownlow, it'd kinda devalue the whole notion of it.
Bit harsh, but yeah.....
This is no way a dig at Jimmy (I think he's a top player) but am I the only one who reckons he's not elite?
Maybe poor choice of description. Maybe not as elite as the top players in the comp. The Ablett's, Franklin's, Judd's etc?
Add if he won the Brownlow, it'd kinda devalue the whole notion of it.
Bit harsh, but yeah.....
Re: brownlow bets.
Forget Judd. I've done a round by round analysis, assessing performances across multiple media reports. I have an in-depth spreadsheet for those that are interested...
Put $50 on Bartel on the morning of the brownlow last year and pocketed $500.
Am really liking Jimmy and Juddy this year.
Forget Judd. I've done a round by round analysis, assessing performances across multiple media reports. I have an in-depth spreadsheet for those that are interested...
Better_Than_You
Debutant
Re: brownlow bets.
Definitely interested if it is available mate
In particular what does your spreadsheet say about a Bartel-Black quinella...
Definitely interested if it is available mate
In particular what does your spreadsheet say about a Bartel-Black quinella...
dl_renning
Debutant
Re: Who do you think will win the Brownlow?
for what its worth which is bugger all, i think judd will win, reason is the umpires love him and everyone wants to see his missus on tv
for what its worth which is bugger all, i think judd will win, reason is the umpires love him and everyone wants to see his missus on tv
NSWCROW
Make me an Admin!
Brent Harvey will win it.
James Bartel is my tip.
Re: brownlow bets.
no love for judd? okay, will be interesting on the night. i reckon its only out of the big 4 (gaz, jimmy, boomer or judd)..
and yes, im very interested in your spreadsheet, if available
no love for judd? okay, will be interesting on the night. i reckon its only out of the big 4 (gaz, jimmy, boomer or judd)..
and yes, im very interested in your spreadsheet, if available
Re: brownlow bets.
best value for a bet that is an absolute moral is bartel - ablett quinella which is paying $3.50. From the round-by-round analysis that I've done, I can't see anyone coming first or second (I have cooney in third but will not beat ablett).
Put a bit on that and its easy money....
best value for a bet that is an absolute moral is bartel - ablett quinella which is paying $3.50. From the round-by-round analysis that I've done, I can't see anyone coming first or second (I have cooney in third but will not beat ablett).
Put a bit on that and its easy money....
Re: brownlow bets.
How does your analysis work for someone the umps have a man crush on eg. Goodes?
A few of my mates think that Kirk is a sure bet from Sydney to poll the most votes but it wouldn't surprise me if goodes pipped him.
How does your analysis work for someone the umps have a man crush on eg. Goodes?
A few of my mates think that Kirk is a sure bet from Sydney to poll the most votes but it wouldn't surprise me if goodes pipped him.
- Jul 12, 2003
- 6,984
- 12,822
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Re: brownlow bets.
Burgan's phantom Brownlow
http://www.afl.com.au/News/NEWSARTICLE/tabid/208/Default.aspx?newsId=68022
Burgan's phantom Brownlow
http://www.afl.com.au/News/NEWSARTICLE/tabid/208/Default.aspx?newsId=68022
Similar threads
