Traded Bryce Gibbs [traded to Adelaide] - (cont. in Part 2)

[hippyhippy]

Your player started it. You mob have an issue with facts.
Kinda like you think we screwed you over with Betts, when you screwed yourselves over.

If betts was still at carlton he might be retired already. Was playing no where near the level he is today. It will take a long time for carlton to improve. I can't even see them challenging the 8 this year and next.

 

[DanWA]

A 1st & 2nd round pick is not reasonable....

It's a premium already!

Adelaide needs Gibbs more than Carlton wants to part with him

Whether it is overs or not is irrelevant. Reasonable is whatever Carlton wants it to be

That is why this one is so interesting whether Carlton crumbles or Adelaide becomes reasonable

 

[Sin City]

i trade will get done. always does.... its just talk, happens every year right up till the last couple mins.... same with omera

I'm not sure, starting to think this one won't go ahead.

 

[Cleric]

Lol

If trading for Gibbs after you started it is too much for you to handle now , we have Whiley and Graham available ...

Your player came to us and asked for us to get him to Adelaide.
Keep your players under control.

 

[Mego Red]

SOS on trade radio
Just said deal is a long way off
Crows need to offer "a lot more than pick 13" and Lyons pick from GC won't get it done.

Looks more and more that Gibbs stays unless Crows come to the party.

Interesting.

SOS clearly doesn't care much about player's wellbeing. He's being offered more that Gibbs value, and he's telling him to GAGF. Hope the difficulties in Gibbs private life don't hurt his career and damage the Carlton playing group, all because of SOS's hubris.

 

[Mego Red]

Last day of trading

Will Carlton crumble or will Adelaide be reasonable?

Adelaide is already being reasonable in offering 13 plus.

SOS needs to show he's the biggest swinging c*** in the room, which is disappointing.

 

[DanWA]

Interesting.

SOS clearly doesn't care much about player's wellbeing. He's being offered more that Gibbs value, and he's telling him to GAGF. Hope the difficulties in Gibbs private life don't hurt his career and damage the Carlton playing group, all because of SOS's hubris.

On the other hand if Adelaide cared for Gibbs's wellbeing after choosing their club publicly, you would think they would make an offer that is reasonable for Carlton not just for themselves

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Adelaide needs Gibbs more than Carlton wants to part with him

Whether it is overs or not is irrelevant. Reasonable is whatever Carlton wants it to be

That is why this one is so interesting whether Carlton crumbles or Adelaide becomes reasonable

Yes, but there is a cut-off point where you are selling the farm.

2 x 1st rounders is just not worth it.

 

[DanWA]

Adelaide is already being reasonable in offering 13 plus.

SOS needs to show he's the biggest swinging c*** in the room, which is disappointing.

That is not reasonable for Carlton, it is only reasonable for Adelaide

Gibbs has 3 years to run at Carlton, Adelaide fans keep forgetting this

 

[My name geoff]

8 going to GWS for Marchbank and Pickett is way overs. Must be something else included in the deal especially if in all likelihood we're taking Rhys Palmers fat contract off their hands too.

Jack Steele is more proven and went for a 2nd rounder.
WHE going to go for a 3rd-4th
Ahern (Same draft pick 7) went for 68 - yes he's injured but so have pickett and marchbank.

Surely Carlton getting stooged if they trade a first rounder for those two based on this week.

I think 13 plus not much else is fair compensation for gibbs. Get it done and build the war chest for Fyfe next year.

Steele was not best 22 for gws, from what I understand Marchbank was.

Pretty much any player that under 24 that is starting 22 for gws should be worth a first rounder.

 

[DanWA]

Yes, but there is a cut-off point where you are selling the farm.

2 x 1st rounders is just not worth it.

Then Adelaide needs to walk away if they can't come up with a reasonable offer

 

[Red Bull]

Your player came to us and asked for us to get him to Adelaide.
Keep your players under control.

Lol ... amateurs !!

Your close but have you got the balls to go all the way in search of that flag ...

 

[Mego Red]

Lol

If trading for Gibbs after you started it is too much for you to handle now , we have Whiley and Graham available ...

Gibbs and how partner started it, because they want to have a strong family life.

Carlton and SOS have been full of frustrated tears ever since Gibbs said he wanted to break up.

Crows offering more than Gibbs is worth, but SOS would rather keep an unhappy player who won't be there for your next flag run. Hard to understand.

 

[Cleric]

That is not reasonable for Carlton, it is only reasonable for Adelaide

Gibbs has 3 years to run at Carlton, Adelaide fans keep forgetting this

Everyone with any idea think pick 13 is his value. Carlton want overs however due to.him being in contract.
So Adelaide is being reasonable.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Then Adelaide needs to walk away if they can't come up with a reasonable offer

Adelaide have made a reasonable offer - 2 x 1st rounders is unreasonable, for which we will walk away.

Name me the last 27, going on 28 year old traded for 2 x 1st rounders? It's ridiculous overs to expect.

 

[Mego Red]

That is not reasonable for Carlton, it is only reasonable for Adelaide

Gibbs has 3 years to run at Carlton, Adelaide fans keep forgetting this

No, we understand that Gibbs would be unhappy for three years if he is forced to stay. The contract is why we're offering more than 13.

 

[Beer n Skittles]

On the other hand if Adelaide cared for Gibbs's wellbeing after choosing their club publicly, you would think they would make an offer that is reasonable for Carlton not just for themselves

Gibbs didn't choose them publicly. He tried to do it quietly in case the trade didn't go through but Adelaide went to the media

 

[Mego Red]

On the other hand if Adelaide cared for Gibbs's wellbeing after choosing their club publicly, you would think they would make an offer that is reasonable for Carlton not just for themselves

We are. We're offering 13 plus, which is more than Sydney got for Mitchell.

 

[Cleric]

Gibbs didn't choose them publicly. He tried to do it quietly in case the trade didn't go through but Adelaide went to the media

Like him wanting to be traded wasnt going to come out during trade period.
What flavour koolaid do you prefer?

 

[TheHunterCripps]

Interesting.

SOS clearly doesn't care much about player's wellbeing. He's being offered more that Gibbs value, and he's telling him to GAGF. Hope the difficulties in Gibbs private life don't hurt his career and damage the Carlton playing group, all because of SOS's hubris.

Have a sook. You have no idea what the "personal reasons" are. There is no public information available about how badly he wants to go home, or whether it is just a preference. You're making assumptions.

 

[Arthur Dunger]

Stay strong SOS

 

[Milanista28]

Gibbs is a mentally fragile footballer, If he has to stay at the blues he will regress next year.

massive sook.

 

[De Iulio2Wiggins]

We are. We're offering 13 plus, which is more than Sydney got for Mitchell.

Sydney were in a weak position because they traded the farm for Buddy.

Adelaide are in a weak position because Carlton no longer need pick 13.

It's starting to smell very desperate on your board, maybe you'll be able to paper over the cracks in your midfield with discards like Barlow and squeak into a prelim.

 

[Beer n Skittles]

Like him wanting to be traded wasnt going to come out during trade period.
What flavour koolaid do you prefer?

Info being leaked ≠ choosing Adelaide publicly

 

[Bic]

Crows offering more than Gibbs is worth

If you did, you would have Gibbs.