bulldogs / Melbourne / pies

[stefoid]

pies to the woods seems probable, but what can the pies offer? They need a 3 way.

So:

pies: gain brown, offload pick #17 and Scottland

dees: gain pick #17 and scotland, loose pick 5 and Lamb

dogs: gain pick #5 and lamb


I picked the dees as the 3rd party because they have a need for a hard onballer and the available low pick.

 

[NathanCarroll41]

I'd suggest pick 5 could get Melbourne a fairly handy player, somebody with a little more promise than Mr Scotland.
He'd be a handy pick up at the expense of a Lamb-Wheatley double but not a draft pick that could get an exciting kid.
The difference between pick 5 and 17 is huge these days, no deal!

 

[bluechampion]

Hmmm.

I think the Dees could do better with their no. 5 pick.

Scotland and pick 17 is not satisfactory recompense.
And you get the impression that the Dogs want a 'name' player to compensate for his loss. Someone to show to the sponsors and supporters.

 

[Adrian1]

assuming lamb and scotland have equal trade value why would Melbourne swap pick 5 fo pick 17.

That is the most laughabl suggestion I have ever heard in my life

 

[stefoid]

Perhaps your assumption is wrong? Is Lamb getting a game with you guys? Scotland has played finals footy and is the type of player you need.

 

[stefoid]

Anyway, the details are irrelevent, Im saying this is the type of deal that needs to go through for Brown to become a pie.

 

[Deestroy]

Originally posted by stefoid
dees: gain pick #17 and scotland, loose pick 5 and Lamb

You're kidding right?

 

[rUsTy_mAgPiE]

scotland is going to port anyway

 

[Adrenaline]

Originally posted by rUsTy_mAgPiE
scotland is going to port anyway

In exchange for who?

 

[Yze_Magic]

HAHAHAH

yeah we are gonna give up one of the best young kids in the land for Heath Scotland

hahaha

 

[OldSchool]

Originally posted by stefoid
pies to the woods seems probable, but what can the pies offer? They need a 3 way.

So:

pies: gain brown, offload pick #17 and Scottland

dees: gain pick #17 and scotland, loose pick 5 and Lamb

dogs: gain pick #5 and lamb


I picked the dees as the 3rd party because they have a need for a hard onballer and the available low pick.

Melbourne in a very giving mood are they ?
The Pies would have to give more than that for Browny
I suggest that if the Dees offered the number 5 selection and Lamb to the Doggies it might just be enough to clinch the deal if they wanted Browny.

 

[un_zero42]

What about:
Collingwood: Gain Brown, lose pick 17, Cole & McGough
Essendon: Gain Cole, McGough and Pick 17
Bulldogs: Gain Solomon and Henneman

 

[CowboyFromHell]

Change the draft pick to #20 and you would POSSIBLY have a deal, but even that would be pushing it.

 

[OldSchool]

Originally posted by un_zero42
What about:
Collingwood: Gain Brown, lose pick 17, Cole & McGough
Essendon: Gain Cole, McGough and Pick 17
Bulldogs: Gain Solomon and Henneman

Why not just offer Cole, McGough and the number 17 selection to the Dogs ?

 

[Grendel]

Originally posted by stefoid
pies to the woods seems probable.

??

Meat pies??? PorkPies (like that'd be a first)???... Humble pie after the weekend I'd have thought...

 

[un_zero42]

Originally posted by OldSchool
Why not just offer Cole, McGough and the number 17 selection to the Dogs ?

I think the Dogs will definitely be pushing hard to get a tall out of the Brown trade. Even if it is Henneman.

 

[carringbush]

What about:
Collingwood: Gain Brown, lose pick 17, Cole & McGough
Essendon: Gain Cole, McGough and Pick 17
Bulldogs: Gain Solomon and Henneman


Are you a lunatic. Malthouse is nothing but wraps for richie cole and you can bet your bottom dollar scotland aint going anywhere either. Mcgough has just turned 18 hes staying put

 

[scooter600x]

What about..

Collingwood gain: Brown
Dogs gain: Rocca and pick 17.

Stop rooting around with duds. If you want quality, it costs quality.

 

[Kretiuk #35]

Originally posted by scooter600x
What about..

Collingwood gain: Brown
Dogs gain: Rocca and pick 17.

Stop rooting around with duds. If you want quality, it costs quality.

That wouldn't make sense to a normal Collingwood supporter - Too many numbers & letters

Anyway, your negotiating with duds, you'll gain nothing from their comments

 

[Lestat]

Collingwood gain: Brown
Dogs gain: Rocca and pick 17.

What....your kidding?

You think Brown is worth a Rocca and Pick 17? What drugs are you on mate?

I'll tell you what.....you can shove brown up where the sun don't shine....how does that sound???

 

[Lestat]

That wouldn't make sense to a normal Collingwood supporter - Too many numbers & letters

Anyway, your negotiating with duds, you'll gain nothing from their comments

Lol...thats pretty funny coming from a Bulldogs supporter.

Hows the employment rate going in the western suburbs mate......had any English lessons from Dougie lately.

Don't know.....maybe I should aks him hey.

Need any charity lately.....maybe we can pass over one of our sponsors to you ungrateful bastards again.....hey???

lol....talk about the pot calling the kettle black!

 

[The Doctor]

Originally posted by Lestat
had any English lessons from Dougie lately.

Don't know.....maybe I should aks him hey.

yes you should aks him.

Must have gone to the same English lessons as you.

Idiot

 

[Lestat]

yes you should aks him.

Must have gone to the same English lessons as you.

Idiot

lol....that ones gone right over your head.....you goose! That was my whole point. I didn't think I'd have explain , but for dips*h*i*t*s like yourself.....the use of aks was to highlight the highly rated intelligence of Bulldogs supporters. Of course its not fair to generalise....however, Kretuik 35 didn't seem to mind (you've gotta wonder about the well being of someone that idolises Kretuik....gotta have pity for them).

You sir.....I have no apologies....you must be pretty stupid to not realise that I was having a go.

You must be feeling pretty dumb right about now.

 

[The Doctor]

Originally posted by Lestat
lol....that ones gone right over your head.....you goose! That was my whole point. I didn't think I'd have explain , but for dips*h*i*t*s like yourself.....the use of aks was to highlight the highly rated intelligence of Bulldogs supporters. Of course its not fair to generalise....however, Kretuik 35 didn't seem to mind (you've gotta wonder about the well being of someone that idolises Kretuik....gotta have pity for them).

You sir.....I have no apologies....you must be pretty stupid to not realise that I was having a go.

You must be feeling pretty dumb right about now.

This only further confirms that you are an idiot. Not that it was needed.

Well you know the old saying about arguing with an idiot.

 

[Lestat]

Well you know the old saying about arguing with an idiot.

Agreed....you are bringing me down to your level.

Would you like me to explain that one to you.....before you make yourself look like a goose again